Gransnet forums

News & politics

Brexit dividing my family.

(432 Posts)
iluvsylvanianfamilies51 Fri 06-Dec-19 13:10:03

I voted leave in 2016 and had no idea it would come to this. I really think this country has never felt more divided. Walking on eggshells when discussing things with friends, family, neighbours. Not wanting to offend but not wanting to back down. It is horrible.

What makes me sad is that it feels like families are splintered and there's so much resentment. Grandkids all voted remain and kids voted remain and leave. All have arguments about it all the time and I feel them getting more closed off to each other.I t is unbearably sad. We shouldnt be divided like this.

I'm sure others feel the same but the reason I post is because my granddaughter sent me this video and I think it articulates it really well. You may not like Labour or momentum but I think we will agree that this tension between leave/remain leaves us weaker. And when I voted in 2016 I didn't think it would be so drawn out. I feel embarrassed about that

twitter.com/PeoplesMomentum/status/1202573131606573056

I have been on the fence about who to vote for but I despise Johnson for his comments on single mothers (AND his racism!) and I think Labour are the best chance we have to get a better leave deal and bring our country back together again. In 2015 I never expected political division to make living rooms tense and communities divided. I wish we could have it back and this stalemate to be over.

varian Sat 07-Dec-19 11:56:43

I sympathise with you freyja, but please only vote Labour if you think that is the best way to beat the Tories in your constituency. If you're not sure please check out the various tactical voting websites. You will find that they do not always agree in every case as some just suggest voting for the party which came second last time but others take account of local election results, EU election results, candidates and other local factors.

garnet25 Sat 07-Dec-19 12:06:13

My husband voted to leave and I am a strong remainder yet we agree to differ and leave it at that. However, we have friends who live in France who have been and will be badly affected by Brexit who can hardly bring themselves to be civil to him. I find all the animosity very distressing and unnecessary.

Greeneyedgirl Sat 07-Dec-19 12:07:45

Like Grannyactivist I do not believe that topics such as politics, religion and sex should be off limits. I really love a good discussion and life would be so boring if these issues weren't chewed over.

I think we should be able to support our point of view without aggression, and importantly listening to those who don't agree.

It's when people haven't learnt how to do this respectfully that conflict becomes entrenched. I have friends who don't all agree with my political stance of course.If I didn't I would be living a very sheltered and boring life.

MaizieD Sat 07-Dec-19 12:08:54

Maybe you’re in on it you then?

Don't be ridiculous.

Sb74 Sat 07-Dec-19 12:09:47

Why not? you claim I am?

MaizieD Sat 07-Dec-19 12:12:20

Time you learned the difference between 'could be' and 'are'. Sb74

varian Sat 07-Dec-19 12:17:07

We were taught to debate at school and political debating was a big feature of university life.

Some people never seem to have learned how to debate, how to understand the difference between arguing about facts and opinions. Facts can usually be checked out, although in our era of fake news and propaganda it has become more difficult.

To the people who say "I had my reasons for voting the way I did three and a half years ago and I'm sticking to my decision", I would ask "Have you learned nothing in the last three and a half years?".

Most of us have learned a great deal more, and one of the things we should have learned is that it was absurd to ask for a simple yes/no answer to a very complicated question. Have you never, having discovered you might have been misled or based your decision on poor information, then later changed your mind about anything?

ananimous Sat 07-Dec-19 12:23:25

Shocking aggression as usual from the losing side...

Sb74 Sat 07-Dec-19 12:26:39

Mazied - grow up. Think you need to go to mumsnet with your attitude. I’m allowed an opinion and my opinion is this is not a genuine post. The fact it bothers you so much is suspicious in itself. Have you been planted on here by the or team to get rid of the likes of me?

Sb74 Sat 07-Dec-19 12:28:07

Pr

Esspee Sat 07-Dec-19 12:34:39

I'm Scottish and here I have not seen much evidence that those who voted leave did it because of racism. Farage and his ilk get almost no attention paid to them in Scotland, in fact we are very welcoming to incomers. In the last week alone a Brazilian and a Chinese separately told me how much they loved Glaswegians and how welcome they feel here.
Of more concern to Scots are subjects like having the right to our fish stocks.

Rhinestone Sat 07-Dec-19 12:43:43

Trying living in the states. So much hate because of Trump. Friends screaming over dinner at others who love him. People leaving long friendships because of him. My friends daughter and her mom don’t talk because the daughter can’t believe her mom still likes him. I understand and sympathize with your situation.

icanhandthemback Sat 07-Dec-19 12:52:58

Every time you vote in an election you are voting for something that impacts on people's lives because that is what elections are for. Brexit may remove "free movement", it won't remove movement between countries nor will it mean there will be no opportunity for young people to move abroad and take up posts there. There will certainly be more paperwork and more of a process to go through but we we were able to go to other countries before the EU and that won't change. It was harder when some countries were ruled by dictators but that isn't the case now.
I can't believe how intransigent most Remainers are. I don't know of any Leavers who have cut off Remainers because they have the temerity to vote differently but the same can't be said the other way round. It strikes me that the only thing Leavers have to do is Remain Quiet about how they voted because of the way they are vilified. My family are a mixture of Leave, Remain and Don't Know but we like each other enough to respect their views.

