Why doesn't Starmer hold another referendum?
Gransnet forums
News & politics
NO DEAL is the only way. The EU 'wrote' the WA Agreement.
(306 Posts)and it ties us to the EU indefinitely.
The Irish backstop could be the least of our worries.
May's WA must be rejected completely. It is an incredibly complicated document leaving hardly a subject not covered, and everything in it has been designed to be beneficial to the EU.
I doubt if any MP has read it from cover to cover. Nearly every paragraph is cross-referenced to a Treaty, Regulation or Directive, and each one has to be looked up, read and understood before moving on. It takes hours.
So says John Ashworth in his article This EU-written Withdrawal Agreement is toxic from start to finish
www.conservativewoman.co.uk/this-eu-written-withdrawal-agreement-is-toxic-from-start-to-finish/
It is a very revealing article, written by someone who has made an effort to link the words to the many treaties, acts and sub-paragraphs which determine the UK's role after a decidedly dodgy exit (or non-exit as it transpires) from the EU.
It is very worrying.
He concludes
During any transition period, we would not be classified as a ‘third country’, so although technically one could claim that we had left the EU, in practical terms, we *wouldn’t have done so – rather the opposite*
We would effectively be controlled by the EU to such a degree that we might just as well shut our Parliament down
We would finally become a ‘third country’ on 1 January 2023, as it is doubtful that the EU would consider an extension other than on the previous transition terms, which would essentially mean that we would still not have left the EU in any meaningful way
We would still be paying our ongoing fees, at full rate, to the EU. The EU would still control our fisheries and our armed forces and we would still be subject to the European Court of Justice, with our Parliament still essentially sidelined. No one in their right minds could want us to be in such a situation
We do not want Brexit in name only (BRINO) which is what the WA will give us, if our only request is the dropping of the backstop.
Boris, must be careful. May's WA is a non-starter. Farage, in waiting, understands that the WA has to be rejected - in full.
Why? Was he your favourite comedian WWM2 ?
On less. Glorious????
The problem with TM's withdrawal agreement was surely that it was widely thought to be less advantageous than no Brexit at all yet thought by the ERM as not to go far enough, and they are the people who are 'winning' now. I seem to remember MPs having to book slots to go and read the d***n thing, and doing so. Or am I thinking of something else? I think it an easy and prob unjust jibe to accuse MPs of not having read it.
The Withdrawal Agreement should anyone wish to wade through it in its entirety, is here, if you open links on this page.
europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-18-6424_en.htm
Boris however is sure (i sincerely hope!) to take note of the simple line contained within the press release from Brussels, 14 November 2018
Nothing is agreed until everything is agreed
Sounds very sinister to me.
Better, persons than me have worked their way through the whole WA, checking innocent looking sentences against treaties, paragraphs, sub paragraphs, clauses, sub clauses, etc, etc, etc. (If you have a spare few weeks/months you might want to try going through that confusing cross referencing too.
)
The NI backstop is one concern. There are MANY others. If Boris is able to engineer minor tweaks and see that as a result, and so agree to May's disastrous WA, he will lose much support - mine for a start!
The Withdrawal Agreement is NOT acceptable to the UK unless we want Brussels to control or have a say in our future movements.
I do hope Boris' advisors are urging him to make a clean break.
Day6 we have been a member of a trading block, the EU, for the last 40 odd years, how on earth do you think it is possible to extract ourselves in some kind of clean sweep? Especially when the world has changed out of all recognition and international trade agreements take years to negotiate.
Anyone would think you are an MEP, a member of the Cabinet, in the Labour and Tory party executives and a member of the Secret Service to boot, when actually, as with most people you are, I suspect, a Daily Mail or Telegraph or Express reader.
What is sinister about 'Nothing is agreed until everything is agreed'? This is a renegotiation of 40 years of trade and economic affairs for heaven's sake. Brussels wanting to control and have a say in our future movements??? I think they'll be glad to get rid of us, from Cameron's days onwards, the UK has been a pain in the butt to the rest of the EU. Once we've gone, they'll happily get on with allocating money to areas which need it, like Wales and Cornwall and Liverpool and Northern Ireland, all of which have benefited enormously from the EU, they'll continue to pass laws which protect the consumer, which opt for best farming practices, they'll continue to harmonise security forces information across Europe so as to protect member states from fraud and widescale corruption, they'll facilitate collaboration in scientific research across member states......and so on.
