Gransnet forums

News & politics

No Deal and supply of medicines

(547 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

jura2 Fri 12-Oct-18 09:45:38

just a bit of 'mithering' here:

www.facebook.com/FullEnglishBrexit/videos/1929957283964805/

Grandad1943 Sat 03-Nov-18 19:27:42

No Mawbroon, but I did take on a great deal in education back then, learning French then would have been just one more task.

However, I believe Britain held much more for those wishing to progress in their education and working lives thirty years ago, than it does now or into the future, sadly.

Would value your thoughts?

MawBroon Sat 03-Nov-18 19:38:32

Just as so many people feel that immigrants to the UK should make the effort to learn and speak English I find it imperative for anybody hoping to make a career in another country to become fluent in that language.
I am amused that you dismiss learning French as “just another” task as if it would have been a piece of cake hmm
Reminds me of the sort of person who says they could easily have written a book/poem/symphony/perform brain surgery if they had chosen to do so!

Grandad1943 Sat 03-Nov-18 19:57:45

I would not dream of working in another country without learning its native language prior to moving. However, in the sixties, seventies and even the early years of the eighties I and many others found it very possible to progress from the shop floor to higher management provided that you improved your education along the way.

The above I believe is now much more difficult if not virtually impossible as the workplace opportunities and adult education are no longer in place for that to happen.

In the above, many left these shores for Australia and New Zealand in those years, but Europe or any non-English speaking country did not come into the equation back then

janeainsworth Sat 03-Nov-18 20:24:44

Grandad <sigh>
Did you actually read the Guardian article you posted a link to?
The only mention of Brexit is in this paragraph:
“The cuts to bursaries [for trainee nurses and midwives] have driven down the numbers of students applying for health degrees while the government’s chaotic handling of Brexit has put off increasing numbers of desperately needed medical staff from coming to the UK to care for our sick and elderly,” he added

The article says that Brexit is deterring EU nationals and other foreign graduates from working in the NHS.
The article does not say Brexit is causing British graduates to leave.

I do wish you would make sure you know what you’re talking about before making such statements.

Grandad1943 Sat 03-Nov-18 21:02:51

janeainsworth, make of it what you will. It explains why the NHS has a severe staff recruitment and retention problem. Do you honestly believe that Btexit is improving that problem?

I believe that this is another case of leave voters clinging to straws in the hope that some credibility can be seen and found by others in the way they voted.

Many were retired armchair risk takers who now wonder why younger people despise the older generation and the damage they are doing to the NHS and many other industries/ professions and the employment in those bodies.

Even the medication supply is under threat because of those that voted leave.

MawBroon Sat 03-Nov-18 21:12:26

Would you care to elaborate on who you are referring to as “Leave” voters Grandad?
Or retired bath (ooops, arm) chair voters?
Or do you persist in assuming that anybody who dares to question your punditry must by definition be a Brexiteer?

Grandad1943 Sat 03-Nov-18 21:30:03

Make of it what you will Mawbroon. It states what it states quite clearly I believe.

I do not refer to you or any particular person as a mistaken leave voter, but obviously they are out there, and many would be retired. grin

MawBroon Sat 03-Nov-18 21:35:38

And?

Grandad1943 Sat 03-Nov-18 21:47:19

And what Mawbroon?

janeainsworth Sat 03-Nov-18 22:38:59

Grandad
Many qualifying with degrees from our universities are now going overseas to practice their professions as they fear Britain will be a declining economy following brexit
Your words.
That is the assertion I am challenging you to substantiate. That UK medical graduates are leaving the country because of Brexit, for financial reasons.
I don’t know how to make it clearer.
I am well aware of the NHS’s staffing problems, so please don’t post any more links that don’t answer my question.
I voted Remain.
Got it now?

Grandad1943 Sat 03-Nov-18 23:03:39

I think there are many in this thread that do not want to get what Brexit is doing to the future of Britain. In that, they cannot see that Brexit will weaken the British economy and there will be less money for the NHS and much other infrastructure.

Therefore many British Medical graduates along with graduates to many other professions look to the overseas as better options for their careers and as greater financial reward for their accreditations.

I do not think anyone should condemn them for taking that option as even leading Brexitier Jacob Rees Mogg has stated it may take Britain fifty years to gain any rewards from leaving the European Unuon

Got it now.

Jalima1108 Sat 03-Nov-18 23:11:37

In the above, many left these shores for Australia and New Zealand in those years, but Europe or any non-English speaking country did not come into the equation back then
Do you have any figures to back up that assertion please Grandad?
I do know several people (and some relatives) who worked overseas in non-English speaking countries in the 1970s and 80s.

