Gransnet forums

News & politics

I do wonder- is this what the Brexiters wanted?

(571 Posts)
Kali2 Tue 11-May-21 13:24:02

Free Movement of people agreed with India in exchange for Deal?

Kamiso Tue 18-May-21 01:07:11

I don’t have a problem with Indians coming to the U.K. The area I am in is very mixed and multicultural which makes life more interesting. They work hard and are very community minded. They also make the best samosas.

There seem to be quite a few Eastern Europeans as well. Presumably they chose to stay.

nanna8 Tue 18-May-21 01:13:37

We hit the worst airport we had ever come across just before Brexit and this was Manchester. It was totally and embarrassingly appalling. Hopelessly long queues, fussy people checking just about everyone. We were flying out not coming in, it took hours to get through. I will never go near the place again. We have travelled a lot through many countries, including China, Vietnam,Cambodia, Eastern Europe etc. Nothing as bad.

growstuff Tue 18-May-21 01:27:22

nanna8 This isn't just about airport queues. It's about making something which was very simple more complicated and expensive.

growstuff Tue 18-May-21 01:29:01

Kamiso

I don’t have a problem with Indians coming to the U.K. The area I am in is very mixed and multicultural which makes life more interesting. They work hard and are very community minded. They also make the best samosas.

There seem to be quite a few Eastern Europeans as well. Presumably they chose to stay.

I doubt very much whether the couple of thousand of Indians who will be coming to the UK without work visas will be making samosas.

MaizieD Tue 18-May-21 08:10:11

growstuff

nanna8 This isn't just about airport queues. It's about making something which was very simple more complicated and expensive.

I've been saying that for ages and ages, but apparently we have to stop complaining and be grateful that we're no longer being privileged over people from other, non-EU countries.

I still have absolutely no idea whatsoever what we have gained from leaving the EU.

I do know what we have lost...

Urmstongran Tue 18-May-21 08:28:34

There’s a lot of negativity on this thread. ?
Aren’t some of these new rules (travelling to France for example) Covid driven and not Brexit-related?

Most travellers visit Europe for a holiday anyway and stay in holiday accommodation. A tiny percentage go over to visit and stay with family.

vegansrock Tue 18-May-21 08:32:08

Lots of people stay with family/ friends, we used to drive down to see family staying in chambres d’hôte as we went along ( not booking ahead, That freedom’s gone now. ☹️

growstuff Tue 18-May-21 08:33:00

Urmstongran

There’s a lot of negativity on this thread. ?
Aren’t some of these new rules (travelling to France for example) Covid driven and not Brexit-related?

Most travellers visit Europe for a holiday anyway and stay in holiday accommodation. A tiny percentage go over to visit and stay with family.

No, they're not Covid-driven. So you don't care one jot about those who visit family? For goodness sake! Where on earth do you get your news?

growstuff Tue 18-May-21 08:34:04

Of course there's negativity. Nobody in their right mind chooses to make something more difficult for no discernible gain.

Urmstongran Tue 18-May-21 08:43:16

I do care growstuff but if that’s how Macron wants to play it (annoying the hell out of his own citizens in the process) there’s not much can be done about it. The voters in France could perhaps lobby their MP’s pointing out how displeased they are? However I still maintain it only affects a small proportion of visitors so nothing will be done about it.

Urmstongran Tue 18-May-21 08:51:05

I see Kali2 has started another thread about travel between the UK & France. This one has morphed from ostensibly being about travelling from India!

nanna8 Tue 18-May-21 08:52:14

If you are from Scotland is it (unofficially) easier to visit France? Just wondering.

Ellianne Tue 18-May-21 09:05:02

nanna8

If you are from Scotland is it (unofficially) easier to visit France? Just wondering.

Don't think so nanna8, but as I am part Welsh my Breton friends might smuggle me in more easily!

In all seriousness, there's no problem on an Irish passport.

