Gransnet forums

News & politics

Would the EU ever trust us and want us back???

(304 Posts)
Kali2 Sun 25-Jul-21 09:19:46

Let's imagine the majority of people in the UK change their mind about leaving. Comes a new PM next election, who is pro EU and wants to negotiate a return, with the backing of a strong majority of the population, say 65% + -

what would the EU say?

As many headlines around the world have been saying this week- Can the UK ever be trusted again?

25Avalon Sun 25-Jul-21 17:08:14

Alegrias1

25Avalon

The vaccine development and roll out in uk.

The Oxford lab suffered a huge gap in funding after the EU money was removed and the roll-out was done by Bingham and the NHS.

Next?

Not quite right. In January 2020 the UK Government gave more than £33million of funding on top of £5million given earlier making it the largest overall source of money. We paid for vaccines before they were reliable and available.

Gwyneth Sun 25-Jul-21 17:14:42

As you say Frenchie no Priti Patel so why are migrants risking their lives to leave France if the UK is such a dreadful place to live?

Kali2 Sun 25-Jul-21 17:24:03

Gwyneth, leave those desperate people out of this argument, this is so below the belt and totally wrong.

No-one has said the UK is a dreadful place to live- but that this PM, and this Government, are making every attempt to destroy what was so much better than elsewhere- our NHS, tolerance, openess, acceptance of differences in a positive way- and so much more.

Kandinsky Sun 25-Jul-21 17:28:49

Why are they so desperate if they’re being looked after in France?
I genuinely don’t get why they risk their lives to come here?
They’re already in a safe country.
No one ever seems able to fully explain it.

Kali2 Sun 25-Jul-21 17:30:17

And totally eroded the respect and trust other nations had for the UK.

So it is actually saying that the reason so many of us feel truly sad and more about this, is because it was so much better than most. I know you won't believe this, but it is the truth.

Kandinsky Sun 25-Jul-21 17:33:37

And totally eroded the respect and trust other nations had for the UK

The average person in the Uk couldn’t give a toss tbh, even if it is true.

Kali2 Sun 25-Jul-21 17:46:51

Oh I am sure they will when the shelves are bare, their jobs gone, medicines scarce and the NHS on its knees... and more.

Leave those desperate immigrants out of this- it is just so wrong and vile - totally disgusting misuse of their situation.

Why do you think so many HGV drivers, agricultural and building workers, nhs nurses and carers, and so many have gone?

Alegrias1 Sun 25-Jul-21 17:50:38

25Avalon

Alegrias1

25Avalon

The vaccine development and roll out in uk.

The Oxford lab suffered a huge gap in funding after the EU money was removed and the roll-out was done by Bingham and the NHS.

Next?

Not quite right. In January 2020 the UK Government gave more than £33million of funding on top of £5million given earlier making it the largest overall source of money. We paid for vaccines before they were reliable and available.

From Adrian Hill, director at the Jenner Institute in Oxford, speaking in July 2020:

More generally across the programmes at the Jenner Institute—and there are more than 12 vaccines in clinical development now—the European Commission has probably been our largest funder over the past five years until now.

So that’s going to leave a gap and we are working hard to try to fill that, but it’s not easy.

The lab wouldn't be there if it wasn't for the EU.

Ellianne Sun 25-Jul-21 17:56:41

In some ways I would be quite pleased for us to no longer be seen as better than anywhere else, or a beacon to the world, whatever that means. That very much brings its own problems too.

Kandinsky Sun 25-Jul-21 17:59:44

1 agree Ellianne - Totally insignificant little country that no one cares about or obsesses over - bring it on.

Kali2 Sun 25-Jul-21 18:23:20

Ellianne

In some ways I would be quite pleased for us to no longer be seen as better than anywhere else, or a beacon to the world, whatever that means. That very much brings its own problems too.

Well yes- but I do think it is something to be really and truly proud of. And very sad and upset to see those qualities being destroyed by the current PM and Government.

Being trusted for your word and honour, is something to be proud of.

I'd say that if you don't care, then you can't be a true patriot and can't really love your country that much.

varian Sun 25-Jul-21 18:26:15

If we ever apply to rejoin the EU, which most British people never wanted to leave, we will be firmly at the back of the queue.

25Avalon Sun 25-Jul-21 18:40:01

The vaccine wouldn’t be here and rolled out if it wasn’t for UK. EU were way behind.

