Gransnet forums

News & politics

Boris getting tough with EU

(200 Posts)
newnanny Tue 08-Oct-19 10:32:24

It sounds like the gloves are off. Merkyl has now told Boris EU will never agree deal unless NI is fully within CU. Boris reply is Conservative manifesto will state we leave with no deal as new policy if EU fail to agree to his deal. He will also offer 'front of the queue deal' to any country vetoing UK Brexit delay but countries approving one will 'go to the back of the queue'. He will also refuse to negotiate any further with EU after Oct 31st. He may refuse to share our security with EU and appoint Nigel Farage as UK commissioner to EU. The great pity is our own parliament sabotaged Boris doing deal with EU by forcing him to ask for yet another useless extension on Oct 19th, costing £1 billion gross every month, so now EU think they don't need to negotiate with Boris just sit tight. Now we will most likely end up leaving with no deal.

Urmstongran Tue 08-Oct-19 13:32:18

I think the stronger the Government is now the greater their majority will be at the next election.

notentirelyallhere Tue 08-Oct-19 13:36:04

The EU have been patiently negotiating with the UK for the last three years. It has been blatantly obvious for months that the UK government was doing its best to not negotiate and go for No Deal (which will benefit all the ERG group, it's what they want) and then blame the EU.

The EU has made it clear what the stopping points are - particularly the Backstop and why, other than to support the UK's age old and careless attitude towards the Irish Republic, should the EU compromise further.

Amagran Tue 08-Oct-19 13:55:04

Two things are puzzling me:

1. Why are we still talking about a no-deal Brexit, and in some quarters, saying it is now inevitable, when it is actually illegal?

2. If the 'will of the people' is more important than considered, informed, debated decision making by elected members, which is the fundamental premise of our Parliamentary democracy, then why is the will of the two thirds of the country who now apparently do not want a no-deal Brexit, being ignored?

Amagran Tue 08-Oct-19 14:01:07

As for Johnson's current threats and rants about the EU, I can only say that he is the most unstatesmanlike, most undignified and most dissembling politician I can ever remember our having in this country. And yes, there have been some bad 'uns before him.

Daisymae Tue 08-Oct-19 14:02:26

Humpty Dumpty, that's so true. We all believe reports or news that concurs with our beliefs and the rest is rubbish. Our grandchildren will not be thanking us in the decades to come.

Anja Tue 08-Oct-19 14:23:27

I sometimes wonder, from the right wing propaganda and support on certain threads if Boris’ or Rees-Moggs’ nannies are on this site ???

Jabberwok Tue 08-Oct-19 14:59:00

It states quite clearly under article 50 that we are perfectly entitled to leave the EU after two years with or without a deal! In doing so, we are not committing a criminal act though some people behave as if we are. Scotland Wales and NI are perfectly entitled to leave the UK if that's what they wish without hindrance or procrastination from anyone else! We are entitled to do the same from the EU!

newnanny Tue 08-Oct-19 15:00:36

@Amagran the MP's were elected because they promised to uphold the will if the people. They then went on to abuse their position by blocking the very thing they were elected to deliver. In all polls I have seen recently the Conservatives on 38%, who are saying we must come out are about 15 points ahead of any other party who either want to remain or revoke. The Brexit Party also wanting to leave with no deal are showing as up to 12% depending on polls so where does the 66% of the country wanting no deal. Last poll I saw specifically asking would you agree to leave with no deal 49% said yes and some said don't know meaning less than half said no.

humptydumpty Tue 08-Oct-19 15:36:01

newnanny actually I believe MPs are elected to do what they believe is right for their country. I hope if there was a referendum which voted to bring back hanging, that MPs would not blindly follow their constuents' opinions..

growstuff Tue 08-Oct-19 15:41:37

ALL the latest polls by respectable polling companies show a majority for Remain.

growstuff Tue 08-Oct-19 15:42:45

Anja I think they're Katie Hopkins wannabes.

