Gransnet forums

News & politics

Will someone please tell them Quidditch isn’t real?

(110 Posts)
MayBeMaw Sun 19-Dec-21 07:46:14

For heavens sake! (I could express it more strongly, but really…)
OFFICIALS in charge of Quidditch, a sport inspired by Harry Potter, are to change its name to “distance” it from JK Rowling because of her views on transgender issues.
JK Rowling has been targeted by trans activists because she does not agree with ‘erasing the concept of sex
JK Rowling has been targeted by trans activists because she does not agree with ‘erasing the concept of sex
US Quidditch (USQ) and Major League Quidditch (MLQ) will conduct surveys in the next few months to decide the new name, they announced in a joint statement this week
It said: “The leagues are hoping a name change can help them continue to distance themselves from the works of JK Rowling, the author of the Harry Potter book series, who has increasingly come under scrutiny for her anti-trans positions in recent years
Our sport has developed a reputation as one of the most progressive sports in the world on gender equality and inclusivity, in part thanks to its gender maximum rule, which stipulates that a team may not have more than four players of the same gender on the field at a time

1). She wrote the bliddy books.
2) It’s not real
3) What have Harry Potter books to do with sexuality/ transgender/ transitioning / or even (whisper) reality?

I really and truly despair confusedconfused

maddyone Sun 19-Dec-21 15:00:30

I agree with everything written on this thread, except for one. You have all expressed expressed exactly how I feel about this. To be sure, the young actors, now adults although not behaving as such wouldn’t be where they are now without JKR.

Calistemon Sun 19-Dec-21 14:34:31

That's what I used to do with friends when we were very young, and pretended we were riding horses

Yes! With a horse's head made out of an old sock and buttons!
I must have been about 7 or 8.

You'd think these people would have grown out of that kind of caper.

Buttonjugs Sun 19-Dec-21 12:53:11

I don’t agree with her opinions but firmly believe we have to separate a person from their art, otherwise there would be very little to read, watch or listen to.

Smileless2012 Sun 19-Dec-21 12:47:55

And for misrepresentation Blossoming. 'Quidditch' involves flying, not running around with a broom between your legs. That's what I used to do with friends when we were very young, and pretended we were riding horsesgrin.

It was always a problem getting over the jumps without knocking them over with the brush at the endhmm.

Blossoming Sun 19-Dec-21 12:44:45

They’re lucky JKR didn’t sue them for unauthorised use of the name ‘Quidditch’.

sodapop Sun 19-Dec-21 12:39:33

Iam64

I read about this earlier and became so irritated, I stopped reading. Childish and avoidant but honestly, JKR is a heroic woman. She wrote books that got boys reading. She’s brought more fun and enjoyment to the lives of children than any of those attacking her.
I read them along with my young teens. They now have small children who love the books and movies.
It’s like Narnia in some people’s hearts. Always winter and never Christmas - bah humbug

Absolutely agree Iam64 my grandson was immersed in Harry Potter when the books first came out, didn't really read much until then. He is 27 now and still enjoys the books and films.
JKR is a woman to be admired for many reasons, not slated as is happening now.
As for Quidditch I would have thought anything which gets people exercising has to be a good thing.

Calistemon Sun 19-Dec-21 12:33:53

Parsley3

I had to have a look at a video to see how this land based version of quidditch worked. So you run about with a broomstick between your legs and throw a ball through a hoop. Disappointingly, no flying was involved and it just looked daft. I were them I would certainly change the name. Kidditch, maybe, or Quackitch. I doubt that JKR would want to be associated with it anyway.

Perhaps they'll all get tangled up in their broomsticks and do themselves an injury.

We can live in hope

(Ooh, sorry, that was spiteful grin)

Calistemon Sun 19-Dec-21 12:32:05

Chestnut

J K Rowling is being wiped out because she doesn't follow the party line on gender. She is not invited to the HP anniversary event (quite a big deal by the look of it) and even the HP kids are against her. So people are not allowed to give their opinions any more or they will be excluded from this brave new society which is developing before our eyes.

I read that with a sense of shock!

Who are these people who think they now own HP? The Thought Police?

As for Quidditch , is it 1st April?
I'd say they were all daft as brooms but they are more sinister and dangerous than that.

Kalu Sun 19-Dec-21 12:24:00

Appalled - must review more!

SueDonim Sun 19-Dec-21 11:54:58

Good grief! ?‍♀️

Parsley3 Sun 19-Dec-21 11:26:07

I had to have a look at a video to see how this land based version of quidditch worked. So you run about with a broomstick between your legs and throw a ball through a hoop. Disappointingly, no flying was involved and it just looked daft. I were them I would certainly change the name. Kidditch, maybe, or Quackitch. I doubt that JKR would want to be associated with it anyway.