Gwyneth Sun 25-Jul-21 18:54:23

But you have still avoided answering a genuine question Kali2 . Why would anyone want to come to live in the UK if as you are forecasting there will be no jobs, supermarket shelves will be bare, the NHS on its knees, medicines scarce etc. You’d be totally mad to want to come here. Am just surprised that people in the UK aren’t packing their bags as I type.

PippaZ Sun 25-Jul-21 18:56:24

25Avalon

Funny how the illegal migrants have so much money to pay the smugglers and also how many of them are “children” who need a shave two days later.

What has this to do with the government being chaotic, liars, incompetent and out to hurt the very people they need to vote for them?

Does it just make people feel better to kick those who are even worse off than they will be under the New Tories?

Polly12 Sun 25-Jul-21 19:00:49

But - I’m confused - I didn’t think you lived in the UK, Kali2?

Alegrias1 Sun 25-Jul-21 19:05:46

25Avalon

The vaccine wouldn’t be here and rolled out if it wasn’t for UK. EU were way behind.

We could have done exactly the same things we did anyway, even if we had not left the EU. Believing otherwise is one of the bits of disinformation that the Brexit-supporting government would like you to buy into.

www.newstatesman.com/politics/brexit/2021/02/why-eu-s-vaccine-disaster-doesn-t-prove-brexit-was-right

www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/blog/covid-vaccine-decisions-brexit

www.bbc.co.uk/news/55163730

fullfact.org/health/coronavirus-vaccine-brexit/

frenchie Sun 25-Jul-21 19:07:59

Aren’t most of the illegal immigrants coming from former British colonies?
The sins of the fathers??

Kali2 Sun 25-Jul-21 19:11:29

You must be very confused Polly, indeed.

The reasons why so many are still coming to UK are very well explained elsewhere, the language, friends and family already here, and yes, the reputation of the UK being open and tolerant still perdures in far away shores.

BTW have you been to Syria lately? Or Afghanistan, or many parts of Africa. You should go and see, if you need some explanation. This has NOTHING to do with this thread, which is about loss of trust and respect for the word of our PM and his Government, and by sad implication, the UK as a whole.

halfpint1 Sun 25-Jul-21 19:19:44

Obtaining financial aid in France has always been a (rightly so)
long and hard path. You have to pay in to be paid out, simple
and that goes for any European residing here.
Britain however has always been known for its generosity in
benefits, what refugee would stay in France when the system
works better for them across the channel. Simple
Leaving Europe was never going to stop the immigration process and if those that voted to leave thought it would they were told a lie

HolySox Sun 25-Jul-21 19:22:09

foxie48 gave a good comment. International relationships aren't based on 'trust' more simply what suits each party.

For 'balance' the BBC reported this issue here:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-57930799

This reports there was room for further renogatiation in the Brexit deal if the NI protocol is 'unworkable'.

"What do you expect?" To be honest I was expecting a no-deal Brexit. The EU were in an excellent position. They had a Treaty with the UK that we ended - some here might say broke. Taking that point of view it can be interpreted that the UK cannot be trusted. As such they won't let us back in - to answer the OP question. The recent request to re-look at the NI protocol is therefore essentially irrelevent.

Gwyneth Sun 25-Jul-21 19:23:09

I don’t think Syria, Iran or Iraq where I believe many migrants are coming from were ever British colonies. But didn’t France have colonies too? But the point I am trying to make but have almost given up as no one seems to be able to provide an answer is if the UK is such an awful place to live why is anyone wanting to settle here. Personally I like living in the UK and get really fed up of the constant moaning or criticism.

HolySox Sun 25-Jul-21 19:33:39

Things are so much nicer in France...
www.france24.com/en/europe/20210724-french-protesters-against-covid-19-health-restrictions-clash-with-police-in-paris
Do UK police carry guns and use teargas?

Kali2 Sun 25-Jul-21 19:39:17

25Avalon

Funny how the illegal migrants have so much money to pay the smugglers and also how many of them are “children” who need a shave two days later.

My grandson is 15, just under 6' and has facial hair.

Gwyneth- Dinahmo has given a very comprehensive answer, and I have repeated som of the well-known points made.

You should watch the brilliant French film 'Welcome' - is you had a grandson, you would weep, as I did. It explains the reasons very well.

Kali2 Sun 25-Jul-21 19:40:11

Some of you are beginning (well it has been a while actually) to sound like Johnson at PMQT- just go on the rant and attack, rather than addressing the question in the OP.