Amagran Tue 08-Oct-19 15:46:40

No, Jabberwok - it is illegal now to leave the EU without a deal. Parliament passed a law to that effect. It is known as the Benn Act. Its legality has nothing whatever to do with the EU.

lemongrove Tue 08-Oct-19 15:48:19

Anja....and I sometimes wonder from the left wing propaganda and support on certain threads if momentum activists are on this site.

growstuff ........ a pathetic response from you.

Amagran Tue 08-Oct-19 15:49:53

Newnanny, a Conservative majority Parliament made that spurious promise. The Conservatives are now not in the majority in Parliament. The Conservatives do not have a mandate to take us out of the EU without a deal.

lemongrove Tue 08-Oct-19 15:50:35

Amagram I would be amazed if Jabberwock ( or anyone)
Didn’t already know that.
In fact there may well be a legal way to circumvent the Benn,
Or Surrender act.

Amagran Tue 08-Oct-19 15:56:25

lemongrove, I respect your opinions on politics and leaving the EU, though I do not necessarily agree with them.

I don't think that accusing those of holding opposing views of being extremists or promulgating propaganda contributes anything useful to what could and should be robust but respectful debate.

lemongrove Tue 08-Oct-19 15:59:03

Tell that to Anja perhaps.

Amagran Tue 08-Oct-19 15:59:28

Inflammatory language again lemongrove. I would be equally upset to see anyone calling Brexit the Isolationists' Charter, or anything else derogatory.

Amagran Tue 08-Oct-19 16:02:52

Yes, what I said applies to anyone being inflammatory, whichever 'side' they are on.

lemongrove Tue 08-Oct-19 16:02:59

grin would you? I think it’s already been called that, or similar over the years on GN.I certainly remember a Little Englander Charter.
Do stop policing the threads Amagram there are paid moderators to do that.

grapefruitpip Tue 08-Oct-19 16:14:18

Yes, do stop Anja, there are plenty of other jolly, smiley posters who can police threads admirably.

varian Tue 08-Oct-19 16:26:03

Boris Johnson will try to blame anyone but himself for pushing us closer to the cliff edge of a disastrous No Deal Brexit.

twitter.com/LibDems/status/1181572738718343170?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Etweet

Caro6699 Tue 08-Oct-19 16:45:14

I agree with new nanny, I do believe Boris is trying to do his best to get a deal but the EU realise he is hamstrung by a divided parliament which has left him In a poor negotiationing position. They know that he is now unlikely to be able to leave with a no deal as parliament will not allow this.
For me , the more worrying thought is, that despite the majority vote, of those that did vote, was to leave 3years ago ,parliament are close to setting a precedent that if they don’t like the result of any further referendum they can they can do the same again to prevent it happening.
What is the point of any further delay We have had 3 years to sort this out?Are we doomed to endlessly revisiting these negotiations, or do we say ok you win , and remain?
What ever happens now there are going to be some very angry voters .

Dinahmo Tue 08-Oct-19 17:07:12

For once the Leavers are out in force but still spouting the same misinformation.

Don't understand how they can admire Johnson so much, despite the lies and fraudulent misuse of money whilst he was Mayor of London. £56,000,000 for a feasibility study into a garden bridge across the Thames. Can anybody explain that cost? Also Boris buses which he was sure could be sold elsewhere - no takers and (whilst Foreign Secretary) the purchase of 2 water cannons (illegal in the UK) which he tried to sell on and have now been scrapped.

Jabberwok Tue 08-Oct-19 18:08:33

Yes of course I am aware of the Benn bill! But lets face it, MPs signed up to article 50 with, as we now know, the sole purpose of destroying it, hence no deal, constant delays, more and more frustration and anger amongst voters as two years turns into three + with no end in sight. Perhaps the EU will kick us out, the Benn bill can't prevent that!
My leaver daughter is so disgusted at the way remainer politicians have behaved in not honouring the results of the referendum that if there's another vote, she and our son would definitely vote to leave, (much to our surprise!)