Gransnet forums

News & politics

EU - I'm in a quandary

(877 Posts)
Riverwalk Fri 03-Jun-16 08:39:39

I can't be the only one!

I'm minded to vote out - the main reason being the free movement of capital and labour has resulted in a very low-wage economy and zero-hours contracts (gravy train, inefficiency, lack of democracy, vested interests, etc., also play a part).

However, how can I be on the same side as Bozzer, Gove, Fox, Farage et al - I wouldn't normally give them the time of day. Apart from Gisela Stuart I can't think of any politician I'd be remotely connected to.

Surely the Big Beasts in politics, academia & sciences, unions, etc. can't all be wrong?

As I said, a quandary confused

durhamjen Sun 19-Jun-16 21:44:55

www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2016/06/19/what-will-happen-to-the-politics-of-the-uk-post-brexit/

This is interesting. Richard Murphy thinks that Theresa May will take over from Cameron. Help!

granjura Sun 19-Jun-16 21:45:59

Why not? If the Lib Dems had again gained sufficient votes to have a significant number of seats to balance out extremes- the situation may have been very different and the Referendum possibly not called.

varian Sun 19-Jun-16 22:08:06

You are so right Granjura. To make matters worse many of the seats which changed from Libdem to Tory in 2015 were where illegal election expenses are being investigated,

durhamjen Sun 19-Jun-16 22:10:40

It'll soonbe time to make more of that, varian.

granjura Sun 19-Jun-16 22:10:46

it illustrates so well the serious consequenses of a 'protest' vote can have!

durhamjen Sun 19-Jun-16 22:59:35

www.precariouseurope.com/power/europeans-speak-on-the-uk-referendum

Interviews with young people in every country of the EU about Brexit.

JessM Mon 20-Jun-16 06:08:54

Good morning .
Today's referendum news is that Baroness Warsi has defected from Leave to Remain, the second high profile Tory woman to do so (and there are not many high profile Tory women) She cites the xenophobic, lying tactics of the Leave campaign as her reason.
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/eu-referendum-baroness-sayeeda-warsi-defects-from-leave-to-remain-a7090741.html

And UK car manufacturers and others also make the case for Remain.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-36572405

Mamie Mon 20-Jun-16 06:32:17

Plus a letter to the Guardian from Nobel prize-winning economists stating that The UK will be better off if the country remains in the EU.
www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/jun/19/we-nobel-prize-winning-economists-believe-the-uk-is-better-off-in-the-eu

durhamjen Mon 20-Jun-16 12:04:56

theconversation.com/britain-could-be-a-key-global-player-if-it-stays-in-the-eu-60742

This saying that if we vote remain we could be a more important country than Germany in 20 years.

durhamjen Mon 20-Jun-16 12:25:56

Tegan for you. What to do with ridiculous Brexit leaflets.

theconversation.com/rubbish-for-remain-or-bins-for-brexit-how-the-eu-affects-your-garbage-60830

durhamjen Mon 20-Jun-16 12:36:27

This is a podcast about the referendum. Lots of questions answered by university professors, including why on earth are we having this referendum?

theconversation.com/anthill-2-brexit-special-60581

1GrannyWW Mon 20-Jun-16 12:56:44

I know
the Outers promise to use money saved by exit, however much that is, for the NHS, and farmers, and deprived areas of Britain - but I fear there will be a huge financial crisis here. By which I mean a crisis in the banks, hedge funds etc. as, for instance, investors pull out and they lose Euro dealing. So guess what will happen to any £billions saved? Just as last time it will all - and then some- go to prop up the financial sector.

Tegan Mon 20-Jun-16 13:02:34

But the car industry trade body, the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders' (SMMT), warned leaving the EU would increase costs and threaten jobs.

"Remaining will allow the UK to retain the influence on which the unique and successful UK automotive sector depends," said chief executive Mike Hawes.

'Directors at Toyota UK, Vauxhall, Jaguar Land Rover and BMW, as well as from component makers GKN and Magal Engineering, also voiced their support.

