Gransnet forums

News & politics

Brexit all done and dusted?

(857 Posts)
Cindersdad Sun 02-Apr-17 16:47:13

As an arch REMOANER I for one (of many) will not simply roll over and say that is that. As things progress at the very least parliament must ensure that the country does not Brexit in a bad way because of "The Will of the People". So many lies were told by both side at the time of referendum that when the full facts come to light a re-think should be considered.

I have yet to hear a sound reason for voting LEAVE. Of course the EU is far from perfect but we are better trying to change it from within than sniping from outside. A general election or second referendum before the point of absolute no return.

I happen to be visiting Brussels on an educational trip after Easter so until then I will put up and shut up unless really provoked.

varian Sun 23-Apr-17 11:50:42

Do not forget that the majority of sitting MPs actually voted to Remain, but all of the Tories, with the honourable exception of Ken Clarke, and a lot of Labour MPs were bullied into triggering Article 50, against their better judgement. It looks like their political careers were more important to them than what they honestly judged to be in the best interests of their constituencies and the country.

Let's hope we can get rid of the Brexiters and elect MPs with integrity who will stand up for the 63% of the electorate who did not vote for any kind of Brexit, let alone a hard Brexit.

The Liberal Democrats will not acquiese in giving away our place in the world and our grandchildren's future.

whitewave Sun 23-Apr-17 11:53:06

varian. Miller - what do you think of her idea?

varian Sun 23-Apr-17 12:06:03

I think Gina Miller's intention is to give voters information in relation to each constituency that will help identify the candidates who will strongly oppose hard Brexit and have the best chance of winning.

This information should help many voters make the best choice, although the FPTP voting system is still a huge challenge to evercome.

The more LibDem MPs elected, the better the outcome, although if you lived in Ken Clarke's patch you might support him or vote for Caroline Lucas in Brighton. There will be other places where the best choice could be a Labour MP who is neither a Brexiter nor a Corbynite.

As I understand it, she says she would then hope that the final deal after negotiations would be put to the vote in Parliament with the option of staying in the EU - i.e. it would be a meaningful vote, not just a choice of bad deal or worse deal (WTO rules).

Do remember that the legal expert who draughted Article 50 has stated clearly that it IS revocable.

whitewave Sun 23-Apr-17 12:10:39

Yes I've always understood that it is revocable from reading A50. It seems sensible to me if the alternative is to shoot ourselves in the foot.

Welshwife Sun 23-Apr-17 12:38:29

The view from the EU

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/apr/22/dont-believe-theresa-may-election-wont-change-brexit?CMP=share_btn_link

MawBroon Sun 23-Apr-17 12:43:34

blush?? daphnedill
Are "forebears" not ancestors??

Kakistracy rules! What a sad legacy to leave to our forebears

whitewave Sun 23-Apr-17 12:57:01

welsh just read the article sad

Fitzy54 Sun 23-Apr-17 13:24:32

I have also just read it. Much of it makes sense, but I thought his reference to TMs "tough negotiating red lines" was a bit rich. As far as I can make out the EUs negotiating position is nothing but red lines!

whitewave Sun 23-Apr-17 13:46:32

No fitz the EU has been running this system with modification since WW11. The rules are what they are. May is trying to introduce something entirely different.

Jalima1108 Sun 23-Apr-17 14:34:40

Yes, we leave a legacy to our heirs who could possibly also be our descendants.

Well, that is the logical thing to do!

Kakistracy rules! it will do if Corbyn ever became PM with his bunch of merry women.

varian Sun 23-Apr-17 14:45:35

I've not noticed any of Corbyn's bunch of merry women looking very merry recently - certainly not Diane Abbot or Emily Thornberry who keep getting wheeled out to defend the indefensible and explain the inexplicable.

daphnedill Sun 23-Apr-17 15:19:04

You're right Maw. Ooops! I was obviously tired (my excuse anyway). It was probably one of my dud edits, when I change the sentence round,but confuse myself. Doh!

There's no way that Corbyn will be PM, so I don't think anybody needs worry about that. It concerns me far more that the Conservatives have a huge majority and won't be challenged on anything - Brexit related or otherwise. At least one prediction is that the Conservatives will win at least 10 seats in Scotland.

Ukip is practically dead and there's evidence that Ukip supporters are now supporting the Conservatives, so May can't become too soft. Most of them came from the Cons in the first place, but some formerly voted Labour. That's one of the reasons the Cons are now polling so high. The Conservatives are losing some of their more centrist supporters to the LibDems, especially the ones who voted Remain.

Miller's aim is to keep the Conservative majority low.

whitewave Sun 23-Apr-17 15:53:17

I thought her aim was to support MPs of any flavour who are willing to stand up and be counted if they thought that a particular area of Brexit would cause severe damage to the UK?

durhamjen Sun 23-Apr-17 15:56:31

I know who will agree with this man.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/apr/23/tony-blair-vote-tory-or-lib-dem-where-they-are-open-minded-on-brexit

stillaliveandkicking Sun 23-Apr-17 18:20:15

Mores to the point now Durhamjen, why do you want to be in the EU. Instead of constantly throwing up links to this and that. Tell me why?

stillaliveandkicking Sun 23-Apr-17 18:21:56

In your own words too rather than all this "armchair" politics that you seem to love. Keep it simple due to me being a normal working class lass.

whitewave Sun 23-Apr-17 18:26:05

That's told you dj grin

rosesarered Sun 23-Apr-17 18:32:24

And it would be nice if durhamjen told us.

whitewave Sun 23-Apr-17 18:34:38

Blimey rose if you don't know by now I would worry about your short and long term memory -you are always keen to bung in your two pennyworth to dj

rosesarered Sun 23-Apr-17 18:34:53

Yes varian Emily Thornberry is getting wheeled out all the time.

nigglynellie Sun 23-Apr-17 18:35:52

Hear, hear![anticipation!]

rosesarered Sun 23-Apr-17 18:36:24

And you are not backward in coming forward yourself ww grin and most of us like our 'two pennyworth' on here ( or had you not noticed?)

stillaliveandkicking Sun 23-Apr-17 18:38:44

grin Love a strong woman.

whitewave Sun 23-Apr-17 18:40:01

Of course I'm not - that's what a forum is about. Yes I had noticed that's why I was surprised at your remark.

durhamjen Sun 23-Apr-17 18:47:16

CBA, saaki.
If you don't know by now why I want us to be in the EU, you never will believe anything I say.