Sb74 Sat 07-Dec-19 12:55:35

I think the PR team is on a coffee break ?.

leyburn Sat 07-Dec-19 13:04:44

BREXIT hasn't caused division, refusal to accept a democratic vote has.

love0c Sat 07-Dec-19 13:04:58

Just been for a walk in our local park. A huge red bus plastered with 'STOP BREXIT' blocking the car park and taking up lots of car spaces. The people with this bus had placards that they were then waving in front of people's faces as they walked past! Very few people interacted with them. Come Thursday I hope the majority of voters do the same.

Sb74 Sat 07-Dec-19 13:13:02

@leyburn. I agree. I wanted to remain but I respect the outcome. I think for us to stop brexit now would make UK look like it doesn’t know what it’s doing and like a bunch of idiots. We just need to get in with it now.

Sb74 Sat 07-Dec-19 13:13:20

*on

JaneD666 Sat 07-Dec-19 13:28:33

Agree with @Authoress. Leaving the EU is not something that can be turned round with another General Election vote in 5 years - once we've left, we'd never get as good a deal to join again. And it's not like which football team you support - that doesn't affect people's lives the way that leaving the EU will. The big difference I notice between Leavers and Remainers is that Leavers think everything is going to be fine but Remainers know it won't be. That's why Remainers are so upset.

okimherenow Sat 07-Dec-19 13:30:23

The results of a football / rugby match are nothing like the results of a brexit..
That will last for decades and I happen to think with no benefits what so ever
So to compare sport tribalism to brexit / remain tribalism... Well nothing like the same impact.

varian Sat 07-Dec-19 13:30:52

Our democracy was totally corrupted by the fraudulent referendum which was won by lies, cheating and foreign interference.

Because of the proven illegality it would have been annulled had it been mandatory, but was not annulled because it was only advisory.

There is no reason for anyone to respect the result of a fraudulent referendum. It has damaged our democracy.

Those who call the Remainers "losers" are indulging in childish playground bullying "we won, you lost - ha ha ha".

This is not a game. If it is not stopped, brexit will badly affect the future of our children and grandchildren and has already cost us billions and our international reputation has been irrevocably damaged.

A senior British diplomat in Washington has quit her post, saying she is no longer prepared to "peddle half-truths" about Brexit on behalf of a Government she does not trust.

Alexandra Hall Hall, the lead envoy for Brexit at the British embassy, accused ministers of using "misleading or disingenuous" arguments about the implications of leaving the EU.

freyja Sat 07-Dec-19 13:44:12

I must admit @'Varvian' I am really not sure who to vote for but I am certain who I am Not voting for. How best to use my vote, is the question I suspect a lot of people are asking. Especially, if like me, you live in strong Tory constituency where the MP has done nothing but close hospitals, child care and services for the last 10 years and stick blindly to the party line regardless if it's what the people want.
The question I keep asking but get no answers, what is this election all about; is it to change the immediate social needs of our people after 10 years of Tory rule or Brexit. It seems those who only care about winning Brexit choose to ignore the neglect and harm the Tories have inflected on our country. They seem oblivious to the urgent needs of the vulnerable and make excuses for the hard working families who cannot feed their children.

What is going on here? How can we solve this? One thing for sure is that the Tories and their rallying cry to 'get Brexit done' is not the answer. If the majority of the elective members; our representatives, in both the House of Commons and the Lords voted against the Brexit plan three times, this included BJ, surely we should think that there must be something wrong with it. The MPs (for and against) must have felt it will not solve our immediate social needs or heal the country, but it may make it worse.

We must elect MPs we trust to examine all the options and make judgements on how best to respect the will of the people, not just those who voted to leave or those who voted to remain but the people who choose not to vote because they were unsure of the mixed messages they heard.
These same MPs must also work to address our immediate social needs and aim to make this a more fairer democratic country. The burden of responsibility is ours in the first instant by electing the MP, no easy task.

jennyvg Sat 07-Dec-19 13:47:23

I voted to leave the EU, my choice my decision, I am most certainly not racist, quite honestly I find it unbelievable that anyone would fall out with family and friends over something like this, grow up comes to mind!

Summerlove Sat 07-Dec-19 14:31:17

I think for us to stop brexit now would make UK look like it doesn’t know what it’s doing and like a bunch of idiots. We just need to get in with it now.

We are well past that.

ExperiencedNotOld Sat 07-Dec-19 14:51:21

I voted leave after taking some time to consider the evidence. As a professional information analyst I believe I’m entirely capable of forming my own decision, which was connected to longer term economics and a belief that the U.K. is better determining its own destiny without interference. There was no racist element, no dislike of foreigners, nothing dishonourable at all. As we live in a democracy I have the right to form an opinion that may differ from another person. No one is right and no one is wrong - and isn’t that just what’s gone wrong? We’ve worked own way to only accepting what YOU believe as mattering.
There s some rather distasteful mud slinging in this forum. What are any of you gaining from it?