Rory Harvey, chairman of Vauxhall, said: "We are part of a fully integrated European company where we benefit from the free movement of goods and people. We believe not to be part of the EU would be undesirable for our business and the sector as a whole."
..and yet the Leave pamphlet states that Vauxhall and Toyota said they will 'stay' in the event of a leave win. This is true in that they aren't planning to leave, but the companies appear to have stated that it will be easier for them if we do stay in the EU. And Unilever [another company mentioned] have written to their employees advising them to vote Remain. So, the pamphlet isn't actually lying but is worded in a way that makes those companies appear to support their campaign. [or am I getting this wrong in some way?]

Tegan Mon 20-Jun-16 13:07:04

They use the word 'could' when it comes to the NHS not 'would'.

granjura Mon 20-Jun-16 13:10:23

Thank you Tegan- surely it is so simple to see. If free movement of goods and people is no longer possible for the big car manufacturers, and the little manufacturing we still have, and high tariffs are slapped on to goods made in the UK- they will just up and go.

One thing that has never been mentionned yet here, I think- is our massive reliance on French and other European companies for energy, electricity, gas, and so on. They just have us on a barrel- we can't do without them to survive. so what happens when they decide top massively up the prices if we leave??? We couldn't say 'stuff you' as we just would not be able to build any stations that would replace them for a VERY very long time! What do we do in the meantime- get candles out and freeze?

durhamjen Mon 20-Jun-16 13:17:35

ukandeu.ac.uk/swots-of-the-uks-membership-of-the-eu/

Tegan Mon 20-Jun-16 13:31:55

Thanks; just read that article confirming what granjura has said but couldn't do a link...

Ana Mon 20-Jun-16 13:41:51

So why hasn't the Remain campaign made much of that aspect, I wonder?

granjura Mon 20-Jun-16 14:08:39

An excellent question Ana. I am indeed surprised as massive reliance on European and Scottish companies, which we simply couldn't avoid - could has a massive impact on our utility bills and industry too, and of course the NHS, Schools, etc.

Tegan Mon 20-Jun-16 14:13:11

'Finally on energy, the poorest households spend three times more of their income on household energy bills than the richest households spend. As long as we are in the EU, we are not allowed to cut VAT on domestic fuel. When we Vote Leave, we will be able to scrap this unfair and damaging tax.'
..from Gisela Stuart. So we have it in black and white that this will be implemented in the event of a leave win. Although the words 'will be able to' don't mean that they will be. Ana the answer to your question is 'I don't know'.

Jalima Mon 20-Jun-16 15:14:58

https://www.myutilitygenius.co.uk/suppliers/
A list of the UK's energy suppliers; if anyone wants to find out who owns what I presume you can find out by clicking on the link to each company.

GillT57 Mon 20-Jun-16 15:25:11

Tegan this statement about scrapping vat on domestic fuel is similar to the 'pledge' made by Pritti Patel to spend some of the saved money on the NHS. As the Radio 4 interviewer so correctly asked her 'On whose authority are you making this promise?'. It is all very well listing the 'coulds' and 'shoulds' but unless the Brexit spokespeople are the Chancellor next time it is highly unlikely.

Jalima Mon 20-Jun-16 17:22:37

Just when I thought I had made up my mind:

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3649655/How-Brussels-spends-money-grows-trees-devastating-dispatch-reveal-Eurocrats-live-life-staggering-excess-10-000-earn-PM-s-150-000-taking-decisions-affect-lives-secret.html

So - just what surprises await us if we Remain?

Those of a nervous disposition need not follow the link
Those who despise the Daily Mail need not follow the link

obieone Mon 20-Jun-16 17:35:07

That is part of what I cannot understand about Remain. They are largely the ones who say more, much more about elitism, cronyism, fatcats, corporate greed, and yet we all know that the EU is a gravy train for many.

Jalima Mon 20-Jun-16 17:41:12

I know, it is a conundrum, isn't it obieone

People who have been very vexed about elitism, cronyism, fatcats, corporate greed,, TTIP, etc etc are all for remaining in this group of disparate nations with bloated, overpaid bureaucracy making unaccountable decisions that affect all our lives.

I shall talk myself back to Brexit by the end of the day. hmm And that is nothing to do with immigration or veering towards the right wing.