Gransnet forums

News & politics

Have we always had so many messages?

(54 Posts)
GracesGranMK2 Sat 30-Dec-17 22:36:56

I like the fact that the Queen makes a speech at Christmas - mainly because we don't hear from her very often but May has given us a "Christmas message" and now we are going to get a New Year one too. Couldn't the politicians just shut up over the holidays?

durhamjen Sat 30-Dec-17 22:43:49

May needs to give us another message just in case we've forgotten who she is and started to think the whole thing is a nightmare from which we will soon awaken.
She has nobody else to read bedtime stories to.

paddyann Sat 30-Dec-17 23:53:52

never watch the QS .have no intention of watching Mrs May ,neither of these women have anything in common with women who live ordinary lives,who struggle to bring up families during these horrible times ..or who have to care for children and elderly relatives while putting in a long week at work .Swap places for a few months or a couple of years and THEN you can maybe pontificate about life and how difficult it is .Until then I'm happy NOT to hear what you say

Anniebach Sun 31-Dec-17 03:42:36

The three party leaders gave messages .

Mocking a woman who cannot have a child is sick, what envy and hate can do, compassionate? I think not

FarNorth Sun 31-Dec-17 06:03:32

Mrs May and H M the queen have nothing in common with any ordinary women, with or without children.

No mocking, just fact.

GracesGranMK2 Sun 31-Dec-17 08:35:01

I feel the need to defend the people giving the messages. If we have to have two from each of the politicians - which is really what I was commenting on - they will not be from people who live the lives that are the same as the rest of us. We have put them in leadership positions and given them the trappings that go with that so they do not - cannot - live lives in common with the rest of us. However none of us lives a life in common with everyone else and what I want from a political leader is the ability to look outside their own lives and understand others. It is surely not impossible.

Does this mean that May then has to give two 'messages' in such short space of time? The only reason the other parties do is because she does. When did two messages actually start?

eazybee Sun 31-Dec-17 08:45:02

The Queen and Mrs. May have plenty in common with 'any ordinary women'.
They both have a huge sense of responsibility, commitment to what they perceive as their duty, the ability to keep going after disaster, either imposed or self-inflicted, and an immense capacity for hard work.

Grannyknot Sun 31-Dec-17 09:07:14

Does anyone actually pay attention to these 'messages'? They will have been written by an army of "Comms" staff. Completely meaningless waffle IMHO.

GracesGranMK2 Sun 31-Dec-17 09:18:09

Totally GK - so why so many to spoil our holidays? When did this happen?

Elegran Sun 31-Dec-17 09:53:19

There is no need to watch, listen to or read all these messages. The ether is full of people opening their mouths just to let their bellies rumble, just as the media and "public life" has always been full of people pontificating. Don't get het up about them, let them waffle on to empty air and ignore them.

GracesGranMK2 Sun 31-Dec-17 09:56:51

I am not 'het up' Elegran. You do seem to perceive other people intentions in an extreme manner and I just wish you would stop commenting on mine.

Elegran Sun 31-Dec-17 10:03:04

That was a general post, GG, to everyone.

durhamjen Sun 31-Dec-17 10:05:01

Even though I watch lots of politics, I admit to not watching either the Queen's speech or May's speech, or even reading them in the papers.

I see no point. They are not real. If May had actually done one thing that she said she would for ordinary people in this country, I might, but her speech on the doorstep of number ten is so far removed from the way she has treated the people she said she wanted to help, that I see no point in watching her tell lies again.

durhamjen Sun 31-Dec-17 10:06:51

So you are telling us all to stop getting het up, are you, Elegran?
Or are we just opening our mouths to let our bellies rumble?
Or is that May, or the Queen?

GracesGranMK2 Sun 31-Dec-17 10:13:24

I didn't watch the Queen's speech either Jen but caught the bits on the news and I know that for some people it is still part of their Christmas day - that's why I quite like the fact that she still does it. Politics and Christmas/New Year is quite another thing imo,

GrandmaMoira Sun 31-Dec-17 10:17:16

I wasn't even aware of May's Christmas speech but her New Year headline annoys me too much to read the rest.

durhamjen Sun 31-Dec-17 10:17:37

I don't mind the Queen giving a speech at Christmas; it's tradition. Just as long as we are not made to watch it.

I don't see why May has to have an extra party political broadcast, particularly as she won't do anything she says she will for the poor or the homeless. She'd be better off spending her time sorting out Grenfell, or going to her local foodbank to reassure her own constituents.

Anniebach Sun 31-Dec-17 10:18:16

I listen to queenies speech and The Arch Bish at New Year, not the others, realised Corbyn has to speak of the many not the few, includes all his wives and Diane A ?

durhamjen Sun 31-Dec-17 10:19:06

Much prefer Murphy's Quiz of 2018.

www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2017/12/29/the-2018-quiz-of-the-year/

durhamjen Sun 31-Dec-17 10:20:25

I seem to recall you saying you don't make jibes, Annie.

Bridgeit Sun 31-Dec-17 10:23:36

'Let he who is without sin cast the first stone'

' walk a mile in my shoes, before you criticise & abuse'

'We are all an accident of birth'

The new year is always a good time to reflect on our own shortcomings & perhaps cut others some slack !!

sunseeker Sun 31-Dec-17 10:23:47

Don't like all the messages? Don't watch or listen. As far as I am aware it is not compulsory - yet.

Anniebach Sun 31-Dec-17 10:26:17

Jen after your nasty comment on May not having children I thought I would join you . Being childless is rarely a choice, three marriages are always a choice .

Chewbacca Sun 31-Dec-17 10:46:33

Let he who is without sin cast the first stone'
' walk a mile in my shoes, before you criticise & abuse'
'We are all an accident of birth'
The new year is always a good time to reflect on our own shortcomings & perhaps cut others some slack !!

This! It would be great if we could have a proper discussion without barbs and spiteful ripostes. But as it's not even noon yet and the knives are out already, it's looking unlikely. sad

Anniebach Sun 31-Dec-17 10:52:09

It would be good Chewbacca but the first reply set the tone for the thread , yes I know no need to join in but somethings such as mocking childlessness is sinking so low