Gransnet forums

News & politics

Brexit all done and dusted?

(857 Posts)
Cindersdad Sun 02-Apr-17 16:47:13

As an arch REMOANER I for one (of many) will not simply roll over and say that is that. As things progress at the very least parliament must ensure that the country does not Brexit in a bad way because of "The Will of the People". So many lies were told by both side at the time of referendum that when the full facts come to light a re-think should be considered.

I have yet to hear a sound reason for voting LEAVE. Of course the EU is far from perfect but we are better trying to change it from within than sniping from outside. A general election or second referendum before the point of absolute no return.

I happen to be visiting Brussels on an educational trip after Easter so until then I will put up and shut up unless really provoked.

POGS Sat 22-Apr-17 16:14:22

WW

Is it possible to ask 'who' or 'what' said that.

I am thinking Gina Miller , the activist.

MargaretX Sat 22-Apr-17 19:05:52

I travel by plane from Frankfurt to Manchester very often and the plane isoften half full of engineers coming and going checking machines their firms have sold etc etc.
I over hear them at the check in on the way back discussing their cuatomers in the UK.
With this kind of trade which the UK needs there must be freedom of movement. Sometimes they have spare parts with them.
In the end TM must give in or it will be a disaster. Brexit will not bring back an old England with only white faces. You could also wish for Elvis to return to entertain us.

rosesarered Sat 22-Apr-17 19:10:08

You would need to go back a long way for that ( all white faces) but we have a long history here ( rather better than Germany) of accepting all races and religions and cultures.
T May will not , I hope 'give in' ( whatever that means)

whitewave Sat 22-Apr-17 19:22:02

Blimey that was a bit below the belt rose

nigglynellie Sat 22-Apr-17 19:24:37

Our record is better than most of Europe going back a very long way, (mists of time) so I don't think anyone wants to go back to white faces only, whenever that was?!

whitewave Sat 22-Apr-17 19:29:14

Electoral Commision is investigating Leave.EU referendum spending. Farage and Banks are understood to have worked with Cambridge Analytical which in turn is linked to Brietbart -Steve Banon. The Cambridge Analyrica involvement was not declared.

varian Sat 22-Apr-17 19:39:24

If Banks and co are found guilty of cheating does that mean that the result of the advisory referendum will be declared null andvoid?

Ana Sat 22-Apr-17 19:41:41

Oh, you all live in hope, don't you...? Talk about clutching at straws.

daphnedill Sat 22-Apr-17 21:49:11

I don't live in hope. I follow what's going on and find it all fascinating. It's instructive about how people behave. Of course, I'll do my bit to prevent this suicide, but I doubt if it will make any difference.

I just wonder how students will in the future answer the questions "Explain how an unpopular government became so successful" or "Explain the downfall of the UK". I expect it will keep academics occupied for decades or centuries. Meanwhile, the majority of UK citizens will suffer, because they'll be players in the downfall.

As ever, I'll do my best to survive on a personal level.

daphnedill Sat 22-Apr-17 21:52:16

What on earth are you implying rosesarered? Surely you don't live in a time warp. hmm I have a horrible feeling that you are.

daphnedill Sat 22-Apr-17 21:57:32

MargaretX Of course there must be freedom of movement. To think otherwise is madness.

Hmm...I wish I had any confidence in the "will of the people". As far as I'm concerned, they really are mad and I can perfectly well understand why the rest of the EU seems to think they're mad.

