Gransnet forums

News & politics

Who will be left in the Labour Party?

(372 Posts)
trisher Tue 01-Dec-20 09:46:02

Angela Rayner is apparently willing to suspend "thousands of members" in order to tackle antisemitism, so is she right? Is it as widespread as she imaginesor is it once again a fight between the LP members and its leadership. And if they are all suspended who will be left?
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/labour-angela-rayner-antisemitism-thousands-suspended-jeremy-corbyn-b1763577.html

trisher Wed 16-Dec-20 21:50:17

I have searched and can find no evidence that this project is actually asking or taking money from anyone at the moment. It is a limited company with 2 directors. Attendance at the launch is free. If someone has information about requests for money please could they post a link?

Retiredwell Wed 16-Dec-20 22:01:25

Devorgilla, there is much I can agree with in your above post. Regarding funding, you may recall that Len McCluskey a few weeks back informed the Labour Party General Secretary that the Unite Union was to reduce its financial support to the party by 10% in the current financial year. He added that the reduction had been agreed within the Unite General Executive Committee and finances saved would be put towards new political initiatives brought forward.

Therefore it is probable that Peace & Justice have received that funding to initiate its startup and finance the organisation until its status and structures are finalised prior to the full launch on 17th of January. I have not seen the new organisation calling for additional donations publicly, but others may have different information.

However, there is obviously "much water to flow under the bridge" between now and the middle of January" with many individuals and organisations to take up their stance on the developments brought about.

As I side matter, I read that Lisa Nandy has stated she will be backing Peace & Justice. Could she be about to desert Starmer or just backing both horses?????

Devorgilla Wed 16-Dec-20 22:28:24

Grany on page 9 states that she has joined but does not indicate whether a subscription was required. Perhaps she could shed light on that side.
Perhaps Lisa Nandy knows it is a new political party and is planning to stand for them, or perhaps she is unaware that is its purpose, in which case she should, for the time being, imo, err on the side of caution.
If it is to be an umbrella organisation worldwide to forward the course of peace and justice then there is merit in that. There is clearly much to be achieved.

Grany Thu 17-Dec-20 09:27:00

No Devorgilla paid no subscription just signed up to the Peace and Justice project launch as has thousands of others too.

Retiredwell Thu 17-Dec-20 09:51:12

That's right Grany have just signed up to the project myself. Anyone else interested can follow the below link to support the movement at no cost at this stage.

thecorbynproject.com/what-we-do/?fbclid=IwAR0JpOT35MP7fqg7K7ztdy0h_yc71OYSWevbdRf_NE1iA5ZsJQug5tQLArM

prestbury Thu 17-Dec-20 11:50:20

trisher

I have searched and can find no evidence that this project is actually asking or taking money from anyone at the moment. It is a limited company with 2 directors. Attendance at the launch is free. If someone has information about requests for money please could they post a link?

thecorbynproject.com/donate/

prestbury Thu 17-Dec-20 11:53:49

I should add, with the above link that if you were to go through the donate process (without actually completing it) it also asks you to signify if you are a tax payer so that additional tax relief can be gained.

Devorgilla Thu 17-Dec-20 14:00:04

Thank you Grany and prestbury for taking the time to clear up those issues. I take it the donations, at this stage, would be voluntary and not part of the process of joining the launch. All will be revealed in the New Year.

lemongrove Thu 17-Dec-20 14:06:17

It looks exactly like the sort of thing that Corbyn enjoys, am guessing there will be lots of earnest discussions and a committee or two and that nothing much of a practical nature will ever be done before it quietly folds.
Why on earth head any new group with a failed leader?

trisher Thu 17-Dec-20 14:47:53

Thanks prestbury and others, I was searching for Peace and Justice project, only news items seemed to come up.
lemon I don't think you can accuse Corbyn of inactivity or lack of involvement in Peace activism. He has a long history of talking to those who are sometimes excluded from negotiations. Hence 2 Peace prizes

Anniebach Thu 17-Dec-20 16:06:21

He certainly did, his friends Hamas and Hezbollah, the I.R.A.

trisher Thu 17-Dec-20 16:43:13

Exactly Annie the political wings of all of those organisations have developed and grown. They brought peace to N. Ireland and they have the potential to bring peace to Palestine. By talking to them peace comes one step closer.

Anniebach Thu 17-Dec-20 17:28:40

Yet he said he was wrong to call Hamas and Hezbollah his friends.

trisher Thu 17-Dec-20 17:36:07

Perhaps he was referring to the terrorist wings of the organisations Annie. And anyway that's all the better, if you only talk to people you consider your friends you can never reach a compromise, and peace always involves compromise.

WishIwasyounger Thu 17-Dec-20 17:36:36

We can talk to groups without calling them friend's can't we. No one can accuse Jeremy Corbyn of being against peace or a terrorist, though you can accuse him of being a poor leader.

Retiredwell Thu 17-Dec-20 17:43:17

Ever since Starmer's election as leader we have seen posts on this forum and throughout social media stating that the influence of left needs to be eliminated from the Labour Party. Now through the startup of the Peace & Justice project, the left in the Labour Party will have a new rallying point to place their views.

Should it be that Peace & Justice becomes a full-blown political party in Britain those of the left will undoubtedly transfer their energies to that organisation along with the trade unions affiliations.

