Gransnet forums

News & politics

Day to day experience; racisim as a a part of life for some!

(105 Posts)

GNHQ have commented on this thread. Read here.

Madgran77 Tue 04-Aug-20 17:49:19

Lots of discussion recently about racism in Britain and racial profiling. Interesting article that describes it as a part of life for some!

www.theguardian.com/football/2020/aug/03/tottenham-danny-rose-tired-of-police-stopping-him-to-ask-if-car-is-stolen?CMP=fb_gu&utm_medium=Social&utm_source=Facebook&fbclid=IwAR0LxzGZ00EVcMxdemZuQ19oUnEOBBVKttpl3038ThQBOs8Gx-3Cl9rJ4Cs#Echobox=1596525039

Madgran77 Wed 05-Aug-20 07:15:09

I started it because I think it is an interesting , highly relevant subject of our time and I thought the article a very articulate description of a problem in our society that we should st least be aware of ..as in the experiences of a significant proportion of our society. The only outrage and hostility has been caused, sadly, by one specific approach to commenting. Other than that people have expressed clear open views, listened and responded to others and I think there is potential to continue an interesting and thought provoking discussion from which each can take and learn as they see fit.

If we always avoid subjects that might potentially but dont have to cause outrage or hostility, then things will never change and we dont get the chance to learn from each other.

crazyH Wed 05-Aug-20 07:17:15

I am of mixed race, mixed cultures and "mixed " colour. Other than being complimented for the tone and colour of my skin, I have not experienced any form of negativity or racism. So you the British, can be proud of yourselves (from my perspective) and I play my part, by trying to conform.

Furret Wed 05-Aug-20 07:21:55

Fenella12

Furret thank you. Yes, it is. I now live in an affluent area, where I have never noticed any racism. I am well dressed, and I believe that people tend to notice the clothes before the colour.

That is so true (about the clothes), I commented earlier how envious I felt of the lovely cool clothes worn by Asian women in the recent heatwave.

I too wonder about levels of racism in different communities. Our town in a university town and the feeling I get is that differences here are accepted and diversity welcomed. I have come across a lot less covert racism here.

Esspee Wed 05-Aug-20 07:42:04

I have experienced casual racism against me on many occasions. What so many fail to realise is that “being different” brings out the worst in so many people regardless of what that difference is. (Class, sex, colour of skin, age, disability etc.)

In most cases I admit it could easily be overlooked but I am highly sensitive to slights like this as my family is a melting pot of races.

I have encountered low grade racism directed at me in every country I have lived in and many countries I have visited.
It is abhorrent and I would love to be able to say that I always call people out on it but frankly when you are the one who is different it is frankly scary to do so because you don’t know whether mild racism is unconscious or a sign of deep hatred.

On the odd occasion I have been threatened with physical violence because of my race and have reported this to the authorities but the mild slights are noted and ignored. (e.g. having shop assistants deliberately ignore me)

Unfortunately it happens the world over.

Fenella12 Wed 05-Aug-20 07:59:14

Madgran77 I was a teacher at the school, not a child. Sorry, I should have been clearer.

Missfoodlove Wed 05-Aug-20 08:30:49

My SIL is mixed race and drives an expensive car.
He is always getting stopped in London where he works but not so much in Cheshire where they live.
He takes it on the chin.
He does not see it as racism but proactive policing.

Esspee Wed 05-Aug-20 08:33:20

Missfoodlove That is in no way proactive policing!

Madgran77 Wed 05-Aug-20 08:44:06

Fenella12 Oh right! In that case it is inexcusable that the headteacher did nit discuss with you and use your skills and experience re gge message!

Madgran77 Wed 05-Aug-20 08:46:57

*My SIL is mixed race and drives an expensive car.He is always getting stopped in London where he works but not so much in Cheshire where they live. He takes it on the chin.
He does not see it as racism but proactive policing.*

I have just read these statistics in The Times this morning:

*Black people in London are nearly 4 times more likely than a white person to be stopped
* 80% of searches lead to no action

Practice policing??? Hmmm!

ladymuck Wed 05-Aug-20 09:38:48

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Fenella12 Wed 05-Aug-20 09:58:05

Message deleted by Gransnet as it repeats a post that has since been deleted. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

biba70 Wed 05-Aug-20 10:05:58

Ladymuck, one of the worst comments I have so far read on Gransnet. Shame on you.

Fenella12 Wed 05-Aug-20 10:18:43

I am wondering now, Ladymuck if your comment is an attempt to get the thread deleted?
To be honest, if I were a mumsnet moderater, I wouldn't delete the thread, but rather be having words with you about your poor attitude towards people of colour.

25Avalon Wed 05-Aug-20 10:35:05

We need to judge people on their character and not the colour of their skin. To do this we need to communicate and interact with one another rather than be divisive. If a bame person gets a job it should be because they are good at it not because they are bame - the latter is insulting to bame people.

Interestingly in the American Civil War a lot of Northerners felt uncomfortable with black Americans because many had no knowledge of them. It’s not just about freedom but acceptance of people for what they are and to do that we need to get to know them. When I went to university the first thing I noticed about one of our group was the astigmatisms in one eye but once I got to know her I never noticed it.

