Gransnet forums

News & politics

Brexit and power to the people

(437 Posts)
whitewave Fri 14-Oct-16 08:18:55

Really interesting court case and day 1 of "The Royal Prerogative"

It basically boils down to whether a minister -in this case Amino 1 - can remove rights established by an act of parliament.

It raises questions of "fundamental constitutional importance about the limits of the power of the executive"

Pannick, QC for the challenger, said " this court is not concerned with the political wisdom of withdrawal" "The government was wrong to suggest the legal challenge was merely camouflage to prevent Brexit"

Pannick's client the court was advised had again received threats, abuse and insults.

A further QC - representing the people
Argued" the constitution of our parliamentary democracy, unwritten as it is , is predicated on the sovereignty of parliament and the courts working as arbiter. Notification of withdrawal leads to the removal of the rights of UK citizens.
Chambers QC argued that the referendum did not replace the UK system of parliamentary democracy"
If the government triggered A50 it would be setting itself up as "de facto legislature"
This is a case about what is legally required, not what is legally expedient.

Good ain't it?

durhamjen Sun 06-Nov-16 14:19:23

You reckon the North East will vote Conservative, do you, roses?

What do you base that on?

rosesarered Sun 06-Nov-16 14:20:57

Labour being out of touch with the Labour voters.

durhamjen Sun 06-Nov-16 16:04:12

There are other parties.
However, Labour aren't out of touch with Labour voters in my area. You shouldn't believe everything you read in the Sun or the Times, or even the DM.

MaizieD Sun 06-Nov-16 17:25:06

I've been out all afternoon. I'm glad to see that we seem to have established that the judiciary is, quite rightly, an unelected, non political, arm of the constitution.

I said your post was nonsensical, POGS, because you seemed to be confusing the judiciary with the House of Lords.

daphnedill Sun 06-Nov-16 18:27:08

@Jalima

Something was wrong with the sound on the video, but I watched it and somehow I don't think Labour will be winning it any time soon, although I looked up the 2010 results and the combined Labour/LD vote was higher than the Conservatives.

I was thinking of the constitutional issue. There was a majority for Remain and Rees-Mogg talks about stuffing the Lords with 1000 new members. What about the 'will of the people'?

I'm afraid I find Jess Phillips incredibly irritating and I can't really take what she says seriously either. A dinner party with her and Rees-Mogg would be my idea of hell!

daphnedill Sun 06-Nov-16 18:28:44

@dj

Well, I suppose the North Sea might turn to wine! grin grin (Just as likely that the North East will vote Conservative - UKIP is more likely.)

rosesarered Sun 06-Nov-16 19:01:12

If the voters in the North East who voted to Leave, feel that only the Conservatives Will deliver on Brexit, then if there was a snap GE, they may well vote that way.Voting UKIP will not help at that stage.Labour certainly got them wrong about Leaving the EU after all.At the moment, it's anyones guess as to what would happen.

rosesarered Sun 06-Nov-16 19:02:16

So save some of that wine for me! grin

daphnedill Sun 06-Nov-16 19:40:45

The Conservative Party itself is split on Brexit. Even some of those who are supportive don't like the way things are heading and they don't like being left out in the cold by May and her little band.

It would be interesting to know what people in the North East (and anywhere else for that matter) though Brexit would actually mean. If it's true that it was partially a protest vote against a public school-educated, London-centric elite, who are as distant as any Brussels bureaucrat, I can't honestly see the Conservatives picking up many votes in the area.

POGS Sun 06-Nov-16 20:14:37

Maizie d. 17.25

I will respond to your further post to myself by using your own kind words to me yesterday.

MaizieD Sat 05-Nov-16 12:31:14
I'm not taking it any further, POGS. You've already had my answer. You not liking it and repeating the question doesn't make me change my mind. It didn't work when my children tried the same tactics, either.

whitewave Sun 06-Nov-16 20:18:09

daph that's one reason that May will be reluctant (apart from quite a few others) to call an early election. It would expose the huge rifts that there are in the Tory party.

MaizieD Sun 06-Nov-16 20:23:35

I wasn't actually asking you a question, POGS. My response which you quote was to being asked the same question over and over again.

In my post of 17.25 I was merely explaining why I'd said your post was nonsensical. Didn't really expect a reply...

Jalima Sun 06-Nov-16 22:40:09

ddill I didn't put on the link with any serious intent, just found it amusing. - mildly

durhamjen Sun 06-Nov-16 22:47:25

Try watching this, daphne, if you haven't seen it before.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEC0R_71ozU

It's Owen Jones talking to Michael Sheen about why people voted Brexit. It could be similar in the North East.
Although people in South Shields might have voted Brexit, they still identify as Labour. I was surprised in the British Legion Club that only two others admitted to voting Tory.

Jalima Sun 06-Nov-16 23:04:54

Why would you be surprised that only 2 people in the RBL club voted Tory? confused

Jalima Sun 06-Nov-16 23:09:12

I would be surprised if everyone in our conservative club voted Tory.

After all, the beer is a lot cheaper in there.

daphnedill Sun 06-Nov-16 23:16:38

Talking of Trump, Sheen said 'what he has tapped into is still there'. Very very true! That's what I meant on the other thread about the voters' motivation still being there, even if UKIP implodes. Love Sheen's description of UKIP as 'a bunch of monkeys'.

From what I can understand, Sheen talks sense. I think it's very sad, because I really don't think people from places like Port Talbot, the North East, Stoke or any of the other 'abandoned' places are going to benefit at all.

durhamjen Sun 06-Nov-16 23:16:58

Because I thought all the Tories would be in there, as they don't have a Conservative Club for cheap beer. He met the Tories in an ice cream parlour.

durhamjen Sun 06-Nov-16 23:21:02

Sorry, that was to Jalima, not you, daphne.

Yes, I agree. Michael Sheen has obviously thought very carefully about things, more than a lot of those who commented on the video.
Have you heard that Clinton has been cleared of any illegal stuff in the latest lot of emails. Of course, Trump says it shows it's rigged. Hopefully people will see through that.

durhamjen Sun 06-Nov-16 23:59:22

Did you hear Farage having to admit to Gina Miller that the referendum vote was only advisory?

whitewave Mon 07-Nov-16 07:04:00

I thought he came close to inciting riot yesterday. It wouldnt take much to encourage a particular element

durhamjen Mon 07-Nov-16 10:31:24

And then this report comes out today. I think some of us knew it, but it's good to have it confirmed that the Tories set out to destroy the working class.

www.theguardian.com/business/2016/nov/06/half-of-uk-deficit-is-result-of-job-destruction-in-older-industrial-areas

Obviously they did not realise what would happen to the workers once the jobs had gone.

durhamjen Mon 07-Nov-16 13:15:44

Could this be another court case for Brexiteers?
Keir Starmer used to be the DPP. I wonder if he will be asked for his view.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/nov/07/brexit-cps-considers-complaint-that-leave-campaigns-misled-voters

annodomini Mon 07-Nov-16 13:43:02

He was on the Today programme on Radio 4 this morning, defending the independence of the judiciary and the sovereignty of Parliament.

granjura Mon 07-Nov-16 18:35:43

There was never ever any doubt that those promises were fraudulent and broke British Law - so glad the CPS agrees.

It is illegal under the 1983 Representation of the People Act to use "any fraudulent device or contrivance" to have an "undue influence" on voters.