Gransnet forums

News & politics

Corbyns Momentum

(1001 Posts)
Anniebach Sun 22-Oct-17 08:49:58

www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/oct/20/labour-mp-clive-lewis-apologises-for-get-on-your-knees-comment

This as the Labour Party conference , a momentum fringe meeting.

Corbyn attended Momentum fringe invites but turned down Friends of Israel invite.

Very Donald Trump isn't it?

Jalima1108 Sun 10-Dec-17 11:31:09

She sounds rather stupid.

Jalima1108 Sun 10-Dec-17 11:35:06

Hard though some may find this to believe, I think the rich started getting 'filthy rich' under the last Labour government - I am not saying it is right but that was the general ethos of the time which is now continuing.

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-1692295/How-the-rich-got-richer-under-Labour.html

Iam64 Sun 10-Dec-17 11:37:32

Why shouldn't Laura Pidock and her partner buy house costing somewhere around £250,000? It's a lot more than any of the 30 plus year olds in our extended family could afford but hey ho. Jealousy gets no one any where.

As jendurham said, she was talking about saving for a deposit on an MP's salary. I doubt any of the young people in our family could have saved enough to buy the small terraces/semi's they're now buying if they didn't have parents who could help. The only way the parents could help was because our own parents were able to buy small houses which were sold when they died and some of the inheritance gifted to their grandchildren.
Yes, I know, we are very very fortunate. There are other family members who are struggling, we try to help financially and in other ways.

Government policies are not helping those of us who are less fortunate than others. I'm beginning to feel I want to echo the posters who ask those who did/will vote tory to explain the positive policies that lead them to feel this is right for them and for the country. No need to explain why you won't vote for JC and co, I say that's understood and taken as read.

Jalima1108 Sun 10-Dec-17 11:40:40

No-one minds in the slightest a well-paid young couple buying a property in that price range - but she does come across as rather hypocritical and, quite frankly, stupid and irresponsible. Fancy missing a vital debate and vote on Universal Credit because she was on holiday in Venice - even if her partner had arranged the holiday.
If you can't turn up for something like that because you are enjoying yourself elsewhere what use are you to your constituents?

Jalima1108 Sun 10-Dec-17 11:41:52

I didn't vote Tory.

Jalima1108 Sun 10-Dec-17 11:42:27

ps so sorry, I can't help you

Anniebach Sun 10-Dec-17 11:44:01

But why only want a £250,000 house and say what she did about a council house, so jealousy? No and a criticism which was unfair.

Fennel Sun 10-Dec-17 11:46:10

"Just had a look, nice terraced three bedroomed for £50,000, why didn't she buy that"
Annie for once I agree with you on this - we must have been looking at the same houses for sale website smile
At one time there were empty terraced houses up on the Durham moors, abandonned pit villages, which were going for almost nothing.

durhamjen Sun 10-Dec-17 11:47:18

Lots of MPs miss votes.
The holiday was booked before she became an MP.
She had permission and was paired with an MP who was voting the other way. It's how it happens in parliament.
That's just another DM non-story. It happens all the time.
She's actually a lot more thoughtful and caring than many other MPs.

Jalima1108 Sun 10-Dec-17 11:54:27

Glad to hear it

It is, however, not a non-story, I am not her constituent thank goodness, but I wonder what some of them are thinking. Thanks for the link gillybob.

durhamjen Sun 10-Dec-17 12:01:13

Because she needs to be within reasonable travel distance of the main towns/villages in her constituency and be able to get to Durham railway station to get down to London?
The District of Derwentside wards of Benfieldside, Blackhill, Burnhope, Burnopfield, Castleside, Consett East, Consett North, Consett South, Cornsay, Delves Lane, Dipton, Ebchester and Medomsley, Esh, Lanchester, and Leadgate, and the District of Wear Valley wards of Crook North, Crook South, Howden, Hunwick, St John's Chapel, Stanhope, Tow Law and Stanley, Wheatbottom and Helmington Row, Willington Central, Willington West End, Wolsingham, and Witton-le-Wear.
A look at a map might show you how difficult it would be if she lived in the Durham Dales in an abandoned pit village.
Tomorrow I am hoping to go to a village in the dales, on the A68, in her constituency. I have to ring up first to find out if the road is open. This happens every year round here. Part of her constituency is always snowed in for a few months. That's the area that has the abandoned pit villages.

Anniebach Sun 10-Dec-17 12:09:07

Must be the same Fennel, I feel rather cross with her and being accused of jealousy, I want a two bedroomed house, can't have one, if she was given a council house would the silly woman expect a three bedroomed house or would she be happy with one bedroom . So many people on minimum wage would love a council house, silly bat.

Anniebach Sun 10-Dec-17 12:11:09

Our MP lives about eighty miles from me, bet he is snowed up too, what a pathetic excuse

durhamjen Sun 10-Dec-17 12:25:19

Jalima, I think when we voted for her to be our MP, that she was the best person to do the job and stand up for us in the commons. She is certainly doing that, as did her predecessor, Pat Glass.

durhamjen Sun 10-Dec-17 12:28:14

And what sort of house does your MP live in, Annie?

Jalima, I think the rich were already filthy rich before Blair came to power.
Anyway, Annie thinks it's okay, so it must be.

Anniebach Sun 10-Dec-17 12:31:32

Pity she didn't give more publicity for the housing for the low paid in Durham not complain about her struggle to buy a £250,000 house for herself

Chewbacca Sun 10-Dec-17 12:31:38

Anniebach grin

Jalima1108 Sun 10-Dec-17 12:32:13

I don't think that, if two people are on very large salaries and can afford to buy, they should expect to be given a council house, depriving someone else of one.

Others, such as some trade unions leaders, may not agree and think that it should be a universal right .

Jalima1108 Sun 10-Dec-17 12:33:08

did you read my link djen?

I thought not grin

whitewave Sun 10-Dec-17 12:33:45

Well they won’t be given a Council house will they? That’s a non argument.

Anniebach Sun 10-Dec-17 12:34:02

No idea Jen and don't care, I would if he started complaining about struggling to find a deposit for a £250,000 house , I certaintly wouldn't defend him

Anniebach Sun 10-Dec-17 12:36:29

Perhaps her constituents could start a fund raising campaign for the poor woman , such a sad story, sob

Jalima1108 Sun 10-Dec-17 12:36:48

Pidcock said she would love one but the reason she can't have one is that there are not enough.
I agree that there are nowhere near enough - but not that she should have one - that is unreasonable.

Anniebach Sun 10-Dec-17 12:41:42

Thinking of her constituents who are desperate for a council house , what an insensitive, stupid woman

durhamjen Sun 10-Dec-17 12:42:35

There aren't any council houses ; that was her point.
There were when we moved here in 2010, but not any more.
There was a council run care home, when we moved here, but not any more. The council had to sell those off.
There is no care home any more in this village.

That's what she rails about, care, pay, housing.
At the moment she is concerned about the fact that her constituents are being put on universal credit from tomorrow, and will have no money for Christmas if they are on benefits.

Don't mind me asking, but why do you think the DM brought this topic up at this time?
To deflect from what?
Working, isn't it?

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion