Gransnet forums

News & politics

Could you imagine Mrs Thatcher breaking the law?

(216 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Wed 09-Sept-20 07:47:46

Thatcher is someone I disagreed with passionately, but I respected her ability, honesty and strength of character.

What Johnson us proposing would never, never have been given a moments thought by Thatcher.

She respected the British constitution and standing throughout the world.

Thatcher gain her reputation throughout the world for standing up for just that.

We are going to lose everything and celebrate the fact with Festival!!

God spare us

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Sept-20 08:17:49

Heads of civil service letter.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Sept-20 08:20:35

Good article about our corrupt neofascist government.

t.co/p7joX0J1HK?amp=1

MaizieD Fri 11-Sept-20 08:27:03

Urmstongran

Shall we have another thread about the treat negotiations? Otherwise we will end up conflating that important topic with this one about Maggie Thatcher.
?

The whole point of this thread was the unbelieveable statement from the NI Minister that the proposed legislation would breach international law and that Thatcher would never have done such a thing.

Maybe it was a bit too subtle for some people...

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Sept-20 08:53:27

It amuses me at the way the Brexiters rant on about this. Fictitious enemy.

We have left the EU all bar the shouting.

We are now trying to negotiate a trade deal, which we will be doing with every other country in the world.

Doesn’t bode well does it if this is anything to go by?

Of course it was sold as the easiest thing in the world, and those warning that it wouldn’t be easy were told project fear.

Hmmm.

Urmstongran Fri 11-Sept-20 08:57:08

Apologies MaizieD you are of course correct. That said, a more directly worded thread might garner more replies.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Sept-20 09:00:18

Urmstongran

Apologies MaizieD you are of course correct. That said, a more directly worded thread might garner more replies.

Blimey ug we aren’t primary school age!!

growstuff Fri 11-Sept-20 09:34:27

My understanding of the OP was how much the UK has sunk morally. It's already lost much of its power militaristically and economically on the world stage, but it did have a good reputation as a stable country which respected that law is the guiding principle of how the country is run, as it has been since the Magna Carta.

I didn't agree with Thatcher at all, but I do think she had ethical standards and would not have broken international law, as is now being proposed by this despicable government.

The UK has become a laughing stock. One respectable German newspaper just laughs at the UK. Johnson himself is described as a "spätimperialistischer Oxfordschnösel" (late imperialist Oxford snotty-nosed brat).

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Sept-20 10:07:12

Late imperialist Oxford snotty nosed brat.

I shall never think of Johnson any other way now ??

Callistemon Fri 11-Sept-20 10:11:25

Threads meander.

ClareAB Fri 11-Sept-20 10:11:42

I don't know if Thatcher broke any laws. She did bulldoze over ethics, morals, compassion and decency towards the most vulnerable of society. She may have been a 'conviction politician' but she was a monster.

Callistemon Fri 11-Sept-20 10:12:42

Theresa May would not have broken the law either.

MaizieD Fri 11-Sept-20 10:36:32

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

growstuff Fri 11-Sept-20 10:38:04

ClareAB

I don't know if Thatcher broke any laws. She did bulldoze over ethics, morals, compassion and decency towards the most vulnerable of society. She may have been a 'conviction politician' but she was a monster.

I agree with you, but the question is whether she would actually have treated the law with such contempt and I don't think she would have done. Apart from being a scientist, she was also a barrister. PMQs between Thatcher and Starmer would have been interesting. hmm

Callistemon Fri 11-Sept-20 10:39:37

MaizieD

Whitewavemark2

Late imperialist Oxford snotty nosed brat.

I shall never think of Johnson any other way now ??

I'm afraid that 'fat slob' is still my no. 1 grin

Blimey ug we aren’t primary school age!!

Really?

Pantglas2 Fri 11-Sept-20 10:41:54

I’d have paid good money to see that too Growstuff! I suspect Starmer would be too gentlemanly to cope though - she rarely thought any man was her equal and regularly gave them short shrift!

Alegrias Fri 11-Sept-20 10:46:37

Oh, dear, Bodach don't be taken in by the attitude to Churchill in Scotland after the war, which was of course positive because of his leadership. Dundee hated him as well.
He was MP for Dundee for 14 years 1908 - 1922. Rarely visited and stayed in a local hotel when he did. Sent in the Black Watch to control demonstrations in the city. Eventually he lost his seat to the only Temperance MP ever, Edwin Scrymgeour. As he left Dundee after losing he said “I will see the grass grow green over the industrial wasteland of Dundee.” A real charmer.

Sorry, I've gone off topic again.

growstuff Fri 11-Sept-20 10:46:38

We all knew where we stood with Thatcher. When she was defeated, it was because people had had enough of so-called Thatcherite policies - and, of course, Blair was the new kid on the block.

I think it's all about personalities now, although I do think that ploy us wearing a bit thin. Can anybody actually list any "Johnsonite" policies? Which three words would people use to describe the government?

growstuff Fri 11-Sept-20 10:49:11

Pantglas2

I’d have paid good money to see that too Growstuff! I suspect Starmer would be too gentlemanly to cope though - she rarely thought any man was her equal and regularly gave them short shrift!

I think she'd have the upper hand too, although she might have pushed Starmer to new highs. At the moment, the only challenge he has is to supervise a petulant toddler.

growstuff Fri 11-Sept-20 10:50:32

At least it would have been an intelligent debate.

Callistemon Fri 11-Sept-20 12:36:20

Which three words would people use to describe the government?
grin

do you want us all banned from GN?

paddyanne Fri 11-Sept-20 12:57:58

Bodach I can assure you I got that information from FAMILY who were at that demo.Its been whitewashed as much of history has ,in favour of the MUCH hated Churchill over the years.Not just for the george Sq bebacle but for the 1000's of SCOTTISH soldiers abandoned in the Dunhirk campaign and the remarks made by him about them being "NO GREAT LOSS" My uncles were all AT Dunkirk ,all came home damaged physically or mentally .Churchill wasn't the GREAT leader he was claimed to be .Maybe read some REAL history about the evil man and the millions of deaths he was responsible for.Oh and Sparkling I'm Scottish NOT English and I ;m not really interested in English history....except where it has affected the running of MY country to its detriment .That sadly has been a lot and hopefuly not for much longer .

Jaberwok Fri 11-Sept-20 13:17:11

The Royal Norfolks and the Ox and Bucks were also left behind paddyann. My mother's cousin was killed when the O &B were surrounded and were fought to a standstill! My father was killed while serving in Bomber command, and another uncle killed in North Africa. It wasn't only Scottish families who suffered loss during that war.

Callistemon Fri 11-Sept-20 13:32:26

Oh and Sparkling I'm Scottish NOT English and I ;m not really interested in English history.

grin
That could be described as one of your more daft statements, paddyann!

Alegrias Fri 11-Sept-20 13:41:08

Oh and Sparkling I'm Scottish NOT English and I'm not really interested in English history.

Why's that daft Callistemon? Seems pretty factual to me... paddyanne can be interested or not interested in whatever she likes.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 11-Sept-20 13:47:25

View from Washington:

The UK is in a very weak negotiating position. Not only is it much more dependent on the EU for trade and the hopes of a UK-US deal have evaporated, but it has been hit economically, by the pandemic, harder than any partners. ~AA