English Scots for YES

Nothing has been said about those who voted YES for independence and yes for Brexit. I cannot see any logic in wanting out of the Union yet also wishing to remain in the EEC who override our laws. That is not independence.

lot of interesting comments sadly some who still believe everything they see in main stream media ,it should perhaps be pointed out that in Scotland neither the queen nor parliament is sovereign....and its the people who will decide ...as we dcided to send 56 MP's to westminster whose core policis independence.Esspee Westminster with 84% english MP's makes most of our laws,the EU somwhere around 7% as an independent country in the EU we will have exactly the same rights as all those other independent nations ...France,Spain.Portugal,Germany etc etc etc,,So do you believe that none of those nor any of the otherEU countries are "independent"? The original post was about English born yes for indy,here are some comments from their page: I am a 60 yr old Englishman who came to Scotland 35 years at the age of 25 and has worked everywhere from Port Patrick in the Borders to Stromness in Orkney and holidayed from Kinlochbervie, to Barra to Ecclefechan. I am a member of the SNP and a supporter of Scottish independence. In all my time here I have never experienced any anti-English animosity.
The Scots are not anti-English they are anti-bawbag.
My advise is, if you are English, behave yourself, don't act like a bawbag, switch off bawbag, stay out of full-on bawbag mode and you will be made as welcome as if you were family.

Just don't be a bawbag, it's that
simple.
Unlike · Reply · 28 · 2 hrs · Edited
Dave Beecroft
Dave Beecroft You mirror my own experience D George. I came in 1982 and have always felt welcome. Wasn't initially a nationalist, I still believed in the Labour Party at the beginning but I'm wiser now and, like you, an SNP member.
Like · Reply · 6 · 7 hrs
Gail Hughes
Gail Hughes Where I used to live, in a tourist area in the West of Scotland, we had a couple who bought a hotel. From the time he arrived to the time they sold up and left six years later, the bloke found fault with everything. Other businesses, employees, the local customers, the tourist board, everyone.

Hardly a week went by without him having an article or a letter in the local paper going on about how everybody else was doing it all wrong. Nearly every of his complaints started out with, "Where I came from in England we..." Not surprisingly he was frequently asked, "If it was so good why don't you back there?" He eventually did, because of all the anti-English abuse, as he saw it.

The reality was that it wasn't where he came from that was the issue, it was the way he consistently told everyone how superior it was. He was guilty of "Bawbaggery" to the highest degree.

Now I'm bowing out ,it would appear that ondependence is fantastic for all countries EXCEPT Scotland.Malta it seems had similar opposition when they aspired to be independent at first in the 1950's.Yet on the 50th anniversary of that becoming reality Your Prince William flew out to celebrate it with them .Malta has a population ten times smaller than ours and none of our resources and they seem to be doing just fine...Scotland will with independence PROSPER.

I am English and I really don't need your advice thank you paddyann and I don't need to be to be told to " behave myself" either. What a cheek !

and what the hells a bawbag when it's at home?

Scotland does not meet the economic criteria to join EU on its own. Its so annoying and daft to even think of another Scottish referendum.

Paddyann, I was rather tired when writing last night and expressed myself poorly.
I am Scottish. I voted for Independence, have voted SNP since I was 18. I voted for Brexit as I expected the EEC to be a trading partnership but it has evolved into a bureaucratic gravy train for career politicians (the Kinnocks are the worst example I can think of), it overrides our laws and ruins our industry (fishing for example). In Scotland we welcome people who wish to become Scottish but are forced by the EEC to protect the human rights of those who wish only to take from us and/or destroy our way of life and even do us harm. I want Scotland to be truly independent - a nation again, completely in charge of our own destiny.

Could I also suggest that your rants do more harm than good and that using derogatory terms like bawbag lowers the tone just for the sake of showing off that you have mastered a Scottish sweary word.

Yes please - what's a Bawbag? I have a feeling it's not very nice!

As to Scotland remaining in the EU, I understood that this can only happen if Scotland becomes independent before Brexit. If we divide into two nations whilst both countries are still members. The same would be true if Catalonia left Spain, one country dividing within the EU.

But if Scotland votes for independence after Brexit. She will have left the union along with the rest of us and will have to re-apply.

With you Esspee. Out of the EU - and the UK - Scotland could be completely independent and could have a new more equal link with England and Wales. (Northern Ireland would be a different problem!)

Bawbag is a derogatory term used for an annoying, useless or stupid person. Literal translation is scrotum.

Thank you for the definition Esspee

You are way out of order Paddyann and really nasty too. Why do you think it's okay to use such a vile word towards the English ? Imagine if the shoe were on the other foot and an English poster used such a term to describe the Scottish ?

Oooo, I thought it was rude. That's very, very rude!

If an English person had said something that nasty s/he'd be banned from GN!

Please don't over react it is not that bad a word, it is usually used in the way you might refer to someone as a "pain in the *rse"

I am not overreacting at all Esspee and wouldn't waste my energy reporting such an ignoramus to GNHQ . But NfkDumpling is right if an English person had used such a term towards a Scottish poster they most definitely would be reported.

I am not sure how calling anyone an "annoying, useless,stupid, scrotum" could be anything other than a "bad" word.

How about if I had called all Scottish people "annoying, useless, stupid, pr*cks" I am sure they would be VERY offended indeed.

Which I am not btw. I am really fond of my (Virtual ) Scottish friends

I think that as Scotland does most of it's trade with the rest of the UK and not EU countries ( not to the same extent) what on earth is the point of being in the EU for them? The EU won't really want an independent Scotland anyway, can anyone see Spain agreeing that?
Of course, Sturgeon knows this, and will simply use it as a clobbering tool to try and get even more goodies from Westminster, although she may well get her bluff called.

How about if I had called all Scottish people "annoying, useless, stupid, pr*cks" I am sure they would be VERY offended indeed.

paddyann didn't use the term about all English people, though.

To me, it seems that before another referendum, sorting out the answers to the questions that were left vague in 2014 (currency, pensions etc) is far more important than in/out the EU.

I will not get involved in this argument but would genuinely like to be given a couple of examples of what roses means by 'even more goodies from Westminster'.

I beg to differ FarNorth and I quote ;

My advice is if you are English etc.

Actually can't be bothered to quote this bile. But do go back and read it .

Are you a Scot living in Scotland mcem? If you are an SNP supporter you will naturally be annoyed by my comment.I meant that Sturgeon will be wanting more powers and concessions given to Scotland in return ( maybe) for not demanding another referendum on breaking away from the UK, or for not going after EU membership.

Scotland is part of the United Kingdom
Malta was a colony of the British Empire
A totally different status


Some very personal stories in your post paddy and I am sure there must be some heartfelt stories which express views from the opposite point of view.
The fervent 'English Scottish Nationalists' sound a bit like the newly converted or like people who have given up smoking and hate anyone else smoking! Zealots

(I used to be one! However I don't know anyone who smokes these days.)

Can you imagine somebody who is now a fervent English ( living in Scotland) SNP supporter and has just given up smoking.

paddyann are you English by birth?

Ps there is a thread on giving up smoking if anyone needs support
I mean cigarettes, not smoke coming out of ears.