Chestnut Sun 19-Dec-21 11:05:05

Agree with Kalu and it is worrying to think where this is all leading as the future unfolds. How can a small minority take over society simply by shouting the loudest? It's time women stood up for their rights and opinions in a BIG way, after all there are a lot more of them.

Kalu Sun 19-Dec-21 10:43:40

I am appealed at the treatment being meted out to J K Rowling.
Why? - simply because she holds an opinion shared by many, certainly by me, has resulted in her receiving death threats!
Are we all supposed to keep our mouths shut, walk on eggshells
and not dare say we don’t agree with something? J K Rowling is a breath of fresh air in the murky world that is denying women’s rights.
She has given so much enjoyment for children globally. A wonderful role model as someone who started following her dream to write with such success that children devoured her books.
Her treatment by those who now have a successful career down to her is truly sickening.

Lucca Sun 19-Dec-21 10:31:29

Josianne

Anything else ...?

??

Oldwoman70 Sun 19-Dec-21 10:21:16

Claims to be one of the most progressive sports in the world (!) on gender equality and inclusivity. Perhaps someone should buy they a dictionary so they can look up the meaning of inclusivity:

the practice or policy of providing equal access to opportunities and resources for people who might otherwise be excluded or marginalized

It would seem their "inclusivity" does not include anyone who may have a different opinion to theirs

TerriBull Sun 19-Dec-21 10:11:19

furore publicity

TerriBull Sun 19-Dec-21 10:06:46

I do like JK Rowling, not only for what she has done for children's literature but also for her philanthropy. I think she's an admirable human being and am appalled at the amount of hate that has come her way for expressing her opinion, which we are all entitled to.

I look back with affection at the Harry Potter years, I picked up her first two books in Waterstones when they were on promotion before all the furore surrounding them kicked in for the children to read on holiday. At the time I had no idea who she was and what would come down the line as to their overwhelming success. Read them they did on that holiday,
my not so mad about books son like many others devoured the whole series, I think my "reader" son liked them but preferred the His Dark Materials series. I don't think we can under estimate how she captured the imagination of a generation and as others have pointed out, engaged so many boys who were not too enthusiastic about books.

I think her trio of child actors have behaved quite shabbily towards her, having seen all of them in more adult material post Harry Potter, I'm not sure they are that great at what they do, although that is a matter of opinion, but do wonder if they would have become as successful and rich as they have done without that almighty leg up from the Harry Potter films.

In our house, we love the Robert Gailbraiths as well and those are a testament to her versatility as a writer.

Germanshepherdsmum Sun 19-Dec-21 09:43:48

Ridiculous. I’m a great admirer of JKR, who is a wonderful role model for young people having made her fortune, which she generously shares, from scratch. As has already been said, she’s helped millions of children around the world to discover the joy of reading. Then she crosses the trans lobby by making a factual statement, also made by the eminent Robert Winstone (?sp) and, rather like those whose made their money from the slave trade, we must remove all trace of her. When did free speech die?

Chewbacca Sun 19-Dec-21 09:34:05

A parallel could be drawn between the extreme trans activists who believe that it's possible to change biological sex and the same cohort who also believe that Quidditch is a real game not a fictional one. JKR deserves a medal for her patience and fortitude in dealing with the TRA bullies who rely on cancel culture to get their opinions across; she's my hero.

Cherrytree59 Sun 19-Dec-21 09:32:51

They are living in La la land.

Galaxy Sun 19-Dec-21 09:32:47

Yep a powerful wealthy woman who they cant shut up. Its driving them to distraction. Misogyny on steroids. Oh and dont think we havent noticed that the women they target most ruthlessly have a history of domestic abuse or sexual violence.

Zoejory Sun 19-Dec-21 09:29:53

Just dreadful. The world is being taken over by bullies on keyboards who decide who can stay and who has to be rid of.

Chestnut Sun 19-Dec-21 09:28:59

J K Rowling is being wiped out because she doesn't follow the party line on gender. She is not invited to the HP anniversary event (quite a big deal by the look of it) and even the HP kids are against her. So people are not allowed to give their opinions any more or they will be excluded from this brave new society which is developing before our eyes.

Baggs Sun 19-Dec-21 09:24:45

Haters gonna hate. It is essentially misogyny. I admire JKR for standing up to the bullies.

tickingbird Sun 19-Dec-21 09:24:40

I find it outrageous what they’re doing to JKR. She was merely stating the obvious. I can’t for the life of me understand why every institution is rolling over for the trans movement. For heaven’s sake stand up to them. It’s becoming more dystopian every week.