Greta Tue 18-May-21 09:24:48

Just another 'little hiccup' thanks to Brexit:

^”A number of long-term British citizens have expressed alarm at receiving letters from the Home Office telling them they risk losing the right to work, benefits and free healthcare unless they apply for UK immigration status in the next six weeks.
Campaigners said they were concerned that the “scattergun” mailshot, which was sent out to thousands of people instructing them to apply for EU settled status before the end of June, revealed weaknesses in the Home Office’s databases, and a lack of bureaucratic clarity about who has the right to live in the UK.
The letter, which was wrongly sent to numerous people who have lived in the UK for over 40 years, states: “The United Kingdom has left the European Union, so to carry on living in the UK after 30 June 2021, you and your family members need to have a UK immigration status,” the letter states.”^

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/may/17/immigration-letter-sent-to-long-term-british-citizens-causes-alarm

MaizieD Tue 18-May-21 09:55:26

growstuff

Of course there's negativity. Nobody in their right mind chooses to make something more difficult for no discernible gain.

Careful, growstuff, you're using words of more than one syllable. A bit much for our self confessed bear of little brain to take in...

My response to the idiotic comment on negativity is short and not to be used on Gnet.

growstuff Tue 18-May-21 10:00:51

Pah! I'm going A-WOL. (Got things to do)

PS Any real Pooh fans will understand the reference.

MaizieD Tue 18-May-21 10:14:29

'Bisy, backson', eh, *growstuff? grin

Peasblossom Tue 18-May-21 10:22:08

growstuff

Of course there's negativity. Nobody in their right mind chooses to make something more difficult for no discernible gain.

I wonder if you’d accept that whilst you and many other benefitted from membership of the EU, a large number of peoples’ experience was that their lives had changed for the worse.

Do you really expect that people who lost their jobs, homes and saw their families in need should care deeply that you now have to do more paperwork to get to France for your holiday?

When you were doing well you didn’t care what was happening to them.

Alegrias1 Tue 18-May-21 10:45:31

a large number of peoples’ experience was that their lives had changed for the worse.

Got any evidence for that? And I don't mean UKIP rantings, either.

MaizieD Tue 18-May-21 10:54:55

I wonder if you’d accept that whilst you and many other benefitted from membership of the EU, a large number of peoples’ experience was that their lives had changed for the worse.

And have their lives now changed for the better?

I very much doubt it.

And, now we just have the people working in Brexit affected businesses added to them. Fishers, meat farmers, wine merchants, musicians, lots of small businesses built on the EU market...

Nothing like a bit of levelling down to keep everyone happy...

Peasblossom Tue 18-May-21 11:00:22

I know you want to think that people voted out because of lies and false promises, but around where I come from, people voted out because they didn’t like what their lives had become. It was that simple.

I’ve said it before, but if only those who were riding high had acknowledged the negative impact of membership of the EU and supported communities through change then we wouldn’t have had Brexit.

But they didn’t. It really was a case of I’m alright Jack. And now it’s moans about holiday homes.

How the other half live?

Dinahmo Tue 18-May-21 11:06:46

nanna8

When we went to Europe we were separated out from those with European residence but it was just a rubber stamp sort of thing. Sometimes we had to have a visa, sometimes not. It didn’t actually make much difference, maybe an extra 10 minutes in a queue.

When did you last go to Europe?

Peasblossom Tue 18-May-21 11:07:28

You wouldn’t acknowledge it then and you won’t acknowledge it now. A lot of people weren’t happy. If everyone had been doing well they wouldn’t have voted out.

Will lives be better. Some no doubt. Winners and losers.
For a while you were the winners and you didn’t care about the losers.

Now you’re losing you free travel to holiday homes. How would you have felt if it was your job and your only home?
Would you have voted to stay in!

Alegrias1 Tue 18-May-21 11:10:48

You have no idea what I want to think "Peasblossom".

What I know is that many people voted out because they had been told for 40-odd years that the EC/EEC/EU was the cause of all their problems. There was no "negative impact" of the membership of the EU that made lives worse for vast swathes of the population, despite what the Brexiters told them. Blame the UK government for not running the country properly.

I think people knew exactly what they were voting for when they voted out. However what they were voting for was based on falsehoods about why their lives were bad.

As for thinking people are complaining about their holiday homes - get a grip.

MaizieD Tue 18-May-21 11:12:35

I know you want to think that people voted out because of lies and false promises, but around where I come from, people voted out because they didn’t like what their lives had become. It was that simple.

I don't suppose they thought to connect it with a tory austerity policy which slashed jobs along with state spending? And was completely indifferent to the plight of people not in work..

If I recall rightly you're speaking about a rural population, aren't you, Peasblossom? I thought that in a previous recent discussion the conclusion seemed to be that it was changing patterns of agriculture that had affected them rather than the EU? No year round employment because of seasonal monoculture?