Gransnet forums

News & politics

Partygate

(272 Posts)
Petera Tue 12-Apr-22 13:44:02

Johnson and Sunak to be served fixed penalty notices. Will he still maintain he didn't break the law?

Mardyone Wed 13-Apr-22 12:39:19

Every single one of the cabinet needs to go unless they stand up and remove the worst leader in history. He didn't get us through the pandemic, science and NHS did, he is not a world leader, Ukraine need our help not through Johnson but through aid, and our citizens deserve better than this

volver Wed 13-Apr-22 12:39:30

Anybody who keeps saying it wasn't a party, or some such excuse.

What did he get fined for then?

catta5 Wed 13-Apr-22 12:44:04

All i am saying i bet everyone broke a rule even if it was not keeping 2 metres apart or seeing family we should let it
drop there are far more relevant pressing issues

Dempie55 Wed 13-Apr-22 12:45:14

Oh, did he lie again? Surprise, surprise. He'll get away with it, because there is nobody else better to step into the job of PM. I'm pretty sure the visit to Kiev and the "family outing" to the Dinosaur park were both timed to lift his popularity ratings in advance of the fine announcement.

As for Sunak, he'll be off to the USA soon to oversee the asset stripping of our NHS prior to selling it all off to the Yanks.

Amalegra Wed 13-Apr-22 12:46:08

It seems to escape notice that it is up to Parliament to judge whether Johnson misled them. He claims he was unaware it was a breach. We will have to see what develops after the Easter Recess. That aside (and its a big aside, I know!), we do have a matter of far more importance to consider and that is of course the war in Ukraine. I cannot see anyone else who could take over from our PM, discredited as he may be. Sunak’s out of course! Sajit David? Liz Truss? Michael Gove? Hardly leadership dynamics! None of them ticks my box! The situation in Ukraine is too fragile to jeopardise. Any blip in the western coalition, in NATO is just what Putin hopes for. We are Ukraines’s staunchest ally in the supply of munitions. Zelensky trusts Johnson. Instability in the UK government (Putin’s No 1 enemy) would be manna from heaven for his evil regime. Breaching Covid rules ( no matter what you think of them) is a serious matter with a fine which, though shaming, does not criminalise you. I think the threat of World War III is much, much more serious. I believe personally that Johnson should stay…for now…as the far lesser of the two evils.

volver Wed 13-Apr-22 12:46:34

catta5

All i am saying i bet everyone broke a rule even if it was not keeping 2 metres apart or seeing family we should let it
drop there are far more relevant pressing issues

But not "everyone" was supposed to be running the country.

And I never broke a single rule, so don't tar me with your brush. I didn't see my parents for 8 months, and they are in their eighties.

I can't see what's more relevant than having a lying cheat as PM?

rosie1959 Wed 13-Apr-22 12:47:24

volver

Anybody who keeps saying it wasn't a party, or some such excuse.

*What did he get fined for then?*

I wondered this one too from the event I have seen described in press releases it certainly didn’t sound much of a party to me
If it was people he already worked daily with what was the fine all about

LisaAN Wed 13-Apr-22 12:48:13

catta5

All i am saying i bet everyone broke a rule even if it was not keeping 2 metres apart or seeing family we should let it
drop there are far more relevant pressing issues

What can be more pressing than getting rid of a PM who has lied, lied and lied again? And will keep lying?

