Gransnet forums

News & politics

Southerners and Northerners are paying higher taxes, but only the Southerners are benefiting.

(133 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:03:40

I will only pay as little as 20% of my properties value should I need to go into care.

Those living in the North will pay up to 60%

We are all paying the same tax.

Levelling up it is called. Who knew

nanna8 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:09:14

But Southerners need more,don’t they ? More expensive there and they have to live in the manner to which they are accustomed.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:09:59

Well I certainly do

nanna8 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:11:59

Good on ya

tanith Tue 23-Nov-21 08:15:36

It won’t only be those in the North though Wales will among other areas will be affected too.

GrannyGravy13 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:18:01

Whitewavemark2 I do not think it’s a simplistic as your OP suggests.

There are areas in the South which are poor, extremely high unemployment, one of the poorest and most deprived areas in England is in East Essex (Jaywick).

The cost of living is generally higher in the South also.

AGAA4 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:19:53

Totally biased towards those with high value properties.
Very unfair as usual.
Glad I live in Wales.

Casdon Tue 23-Nov-21 08:20:31

Wales won’t be affected tanith, health and care is devolved here, as in Scotland and Northern Ireland so the Act won’t apply to us thankfully.

growstuff Tue 23-Nov-21 08:22:22

I don't like the divisiveness of north/south. However, the fact remains that the people with lowest value homes will pay a far bigger percentage for care.

PS. It's also a fact that on average properties in some areas, mainly in the south, are worth more and people will reach the cap sooner.

Pantglas2 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:31:03

Casdon

Wales won’t be affected tanith, health and care is devolved here, as in Scotland and Northern Ireland so the Act won’t apply to us thankfully.

I wonder how it’s going to work in Wales given the intention to deliver care in a similar way to the NHS i.e. free at point of delivery.

Here in north Wales so many people with holiday/retirement homes may decide that’s the place to spend their old age for that benefit alone?

Oldnproud Tue 23-Nov-21 08:42:35

How can it possibly it fair that the inheritance of the offspring of those in expensive houses (in any part of the country) is to be so much better protected than that of those of parents who had less expensive houses?
Because that is largely who stands to gain from this in the long run, isn't it, the offspring rather than their parents?

Yet another example of wealthy in parliament protecting their own kind again, I fear.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:43:45

GrannyGravy13

Whitewavemark2 I do not think it’s a simplistic as your OP suggests.

There are areas in the South which are poor, extremely high unemployment, one of the poorest and most deprived areas in England is in East Essex (Jaywick).

The cost of living is generally higher in the South also.

Those whose are the most deprived almost certainly will not have an estate worth more than £20k as they will probably rent. So the very poorest will quite rightly pay nothing.

growstuff Tue 23-Nov-21 08:47:37

Oldnproud

How can it possibly it fair that the inheritance of the offspring of those in expensive houses (in any part of the country) is to be so much better protected than that of those of parents who had less expensive houses?
Because that is largely who stands to gain from this in the long run, isn't it, the offspring rather than their parents?

Yet another example of wealthy in parliament protecting their own kind again, I fear.

Unbelievably, most of the Tory MPs in "red wall" seats voted for the Bill and against their own constituents' interests.

Urmstongran Tue 23-Nov-21 08:47:51

Like this really.

Regards,
A northener.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:54:24

growstuff

Oldnproud

How can it possibly it fair that the inheritance of the offspring of those in expensive houses (in any part of the country) is to be so much better protected than that of those of parents who had less expensive houses?
Because that is largely who stands to gain from this in the long run, isn't it, the offspring rather than their parents?

Yet another example of wealthy in parliament protecting their own kind again, I fear.

Unbelievably, most of the Tory MPs in "red wall" seats voted for the Bill and against their own constituents' interests.

When it comes to safeguarding their own interests the Tories are second to none.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 23-Nov-21 08:56:47

Of course there is the added factor that those with the highest value properties will largely be able to afford care without having to dip into their property value, thus leaving 100% to their heirs.

Coastpath Tue 23-Nov-21 09:07:35

From the evidence of my entire life all I have ever seen is that this is the Tories doing what they do.

They break promises, lie and rob the poor to pay the rich. They protect their own. They operate in a bubble of rich, connected, entitled people who are in a club we will never be allowed or able to join. This club has its roots in London...not the North. They don't care about the weak, sick, poor, disadvantaged, young or old. If you vote for them, this is what you voted for and this is what you get.

Surely if you are poor, or old, or ill, or have children in education or if you simply care about people in those positions then voting Tory is an act of self harm?

kittylester Tue 23-Nov-21 09:14:43

Not sure how true that is, whitewave. I know a lot of people round here are property rich and cash poor.

Casdon Tue 23-Nov-21 09:22:26

~I wonder how it’s going to work in Wales given the intention to deliver care in a similar way to the NHS i.e. free at point of delivery.

Here in north Wales so many people with holiday/retirement homes may decide that’s the place to spend their old age for that benefit alone?~
That’s a good question Pantglas2. I expect there would be a requirement for proof of residency, and maybe people would have to live permanently in an area for x number of years before becoming eligible? Thousands of people retire to Wales every year from England, so it needs to be answered. Another little known ruse is that when English Local Authorities place people in care homes over the border in Wales, after 5 years the LA where the care home is situated picks up the costs for them - so maybe there will be a 5 year eligibility clause?

Urmstongran Tue 23-Nov-21 09:23:00

I only lent Boris my vote to Get Brexit Done. He was the only one offering it. The other parties all either fudged it or promised to actually reverse the result of the referendum (yes, looking at you here Jo Swinson).

I’ve been disappointed. I won’t be voting Tory again.

Casdon Tue 23-Nov-21 09:23:12

Sorry I tried to put the quote from your post in italics, but it didn’t work!

Coastpath Tue 23-Nov-21 09:47:35

Urmstongran

I only lent Boris my vote to Get Brexit Done. He was the only one offering it. The other parties all either fudged it or promised to actually reverse the result of the referendum (yes, looking at you here Jo Swinson).

I’ve been disappointed. I won’t be voting Tory again.

You can't lend a vote. A vote counts. Always.

Coastpath Tue 23-Nov-21 09:51:30

Some people would have voted for the Devil if he had promised Brexit. On a foundation of weak promises said with fingers crossed they'd have compromised all their principles for sovereignty.

Sovereignty = the right to distance yourself from all your neighbours and be ruled by a corrupt club of self interested liars who own and control all the checks and balances on themselves. This is where we are now.

BigBertha1 Tue 23-Nov-21 09:54:20

granygravy13 my sister has been working in Jaywick and she said she would never have believed such dreadful living conditions and the health condition of some of the people she has been visiting. I lived in Clacton on sea in my teens which is a long time ago and the government of the day promised to rebuild Jaywick then after the 1953 floods in fact - it never happened. Large number of older people live here on very basic incomes. You are right to point it and its not the only place in the south by a long way.

Urmstongran Tue 23-Nov-21 09:56:33

I do realise that Coastpath but it was the verbal currency used at the time, to illustrate an unusual change from the norm.

It was indeed the only time I have ever voted Tory. So in fact I did only ‘lend’ my vote as I shan’t be doing so again.