Gransnet forums

News & politics

How to vote tactically (spreadsheet)

(347 Posts)
Grannyknot Fri 21-Apr-17 16:28:15

Interesting how t'innernet can be applied to most things these days - someone has made a spreadsheet and put it online:

docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/19_yf4RL133fBKscvSbID4eRKwztzY9KSI_2BMaI1bU8/htmlview?usp=embed_facebook&sle=true#

varian Mon 24-Apr-17 17:45:40

A lot of people who feel like you, Grannyof11 have looked at all the parties and decide to join the Liberal Democrats - over 12,000 new members bringing the total to over 100,000!

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-39694417

durhamjen Mon 24-Apr-17 17:47:47

It costs to put up candidates. That's why there are no Green party candidates in many constituencies, because they do not have the sort of financial backing that other parties have.

I suppose you could say the Green party is encouraging tactical voting by only putting up candidates where they think they could come second.

Lazigirl Mon 24-Apr-17 18:11:52

I agree varian that FPTP is undemocratic and there are many who feel as I do that their vote just doesn't count in their constituency, and some smug MPs in safe seats don't even have to try. I could not bring myself to abstain, or waste my vote so tactical voting is my only (faint) hope.

durhamjen Mon 24-Apr-17 18:38:10

Here's a constituency to vote tactically.

www.theweek.co.uk/general-election-2017/83869/womens-equality-partys-sophie-walker-vs-conservative-mp-philip-davies

It'll get rid of an MP who holds women and parliament in contempt.

GillT57 Mon 24-Apr-17 18:40:10

Agreed Lazigirl I most certainly will not abstain, I will vote tactically, and as a last resort, comfort myself with the thought that I did my best with an unfair system. It is just so exasperating living with a smug, safe, lazy MP who does not represent the majority of his constituents ( he is staunch Brexit, majority by far are remainers). So much for local representation.

whitewave Mon 24-Apr-17 18:49:53

Let's hope everyone else thinks like you gii and he gets the boot- what a glorious result!!

rosesarered Mon 24-Apr-17 20:33:26

Yes Gill but no doubt there will be a smug safe lazy MP somewhere else who is a staunch Remainer in a mainly Brexit constituency grin and maybe he will get the boot too!

durhamjen Mon 24-Apr-17 22:10:42

For those who think that Labour don't cost their promises.

twitter.com/LabourEoin/status/856151105323106304/photo/1

GillT57 Tue 25-Apr-17 17:30:16

Indeed Rosesared and I don't have a problem with that. Smug lazy MPs of any party should be challenged, and should be representing the majority of their constituents.

whitewave Tue 25-Apr-17 20:15:00

It appears that this idea of tactical voting is gaining momentum. The BBC is reporting the move by the broad left to corporate in trying to stop the Tories.

whitewave Tue 25-Apr-17 20:44:53

Cooperate!

durhamjen Tue 25-Apr-17 21:29:48

That's what I thought you meant, whitewave.
Here's a list of MPs that Open Britain want to save or not.

labourlist.org/2017/04/labour-dominates-the-list-of-mps-which-open-britain-aims-to-save-on-june-8/

I notice that Kate Hoey has left the group.

whitewave Tue 25-Apr-17 21:33:38

Yes there's that as well as voting tactically in marginals. So where there is a small majority in a Tory seat then it would be a good idea for the broad left to ensure those supporting the broad left and want to keep out the Tories to identify who to vote for. The Greens are keen and writing to various other party members.

durhamjen Tue 25-Apr-17 21:42:53

I notice that Caroline Lucas was on that list of MPs to be saved. I would have thought she didn't need that.

durhamjen Tue 25-Apr-17 22:39:06

theconversation.com/a-progressive-alliance-is-a-once-in-a-generation-chance-that-must-be-taken-in-election-2017-76604

durhamjen Tue 25-Apr-17 23:47:09

A new website that might be worth looking at.

www.progressivepulse.org/

Started by people who read taxresearch.

durhamjen Wed 26-Apr-17 07:41:19

Tactical voting in order to keep out the Tories is a brave thing to do, and requires a lot of negotiation.
It's the sensible thing to do for anyone who believes in PR, and does not want a permanent Tory government.
Easy for me to say, as my tactical vote is for Labour.

whitewave Wed 26-Apr-17 07:56:59

And mine. Next door is Green

daphnedill Wed 26-Apr-17 08:18:49

dj Tactical voting is up to the individual and doesn't require any negotiation. It's what loads of people have been doing for years anyway.

A progressive alliance is something different. That's when a party without any realistic chance of winning agrees not to field a candidate and extra canvssers, etc are sent to a seat. There have been a couple so far. I think Vauxhall is one of them. I think the Labour Party in Jeremy Hunt's constituency is deciding whether to drop out. JH has a 24,000 majority, so it's going to be difficult, but impossible if the opposition is split. I can't remember where the other one is, but I think it involves the Greens, who will probably be relieved to save their deposit.

It's easy for me too. I'll vote for my preferred candidate, because it won't make any difference.

TBH, it's like using a bucket to bail out the Titanic. Labour are forecast to lose 100+ seats. All tactical voting and/or a progressive alliance will do is possibly reduce a Conservative landslide by a few seats. The Conservatives are going to have a blank cheque to do whatever they like, so it's a question of damage limitation. There aren't many seats where individual votes even matter.

It wouldn't be a surprise if there's a new left of centre party ready for 2022.

whitewave Wed 26-Apr-17 08:38:27

It appears that we are facing a once in a lifetime swing to the right, and as you rightly say dd all we can do is try to mitigate the disaster where and how we can.

Brexit with no vote, and a possible cliff edge will be over and done with by the next election.
We will see our living standards dropping and the NHS privatised. No recognition will be given to the political centre - May will end up looking like a dictator.

The one ray of light is that as the Buddhists understand, nothing stays the Saale, everything changes. I shall cling on to that.

whitewave Wed 26-Apr-17 08:39:11

Nothing stays the same!

Lazigirl Wed 26-Apr-17 09:57:14

The Buddhist mantra is one that gives me hope too whitewave. Sadly for the moment we will end up having one party state, which will in effect be a dictatorship. We can't criticise Turkey then! It is crucial for a healthy democracy that there is a strong opposition for checks and balances.

jimmyRFU Wed 26-Apr-17 10:16:02

at the end of the day there's not one party of any use. I've been brought up in a Labour environment and voted that way no matter what. Difficult decision this time because you want your MP to be doing what benefits your area and s/he may be Tory.

whitewave Wed 26-Apr-17 10:19:05

So the Tory will benefit your NHS? Your schools? Your children's opportunity of choice, your day to day life?

stillaliveandkicking Wed 26-Apr-17 21:11:35

tactical voting = just as weak as the people that do this.