Meanwhile, our mean, morbid little State will be in the pocket of Trump with his chlorinated chicken and cheap food and minus a decent health service because our government has wasted time and money pretending a narrowly won referendum was a) democratic and b) unchallengeable and c) an innocent poll about the EU when actually it was about the Tory Party unable to stop having nights of the long knives and was run from the beginning by forces of the Far Right who want a state free of control so that they can rip off the rest of us. Sheesh, I'm off to have a double G and T.
‘Our mean morbid little state’ ??
Which country are you moving to?
notentirelyallthere, I think you may infact be totallyallthere.
‘As with most people, you are I suspect a Daily Mail or Telegraph or Express reader’ ( you write to Day6)
What personal nonsense you write notentirelyall here !
when actually, as with most people you are, I suspect, a Daily Mail or Telegraph or Express reader
Oh dear notentirelyallhere I suspect your user name suits you given you attack with such cheap jibes.
I am not offended to be called any of those things, just as you probably don't mind being referred to as an hysterical referendum loser who scours every pro-EU publication supporting her point of view.
You see, it works both ways.
The Telegraph isn't a bad paper actually. There are lots of interesting articles in it written by guest journos.
How about you address the post and not the poster? That's how grown up discourse works, and we can both move on?
I think some people’s should start calling EU ‘Eutopia’ as the have such a rose tinted perception of the union.
People!
I had no idea about the Irish Border issue before the vote is should have been explained and made public.
A local TV prog last night showed how fish are still being chucked back into the sea. After being caught, over the quota, now dead.
All good food
One of the reasons why i hate the EU........there are hungry people and the fishermen have to throw the good fish back dead. Makes no sense.
and was run from the beginning by forces of the Far Right who want a state free of control so that they can rip off the rest of us
Honestly, that is beginning to sound like paranoia. I hope you are OK.
My take and that of many Unionists and left wingers is the EU fans the flames of austerity, is a dream scenario for capitalism and affects wages throughout the continent, keeping them low, so bosses make huge profits.
THAT sounds very nasty to me. I am so surprised you support that.
Of course Day6 .....which is why Corbyn has railed against the EU all his political life!
There is vast poverty and unemployment in so many member states too.
You ask the people on the streets if their lives are made better by being in EU controlled countries and they are likely to tell you their lives couldn't get much worse. Many young people in EU member states don't see a future for themselves.
Exactly lemon.
I am one of life's floating voters, always have been, but I could march with socialists against the EU. Many left wingers despise it.
Until he could be in touching distance to the keys of No.10.......then the UK will be totally “screwed”
I had no idea about the Irish Border issue before the vote is should have been explained and made public.
Really, no idea?
I think he is universally despised by anyone not in or supporting the Labour Party. They lost the last election with Jezza at the helm, didn't they?
His history of supporting the UK's enemies makes him a non-starter in my book, and is made worse by his total U turn on the EU.
Who up until a few months ago,
A )vociferously denounced and despised the EU for the decades he has been an MP?
B) Who then sat on the fence as Labour leader regarding EU issues, not revealing his true feelings or guiding the party to Leave, or indeed in any direction at all. Labour were rudderless under pathetic Corbyn and the party split.
C) Who recently decided he would support Remain (because he could smell unrest ) also support a second referendum, and in doing so betray so many Labour supporters?
He really is a weasel. (Hang on, that's not fair on weasels. Sorry weasels. They could probably run a political party better than he could.)
Corbyn is motivated by power to break Britain alongside his Marxist allies within the now hard-left Labour Party.
Corbyn looks to be redeeming himself, at least to some extent, by saying he will not vote for a general election until a no deal brexit has been decisively and securely been removed from the table.
Corbyn looks to be redeeming himself, at least to some extent, by saying he will not vote for a general election until a no deal brexit has been decisively and securely been removed from the table.
Oh, the hypocrisy. He has been calling for an immediate election on a daily basis!
Tony Blair has warned him about BJ's "elephant trap" and it seems he has paid attention.
Not hypocrisy, Joelsnan, just putting the in,Teresa’s of the country to the forefront rather than personal ambition.
Interests, nothing to do with May.
Join the conversation
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join the discussion, watch threads and lots more.
Register now »Already registered? Log in with:
Gransnet »