I just wish that that a couple of percent hadn't dragged me into this collective madness.

whitewave Sat 22-Apr-17 21:58:35

Yes dd I actually think that this will be a fascinating period in future. Especially if you look at the bigger picture. Living through it won't be so brilliant though, and I worry for our grandchildren. But historically it will be such a good period to study.

daphnedill Sat 22-Apr-17 21:58:40

No Ana it's people who think that leaving the EU will result in something better who are clutching at straws.

daphnedill Sat 22-Apr-17 22:01:26

Oh yes Ww. It will rank alongside the the French Revolution, the English Civil War, WW2 as significant turning points in history.

rosesarered Sat 22-Apr-17 22:04:48

So dd everybody ( over 17 million) are 'mad' are they? Because they voted to Leave and you didn't..... can't see the logic.

rosesarered Sat 22-Apr-17 22:07:27

Everybody will have to get used to us leaving the EU Time to leave all this bitterness behind.Whichever Party gets in at the GE will implement Brexit.

rosesarered Sat 22-Apr-17 22:08:21

No idea what you are saying dd I was making a comment and not implying anything.

Cindersdad Sat 22-Apr-17 22:29:20

While I was away in Brussels hearing the EU side of the argument St. Theresa of Bray asked us to give her support and celebrated by making herself a style icon with the "Mmy Bob Cut". Anyway enough of this frivolity because we now have chance to turn the tables. If enough of us vote Lib Dem, Labour or SNP Brexit can be stopped in its tracks.

The Election may go the way TM hopes because of the FPTP system but the overall vote count, though tainted by tactical voting, will show what the country really thinks.

If it what wasn't so serious it would be unbelievable. World politics bereft of leadership - a worrying situation.

daphnedill Sat 22-Apr-17 22:32:16

Ah well! I'm not persauasive enough to persuade everybody to use their brains.

Sorry you don't have the ability to understand my logic.

Kakistracy rules! What a sad legacy to leave to our forebears.

NfkDumpling Sun 23-Apr-17 10:26:16

With the French elections happening I've been paying a little more attention to that country - I generally only watch the BBC news and they only report explosions. I'd been under the impression that it was doing well economically. Up there with Germany. But they're not. (I was surprised how much anti-EU sentiment there is.). So who exactly, other than Germany, is doing well out of the EU? Certainly not Greece, Italy, Spain, Belgium, or after initial benefits and building schemes, the Eastern European countries who're training doctors and dentists who then (along with most of their working population) move west.

NfkDumpling Sun 23-Apr-17 10:30:11

(I am genuinely interested by the way. I don't spend too much time watching or thinking about politics as my life seems to fill with other miscellany and I'm a bear of very little brain. I miss a lot and reading all your arguments and points of view is very interesting.
But I still think we should come out of the EU.)

Jalima1108 Sun 23-Apr-17 10:37:06

Ah well! I'm not persauasive enough to persuade everybody to use their brains.

Sorry you don't have the ability to understand my logic.

Perhaps people have enough 'brains' and 'logic' to think differently to you, though daphnedill.
Your logic has led you to believe that someone who thinks differently to you must be wrong.
Their logic may lead them to believe that their way is the right way and yours is wrong.

Who is to say?

Jalima1108 Sun 23-Apr-17 10:45:12

If enough of us vote Lib Dem, Labour or SNP Brexit can be stopped in its tracks.

So 'Saint Jeremy of Islington' et al will reverse a democratic vote then Cindersdad? Even though we all know that he probably voted for Brexit and has been consistently anti-EU for many years?
Then the SNP will lead the Scots into independence and leave the English and the Welsh with the results of their anti-democratic actions.

I cannot follow the logic of that argument at all.

Fitzy54 Sun 23-Apr-17 10:59:41

There is not going to be any reversing out of Brexit, even if Labour win outright. I would very much like a viable trade deal with the EU, but to get that the EU will have to soften its stance on free movement. I'm starting to see that as a possibility. I think TM, with new intake of moderate MPs, might meet the EUhalfway with some sort of deal on immigration. But all just hopeful speculation on my part really.

Welshwife Sun 23-Apr-17 11:08:44

The UK politicians do not really understand the rules of the EU or the ECJ despite being members of both for years. The exception to this is Nick Clegg being really European and working there for years and Ken Clarke has probably made it his business to understand the rules but no one is listening the them.