Even 'Sunny Jim'Callaghan said:
"Our place in the world is shrinking: our economic comparisons grow worse, long-term political influence depends on economic strength - and that is running out," he told his colleagues in November 1974. "If I were a young man, I should emigrate."
He didn't have much faith in his PM then!

Jalima1108 Sat 03-Nov-18 23:14:45

I voted Remain.
Got it now?

No janeainsworth, I don't think that Grandad has got it.

I voted Remain too but I do realise that not everything can be laid at the door of Brexit.

Grandad1943 Sat 03-Nov-18 23:15:09

I find it strange that many on this forum state that they voted remain, but then go on to rally against anyone that criticises the Brexit argument.

Makes me wonder? grin

MawBroon Sat 03-Nov-18 23:18:34

Your second paragraph is a complete non sequitur Grandad - there is no “therefore” about it and the behaviour you are describing has been going on long before we were even in the EU let alone about to leave it.
Yout first paragraph is a matter of opinion and adds very little to anything and your final paragraph quite irrelevant.
So I fail to see what your posts today have added either to your argument or anybody else’s understanding of Brexit - let alone anything to do with drug shortages.
Perhaps Jura will provide you with a new starter for ten tomorrow morning.

Jalima1108 Sat 03-Nov-18 23:22:02

Makes me wonder?
Yes, I wonder too Grandad
Criticising Brexit with well-researched facts is one thing, but throwing out unverifiable statements which can be proved to have no foundation does not help your cause.

Grandad1943 Sat 03-Nov-18 23:27:13

MawBroon, and I find your above post compleat nonsense also.

Good night have a good paragraph. grin

Jalima1108 Sat 03-Nov-18 23:32:20

compleat
I haven't heard that word in a long while, since I last visited Izaak Walton's cottage.

moon

MawBroon Sat 03-Nov-18 23:36:02

Not since The Compleat Angler, I agree.

Nonsense, Grandad?

janeainsworth Sun 04-Nov-18 01:44:33

Grandad
I voted Remain.
That doesn’t mean that I have to support other Remainers when they are talking complete codswallop.
You actually weaken your case when you just make stuff up.
Why don’t you just admit it?

MawBroon Sun 04-Nov-18 07:27:03

MawBroon, and I find your above post compleat nonsense also

Good night have a good paragraph

I am sorry perhaps it was not clear I was referring to your post of 23.03 which contained three paragraphs and an envoi “Got it”
Sadly as I believe they say across the Pond
“No, you don’t got it”

petra Sun 04-Nov-18 08:52:29

Grandad1943
rally against anyone who criticises
It's obvious from recent posts that we have some
criticle thinkers on GN. Hallelujah.

POGS Sun 04-Nov-18 10:22:48

Grandad

" I find it strange that many on this forum state that they voted remain, but then go on to rally against anyone that criticises the Brexit argument."
----

In other words you believe some posters are lying, is that correct?

I voted Remain but I have been ' informed ' on more than one occasion I was a ' Brexiteer ', maybe by yourself too.

I recall another thread where if I am not mistaken you said a very similar thing accusing posters of being ' Brexiteers ' who took a different view to yours . When you were asked who the ' Brexiteers' were you were speaking of you never answered . Perhaps you missed the question as you moved on to other threads , no doubt that thread will be resurrected as it is a topic that annoys some posters into teeth gnashing.

To my mind there are some who use the word ' Brexiter ' as a derogatory term and they make no bones of who/what/why THEY deem a ' Brexiter ' to be. There are others who use the word ' Brexiter ' in it's obvious form of a person who chose to leave the European Union for their own individual reasons and accept their right to do so. To my mind the sneering , derogatory using of the word is so pathetic I decide occasionally to have an input , especially when some posters have gone too far and called them ' 'Brexshitters' etc.

If a poster queries another poster over their factual evidence , perhaps time line of the information they produce, comments they made it shows a weakness on the part of the poster being queried if their only way of dealing with it is to result to plan B and fall back on the now very old cry of calling them a ' Brexiter' as if it that were a sin.






From the time of the Referendum result be astounded by the level of bile and name calling and

Jalima1108 Sun 04-Nov-18 11:06:56

janea grin
compleatly correct

Elegran Sun 04-Nov-18 11:09:28

Some people believe that all's fair in love, war and politics, the end justifies the means, and anything at all can be blamed on the opposite to what they wish for. Others are open-minded enough to dislike unfair and biased criticism, even of those proposals that they voted against.