Fenella12 Wed 05-Aug-20 11:02:40

Sorry, gransnet, not mumsnet!

GagaJo Wed 05-Aug-20 11:30:26

Fenella, my ex husband is black. He told me about the behaviour of people towards black people on buses and demonstrated it for me. The bus was over full, but the seat next to him was the last seat left empty, even while people were standing.

I knew the uk was racist before I married him, but it was an eye opener, the comments, assumptions, attitudes. Even rude remarks about our child.

The area I live in now, I thought was a nice area. But since my now adult daughter and grandson moved here to live with me (necessity), my eyes have been opened. I'm planning on moving to the multicultural area of the city before grandson starts school, because he can't grow up with this racism and be the only brown person in the school.

25Avalon Wed 05-Aug-20 11:32:56

Esspee I think this is part of the problem that when people say or do bad things to you then you do get sensitised and you will see remarks that were perhaps not intended to be offensive as just that. We need to be more sensitive in the way we treat people. For example I had words with a trans player the same as I would with any player but she got quite aggressive primarily because she has received so much abuse from a lot of hateful people. I realised I should have been more sensitive in my approach and apologised.
Regarding not being served in shops that invariably happens to me as well so I’m not sure if it’s down to colour or age so much as down to rude assistants. I tell myself I must be wearing Harry Potter’s cloak of invisibility again!

Fenella12 Wed 05-Aug-20 12:11:15

Gaga Jo thank you for your comments. I think you will be wise, regarding moving to a multicultural area for your grandson.
Part of my problems in life are due to the fact that I was completely unsupported as a child, in regards to my ethnicity. My father was a Windrush immigrant, and a founding member of the Caribbean Cricket Club in Leeds. He actively discouraged any discussion on race. Until I was five, my playmates were all of my own ethnicity, but, I lost touch with them as we lived in a different part of Leeds, so I was one of only two brown children at school in the early 1950s, where I experienced very many racist incidents.
My younger sister says she was not affected, but has had counselling many times in her life and is currently having counselling, in her sixties, so I think she was just as much affected as I was.

25Avalon I think this is part of the problem that when people say or do bad things to you then you do get sensitised and you will see remarks that were perhaps not intended to be offensive as just that
This too is part of the problem - being told that people of colour are 'too senstive' to remarks that are not intended as offensive. I have heard very many remarks that were followed by the words 'no offence meant,' or, 'I don't mean you, of course.'
I have reached a point in my life now (late sixties) where I will tell people that offence has actually been taken, whether or not it was intended.
Until I reached my late fifties, my reaction was to try to play it down, or to go off and cry!

MawB Wed 05-Aug-20 12:31:49

MawB

Message deleted by Gransnet as it repeated a post which has since been deleted. Here's a link to our <a target="_blank" rel="noopener" href="https://www.gransnet.com/info/netiquette">Talk Guidelines.</a>

I merely asked who Tony Morris was! And you deleted it?
FFS GNHQ

25Avalon Wed 05-Aug-20 14:10:32

Fenella12 to clarify what I meant was that anybody who has suffered abuse will be more sensitive to thoughtless remarks and we all need to be more understanding of that. If I beat my dog everyday it will come to expect me to continue to behave like that even when I stop and will cower away. Saying “no offence” to me shows someone is really being offensive and know it. If it might cause offence don’t say it. Good on you for speaking up. If people are rude or insensitive enough to say things they need to be told and hopefully apologise.

moggie57 Wed 05-Aug-20 14:16:12

in my charity shop always we get it....customer because i'm black that you wont give me a discount.... so me being silly says well i'm white and i dont get one either..... lol....

Fenella12 Wed 05-Aug-20 14:35:10

25Avalon thank you for clarifying, I understand what you mean and I do agree.

AGAA4 Wed 05-Aug-20 14:49:32

I find it very sad that people, any people, can be constantly hurt by racism. Racists have no respect, compassion or empathy for anyone who is different to themselves.

welbeck Wed 05-Aug-20 15:31:22

i was in a charity shop once going through the books, when i heard a black woman who had been looking around ask to speak to the manager. she told her that she objected that since she had entered the shop, a volunteer assistant, an older woman had been following her around, and that it was racist.
she was very calm, and i realised it was true. nobody else was shadowed like that. i was at the bookshelves so long that i might have aroused suspicion, but no interest on me. only her. i admired her for speaking up. and you fenella.

Madgran77 Wed 05-Aug-20 15:33:40

I haver been out most of the day and was sorry to come back and find that deletions had been needed by GNHQ ..but good to see that it is now back on track.

Fenella your are right about being told that people of colour are 'too sensitive' to remarks that are not intended as offensive. Intended or not many remarks are offensive and that should be listened to! (Avalon I know you clarified your comments and did not mean that)

Fenella I have been pondering on your earlier remark about "unconscious racism". I do think that it can exist...in terms of assumptions being made about someone because of the colour of their skin or because of the culture. Someone may be aware that they are categorising/making an assumption and feel that that is entirely valid based on their experiences. They may not realise that those very assumptions ARE racist because they are not based on the individual but on a generalised view of that "people who are that colour" or "people from that culture"! So they are aware of what they view as a valid assumption but are unaware of the inherent racism in that¬! Does that make sense?