Gransnet forums

News & politics

Brexit induced poverty. Worth it?

(172 Posts)
MaizieD Wed 28-Nov-18 08:49:05

Yet again we are told that Brexit will make us poorer (Chancellor R4 this morning.

I wonder how many of our Gnet Leavers wil be happy to take a hit on their incomes/spending power for 'the cause'.

And how they feel about condemning half their fellow citizens to unwanted diminished economic prospects? (The Remain half, I mean.)

varian Thu 29-Nov-18 19:17:18

It is ironic that the latest immigration figures show a drop in EU immigrants but a dramatic rise in immigrants from non-EU countries.

The racists who voted leave are achieving what they did not want - a lot more black and brown immigrants to the UK!

Jalima1108 Thu 29-Nov-18 19:44:31

How do you know that varian confused
Not everyone who lives is a non-EU country is black or brown.

I thought that quite a number of well-established Asian communities in the UK voted Brexit too.

Jalima1108 Thu 29-Nov-18 19:46:04

the other thing is that many people think that, with our ever closer union to the EU, we were distancing ourselves from our Commonwealth brothers and sisters.

It is something that has worried me for a long time, although, on balance, I decided to vote remain.

Labaik Thu 29-Nov-18 19:50:57

Were we preventing people from the Commonwealth from coming here then?

varian Thu 29-Nov-18 19:51:00

You made the right call, Jalima when you voted REMAIN. All credit to you for giving it serious thought.

Jalima1108 Thu 29-Nov-18 19:52:21

We were making it quite difficult Labaik, especially when it came to British citizens bringing in spouses.

lemongrove Thu 29-Nov-18 21:49:17

Parliament went along with both holding the referendum and honouring the results, whatever anyone chooses to believe to the contrary.
If all had not voted to trigger article 50 then we would not be leaving the EU.

maryeliza54 Thu 29-Nov-18 22:45:37

The majority of non-EU immigrants are from Asia so I would guess rather on the brown side

MaizieD Thu 29-Nov-18 22:52:22

Didn't Priti Patel assure the British Asian voters that leaving the EU would open up the UK to immigration from India and Pakistan?

crystaltipps Fri 30-Nov-18 06:49:05

The only reason May has rejected a Norway style Brexit is because it include FOM, thus acknowledging that it was halting immigration that was top of most Brexiteers wish list. She can now say she has done this with the WA. Unfortunately Brexiteers should be careful what they wish for, as immigration will still continue but they now can’t blame the EU.

Nicenanny3 Fri 30-Nov-18 07:36:02

varian from what I can see by reading the posts on GN I have not seen any racist posts from Leavers it's you who keeps posting about immigrants and what colour they are. It seems to me from your posts you prefer the white EU immigrants not the black and brown ones, so instead of keep calling Leavers racist perhaps you should take a good look at yourself in the mirror.

MaizieD Fri 30-Nov-18 07:48:38

varian from what I can see by reading the posts on GN I have not seen any racist posts from Leavers

There is a world outside Gnet, Nn3; I think that's the one varian is talking about. A world in which racism, sadly, still exists.

crystaltipps Fri 30-Nov-18 08:00:05

Anyone thinking there is no racism in the UK is sadly in cloud cuckoo land. There have many racist incidents linked to Brexit unfortunately.

Greta Fri 30-Nov-18 09:31:52

Jalima: ^”...many people think that, with our ever closer union to the EU, we were distancing ourselves from our Commonwealth brothers and sisters.^”

I can see that this is a concern for them. However, we are now distancing ourselves from our European neighbours. It's all very well to say we must now restrict immigration from EU-countries. Careful – they may no longer wish to come.