GillT57 Wed 13-Apr-22 12:48:32

I am anticipating more fines for more of the parties, it strikes me that the one they have been fined for so far, was the more 'minor' of the many events, not that it is an excuse. I am concerned about the one the night before the Duke of Edinburgh's funeral, when the Queen had refused the offered special dispensation to bend the rules, the one where they wheeled out the decks and danced the night away in No10. So, for all you apologists; not just an accidental slice of birthday cake, a planned, organised knees up. Then there are the 'business meetings' in the garden with the laptops cunningly disguised as wine bottles, and that well known civil servant, Mrs Johnson present.

fordk4 Wed 13-Apr-22 12:48:33

what about the labour leader who was in a pub on lock down was he held to accout no and I saw many people on lockdown shopping with out a mask and people told me they would not wear a mask or have the covid jabs boris did not kill anyone but the general public did so look at the over all picture boris had to run the country ans dont forget all the people cwho got paid 80% of their salary I know people who had to work for 80% of their salary all wake upnthe wat through lockdown and wherte was labour and all the other parties who did nothing during the lockdown you the public need to look at the full picture not the bits you do not like wake up britain and ask your selfes how many times did you and yiur friends break the lockdown rules

Joesoap Wed 13-Apr-22 12:49:43

Totally unforgiveable, we have all been taken for a ride,big time! of course they should resign, but it isnt the correct time, with whats happening in Ukraine,We shall not forget, when the war is over.

Lucca Wed 13-Apr-22 12:50:38

what about the labour leader who was in a pub on lock down

He wasn’t.

Sorry but I’m struggling to understand the rest of your post.

GillT57 Wed 13-Apr-22 12:52:56

fordk4

what about the labour leader who was in a pub on lock down was he held to accout no and I saw many people on lockdown shopping with out a mask and people told me they would not wear a mask or have the covid jabs boris did not kill anyone but the general public did so look at the over all picture boris had to run the country ans dont forget all the people cwho got paid 80% of their salary I know people who had to work for 80% of their salary all wake upnthe wat through lockdown and wherte was labour and all the other parties who did nothing during the lockdown you the public need to look at the full picture not the bits you do not like wake up britain and ask your selfes how many times did you and yiur friends break the lockdown rules

Nope, I didn't break any rules.
I didn't set the rules.
You are talking nonsense
Starmer didn't go to the pub during lockdown.
Can't read the rest without taking a breath.

volver Wed 13-Apr-22 12:53:48

rosie1959

volver

Anybody who keeps saying it wasn't a party, or some such excuse.

*What did he get fined for then?*

I wondered this one too from the event I have seen described in press releases it certainly didn’t sound much of a party to me
If it was people he already worked daily with what was the fine all about

So are you suggesting that the Police were wrong to fine him?

You don't get fined for a "party", you get fined for an indoor gathering that was against the laws in place.

And even if you are working in the same building as other people all day, you don't have to mix with them. You don't have to all crowd into the same room and rub shoulders with each other. You don't have to bring the Missus.

He and Sunak have been fined for breaking the law. That's it.

ShepherdC Wed 13-Apr-22 12:54:02

He knows he is on a good thing with this job as none of his conservatives will even try to remove him from office. Should really be automatically fired for breaking rules and then blatantly lying about it. He does not care about the people that list loved ones and were unable to grieve properly. Hopefully wrong about the conservatives and they will remove him sooner than later. Until last election I had always voted conservative but did not want to vote for him last time due to his continuous lying in the past which continues now.

OakDryad Wed 13-Apr-22 12:57:15

How did we get here, volver?

By the majority of the electorate being told what they wanted to hear by a man who said whatever was necessary to get him into the highest political office, aided and abetted by the right-wing media printing his lies without fact-checking. Both the EU referendum campaign and the 2019 general election campaign were an onslaught of deliberate lies, more deliberate lies and even more deliberate lies.

This current crisis will seem like small fry to him. He has been allowed to get way with so much in the past he thinks he's invincible. Why should this be any different?

Ask the man in the street if he likes being lied to and you'd expect him to say no. So why accept it from Johnson and his party?

This forum often has threads warning people about scams. Johnson is the biggest scammer of all and yet Tory voters lap up his dishonesty again and again. You have to ask yourself why?

Rosalyn69 Wed 13-Apr-22 12:59:33

Breaking the rules when you made them and expected everyone else to keep them is unforgivable.
I don’t understand people saying it wasn’t that important and it’s imperative we keep him as PM because of the warin Ukraine is rubbish. The French are currently going to the polls. What’s the difference?

rosie1959 Wed 13-Apr-22 12:59:41

volver

rosie1959

volver

Anybody who keeps saying it wasn't a party, or some such excuse.

