Gransnet forums

News & politics

Now that ISN'T funny.

(65 Posts)
Anne58 Wed 08-Apr-15 13:43:39

BBC Radio 4, World at One, covering the Nigel Farage campaign. Interviewing some people in Dudley, and one chap remarked that he liked Nigel Farage because (and I quote) "He calls a spade a spade" which he quickly followed by saying "That's a joke, by the way"

Ana Wed 08-Apr-15 13:46:01

Well, what's wrong with that, if he was using the phrase as meaning 'down to earth'? Good heavens, did he think someone might think he was being racist...? confused

rosequartz Wed 08-Apr-15 13:48:52

I don't get it confused

Does he mean NF doesn't call a spade a spade?
Like the Australians who call a spade a shovel?

Ana Wed 08-Apr-15 13:55:10

Or have I missed the point and it actually was racist? confused
(Does anyone actually use that word any more to describe a black person?)

merlotgran Wed 08-Apr-15 13:59:14

On the fens a spade is called a digging shovel!

It wasn't racist surely?

jo1book Wed 08-Apr-15 14:00:12

Not in Dudley. They would mean that they believe NF says it like it is!

Galen Wed 08-Apr-15 14:45:29

In Wednesbury (not a million miles fom Dudley) a spade is a bloody shovel.

jo1book Wed 08-Apr-15 14:59:58

Precisely Galen. Just seen the Express & Star headline. Nigel says he will win seats in the Black Country. But, from which Party? Dudley North is Labour, I think. I suspect Labour rank and file relate more to NF than to intellectual socialists like Milliband. Whereas Tory disaffected would turn further to the right.

Anne58 Wed 08-Apr-15 15:26:08

I'm left wondering (if he was really meaning "down to earth") why he then felt the need to add "that's a joke by the way"

amarmai Wed 08-Apr-15 15:34:03

Considering the speaker was referring to NF , it's really stretching to interpret this as non racist.

Elegran Wed 08-Apr-15 15:37:01

I think he couldn't resist the opportunity to sound as though he was being clever with double meanings.

Ana Wed 08-Apr-15 15:49:15

Yes. He did rather ruin the effect by saying it was meant to be a joke...hmm

soontobe Wed 08-Apr-15 15:54:37

<oh crumbs> emotion.
I dont understand this thread either.

I am staying off gransnet for several hours more.

GrannyTwice Wed 08-Apr-15 16:15:46

And again soon wink. wink

rubysong Wed 08-Apr-15 16:23:04

I'm no fan of NF but it wasn't him who used the phrase, it was 'one chap' speaking about him.

Anne58 Wed 08-Apr-15 17:16:24

That's what I said in the OP ruby

loopylou Wed 08-Apr-15 17:21:18

Very confused
Non comprendo
Please don't tell me that phrase is racist......

[givesupandwandersofftowaterplantpots]

soontobe Wed 08-Apr-15 17:24:22

[joinsloopylouwateringplantpots]

Anne58 Wed 08-Apr-15 17:27:55

Thankfully in most places the term is no longer used, but the phrase "spade" was sometimes used to refer to people of colour/negroes/Afro Carribeans etc. It is sometimes thought to sort of relate to the suit "spades" in a deck of cards.

durhamjen Wed 08-Apr-15 17:32:30

Jo1book, I always think of Ukip as being further to the right of Tory.

Ana Wed 08-Apr-15 17:42:05

I thought everyone would know that, phoenix, which is why I didn't elaborate in my previous post.

I was obviously wrong! confused

Juliette Wed 08-Apr-15 17:52:14

First used in the 16th Century, according to Mr.Google.
At least the fatal phrase was uttered in The Black Country and not in the
'people of colour' country.
PC madness yet again.

soontobe Wed 08-Apr-15 17:54:37

May be there are north uk and south uk phrases.
In the county I live in, there are lots of verbal variations in different sections.

I get a bit annoyed, to be honest, that everyone thinks that everyone knows all the different words and phrases.

I shall start a thread!

durhamjen Wed 08-Apr-15 17:58:15

Must be nice to be as innocent as you, soon.

Ariadne Wed 08-Apr-15 17:59:35

Nonsense!

It's not about North and South at all, just about making the effort to understand, reading things carefully, twice if you don't understand, then asking clear questions rather than making wide ranging assumptions about language distribution.

Most language is comprehensible if you make the effort!