Lazigirl Fri 30-Nov-18 09:48:19

I have looked at studies about why people voted the way they did in the Referendum, and whilst obviously they cannot discern individual reasons they look at the demographics. There's no doubt that immigration played a part in vote Leave, but so did deprivation in areas that have seen the biggest cuts in local services. Ironically if the economic predictions are correct then whatever type of Brexit we achieve, those hit the hardest by the austerity cuts will suffer the most post Brexit.

maryeliza54 Fri 30-Nov-18 10:13:06

It’s hard isn’t it Lazi not to conclude that that’s because the government couldn’t give the proverbial about areas of deprivation and those suffering most from austerity . Remember all the hype about the Northern Powerhouse and GO in his hard hat and hi-vis jacket? Remember TM’s speech on the steps of Downing Street when she first became PM. Sheer sheer lying hypocrisy.

Davidhs Fri 30-Nov-18 10:23:52

Actually TM ruled out a deal with Corbyn regarding a Norway style deal - at least for now.

I saw the immigration figures yesterday EU migrants well down but the increase in migration from all country's was 280,000 so much for getting net increase below 100,000

And we still haven't got enough doctors and nurses

MaizieD Fri 30-Nov-18 10:32:45

The hardest thing about watching the results on referendum night was Sunderland voting Leave. If ever a region had a real reason to be grateful for the EU it was Sunderland. Nissan moved there because of access to the EU market. It's reckoned that some 37,000 jobs in the area are dependent on Nissan and they will go if we leave. The NE can't afford that.

People I spoke to in the aftermath were so confident that Nissan needed their highly skilled and efficient British workforce so much that they wouldn't relocate. Blind to the fact that other EU nationals apart from the Brits are capable of being highly skilled and efficient. I think they've swung to Remain now but is it too late?

winterwhite Fri 30-Nov-18 11:24:38

It’s disturbing that Leave campaigners are so ready to dismiss as ‘scaremongering’ two independent professional reports on the economy that come to the same conclusion, and then themselves hold forth about nebulous ‘plans’ for a European army and a European bank as though already set in stone. Pots and kettles?
The leaders of these same Brexiteers declared throughout the first half of 2016 that they would never accept a 52:48% remain result as conclusive, yet now round on Remainers for challenging the validity of statements such as ‘the nation voted to leave’. For that reason I now doubt that a second referendum will mend matters.
It is the Tory-led Brexiteers who have led us into this appalling mess and now blame everyone else, including as other posters have said taking our membership of the EU to be responsible for the state of our hospitals, schools and roads.

varian Fri 30-Nov-18 13:16:48

Gareth Southgate has said there there were "racial undertones" to the Brexit vote.

The England manager spoke out about the power of football to bring people together and the part it can play in the country's struggle to find a "modern identity". And he said that one of the reasons he felt young people would engage with the England team during the World Cup was because it was as diverse as modern England.

Speaking in an ITV documentary on the inspiring rise of black footballers he said: "I didn't like the connotations around Brexit there were some generational opinions about what modern Britain should look like. "We felt that young people in particular would connect with our guys because they must have been confused after Brexit because for me a lot of the undertones of the voting on Brexit were racial undertones."

England's unexpected success in the World Cup in Russia boosted the public mood as the young squad made their way through the tournament. And it became a moment for the whole country to come together - regardless of their politics.

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/gareth-southgate-says-were-racial-13665569

crystaltipps Fri 30-Nov-18 15:26:13

Some Brexit voters believe the EU countries are about to implode politically so we should “escape” before that happens, wonder how they feel now it is the U.K. that is imploding politically?

petra Fri 30-Nov-18 16:03:36

Crystaltipps
Riots in France last week, riots in Brussels as we speak. Where next?

suzied Fri 30-Nov-18 16:57:55

The protests were legal- we have them here about all sorts of issues-- they weren't demanding to leave the EU they were directed at their own governments policies.

Lazigirl Fri 30-Nov-18 17:52:25

Unfortunately UKs big protest, perhaps in lieu of rioting, was the Referendum, where people who were feeling disaffected could have their say. Possibly and controversially, little to do with EU at the end of the day, but for many other reasons in our society which cause people to feel angry?

crystaltipps Fri 30-Nov-18 18:27:31

Some people think any protest in EU countries demonstrate that the EU is about to collapse even when the protests have nothing to do with the EU. We have many protest here - last week in London we had protests about climate change, the congestion charge, air quality, the Saudi regime etc etc.