*What did he get fined for then?*

I wondered this one too from the event I have seen described in press releases it certainly didn’t sound much of a party to me
If it was people he already worked daily with what was the fine all about

So are you suggesting that the Police were wrong to fine him?

You don't get fined for a "party", you get fined for an indoor gathering that was against the laws in place.

And even if you are working in the same building as other people all day, you don't have to mix with them. You don't have to all crowd into the same room and rub shoulders with each other. You don't have to bring the Missus.

He and Sunak have been fined for breaking the law. That's it.

I didn’t say the police were wrong to fine him but there must be more to the event than as described to receive a fine.
I don’t actually think he brought his Missus as you say I suspect she instigated the event but not really that strange as she lives there.

HolySox Wed 13-Apr-22 13:00:21

Far as I can read Boris won't get a criminal record for his FPN.

I was surprised he paid it ... if the birthday cake was a surprise in an otherwise official meeting it sounds like 'entrapment' and a good barrister could have defended him. Putting it in perspective, if a tealady had wheeled in the afternoon refreshments would the police have issued a fine?

Joane123 Wed 13-Apr-22 13:00:48

The problem is the Government put the rules in place and they then broke them to suit themselves. Whatever other people did is not relevant. The Government should set an example.

Quite simple really. they set the agenda and then went on to do what they liked.

GillT57 Wed 13-Apr-22 13:01:06

Brilliant but chilling post OakDryad.

volver Wed 13-Apr-22 13:04:49

Damian Collins Tweet.
The PM rightly apologised for lockdown parties that took place at 10 Downing Street. He should never have been put in this position & that's why reform was needed in the way Downing Street is run. The parties are over and it's time to get on with the job. He has my full support.

Apparently he should never have been put in this position. Ambushed by cake, clearly.

These people live in a parallel universe.

MaizieD Wed 13-Apr-22 13:09:27

^ How did we get here?^

I think we got here because of people like several posters on this thread who don't give a monkeys about competence, honesty, and obeying the law. Who can't even recognise that most of the 'crises' the country is facing are of Johnson's own making.

It's a sad place we're in..

Whitewavemark2 Wed 13-Apr-22 13:10:39

Dempie55

Oh, did he lie again? Surprise, surprise. He'll get away with it, because there is nobody else better to step into the job of PM. I'm pretty sure the visit to Kiev and the "family outing" to the Dinosaur park were both timed to lift his popularity ratings in advance of the fine announcement.

As for Sunak, he'll be off to the USA soon to oversee the asset stripping of our NHS prior to selling it all off to the Yanks.

Absolutely!

The police issued the fines. Johnson delayed saying he had received a fine until this week, meanwhile he made a hurried visit to Ukraine, hoping this would help take the focus away from his behaviour.

Nothing he does is for anything else other than himself.

volver Wed 13-Apr-22 13:14:39

I didn’t say the police were wrong to fine him but there must be more to the event than as described to receive a fine.
I don’t actually think he brought his Missus as you say I suspect she instigated the event but not really that strange as she lives there.

From the BBC website: Up to 30 people attended, sang Happy Birthday and were served cake, according to ITV News. As well as Downing Street staff, the interior designer Lulu Lytle - who was not a member of No 10 staff - was present.
No 10 said staff had "gathered briefly" to "wish the prime minister a happy birthday", adding that the PM had been there "for less than 10 minutes".

The rules
Gatherings of more than two people inside were banned by law. An exception was allowed if the gathering "was reasonably necessary" for work purposes.
.
.
As Mr Johnson is to be issued with an FPN for this gathering, it is clear the police have not deemed the gathering to have been necessary.

I don’t understand why people are trying to minimise the fact that the Prime Minister broke the law.