Surely Starmer and all who support him will have all they could wish for in having the present Labour Party entirely in the hands of the right and through that draw in financial donations from commercial interests and very wealthy private people.

However, throughout social media since the announcement of the formation of Peace & Justice, there are numerous posts and tweets downplaying and regretting the formation when it would be expected that the right in the Labour Party would have been encouraging such a move. The right in the party will have achieved their wish with a successful launch in seeing the departure of left and trade union influence in the Labour Party.

Therefore I cannot understand the reluctance of seeing the formation of Peace & Justice by those of the right in the Labour Party and the lack of enthusiasm to see it succeed.

Devorgilla Thu 17-Dec-20 20:36:17

Retiredwell, if, as you seem to indicate quite strongly, and you do give the impression of being in the 'know' about these matters, that this pressure group is going to emerge as a new political party exclusively for the left of the party who were in the Corbyn court, then I personally believe they should come clean about that now. It does matter to people whether they are signing up for a political party or a pressure group. I would have preferred to see this launch done, without having to sign up, on a platform such as YouTube where anyone could listen to it. I don't like my data out there until I know it is an organisation I want to be associated with. Many members in the Party are to the left, but not in the Corbyn mould. I expect many of those will remain in the Labour Party.
It is quite usual, with their connections and influence, for retired leaders to take on projects but they don't normally try to replace their own Party. If the real purpose is a new party they should have the guts to nail their colours to the mast from the very start.

Ilovecheese Thu 17-Dec-20 20:41:11

It is just retiredwell 's opinion, nothing more, nothing fishy going on. Wishful thinking I suspect.

I was pleased to see that Keir Starmer thinks it is appalling that UNICEF is feeding children in our country. This is the sort of issue he should be highlighting.

MayBee70 Thu 17-Dec-20 20:42:58

I’ve never said that the influence of the left should be eliminated. I agree with good, socialist principles. Wouldn’t support the party if that wasn’t the case. What I don’t want the extreme left of the party to do is constantly undermine a new party leader and shadow cabinet that are holding this government to account far more than the previous leader did in the whole time he held that position. And acknowledge the fact that the new leader that the left are trying so hard to get rid of is actually electable. And you can’t achieve anything if you can’t get elected.

trisher Thu 17-Dec-20 21:31:52

MayBee70 but what those on the left really fear is an administration like Blair's which tinkers a little but does nothing to really change anything, which in effect is so similar to the Tories it is difficult to see the difference sometimes. They think that it is those policies which ultimately are responsible for the very real poverty in the UK now and only a radical change can stop that happening again. It's possible to see in Blair's failures to build social housing, to support the unions and repeal anti-union legislation, his acceptance of zero-hours contracts and his falure to introduce real socialst policies the roots of today's poverty. And the left wing want to stop that and change things.

MayBee70 Thu 17-Dec-20 22:31:00

But people didn’t/wouldn’t vote for that would they. Even after years of austerity. The very people that Labour are trying to help won’t vote for it. Can you tell me what Corbyn achieved during his leadership?

Retiredwell Fri 18-Dec-20 08:07:50

Devorgilla regarding your post of 20:36 yesterday, I have no greater knowledge of whether Peace & Justice will become a political party other than what I see happening within the Labour Party and within the Unite Union of which I am a member.

As with very many Unite Union Branches the one I am a member of has passed a resolution demanding of the General Executive that all funding of the present Labour Party should stop and that Unite should not continue it's affiliation to that party while it does not subscribe to the basic core values of the broader Labour Movement in Britain.

The forgoing has been brought about as it is clear that a right wing element in the Labour Party Central Office worked against a Leader (Jeremy Corbyn) throughout his four years as leader having been elected twice with the largest majority ever seen by the Party . In that, those people also used funding given by me and all who paid the political levy in the trade unions throughout those years to act against Corbyn and all those that stood for election in full support of him.

The persons that carried out the above have now been paid off by for their services by Starmer and therefore all on the left of the Labour Party and those within left leaning affiliate organisations are very aware that there is no place for them or their views in the present leader's party.

Therefore I and many thousands of others who are members or affiliate members of the party are very much hoping that Peace & Justice does form into a political party for then there will be a fresh home for our views and funding. I firmly believe that the rifts in the Labour Party are now too deep to be repaired and therefore a division of the Broader Labour Movement in Britain from this Parliamentary Labour Party is required, and Peace & Justice gives an opportunity for that to come about.

Grany Fri 18-Dec-20 08:18:10

Labour under Jeremy Corbyn holds the record for the number 41 of u turns the government has had to make.

He had the biggest Labour membership party in the whole of Europe and brought the party from debt to credit.

He always spoke out and still does about injustices and championing rights for the poor, disadvantaged and workers rights.

He has always been on the right side of history Speaking up about the PFI that Blair introduced. And spoke out about the Iraq war.

And Richard Burgon yesterday
Wrote an open letter to Labour Leadership
Stand up for Labour Party Democracy

www.instagram.com/p/CI6ueJrFW7D/?
igshid=mmnvgo8bo7lb

I agree with what trisher said. 21:31

Galaxy Fri 18-Dec-20 08:22:44

I am crying with laughter about complaints about social media behaviour bearing in mind what is going on in this thread. Could there be a better example of transference.

Iam64 Fri 18-Dec-20 08:38:55

I can't think of one Galaxy.