Gransnet forums

News & politics

Whilst we are all looking one way

(57 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Tue 26-Apr-22 08:48:25

The government is effectively removing the Electoral commissions independence to oversee fair and democratic elections in the U.K.

The lords have voted against it.

The voters polled showed a 70% of them think that the commission should be independent.

The government will almost certainly override the lords and push through a bill that the vast majority in the country think is wrong.

varian Tue 26-Apr-22 09:07:41

This could not happen in a true majority. The next government must try to reverse so much of the damage that has been done since 2015.

paddyann54 Tue 26-Apr-22 09:16:23

Do Tory supporters still think Boris and his circus is good for their country or can they now see how he and Putin can be put in the same class ?

Beckett Tue 26-Apr-22 09:18:44

Daily anti-Boris, anti-Tory post

volver Tue 26-Apr-22 09:21:54

I prefer to think of it as the daily pro-democracy thread.

Anyway, what is their excuse WWM2? Why do they think we need it?

MaizieD Tue 26-Apr-22 09:23:25

Beckett

Daily anti-Boris, anti-Tory post

Can you explain why you support the loss of democratic freedoms?

Why you think that the government should control every aspect of the electoral process and be the only judge of its legality?

Beckett Tue 26-Apr-22 09:23:39

Where the same people vent their spleen to each other while everyone else ignores them

GagaJo Tue 26-Apr-22 09:27:22

Beckett

Daily anti-Boris, anti-Tory post

What do you think is a democracy?

Blossoming Tue 26-Apr-22 09:41:34

Beckett

Where the same people vent their spleen to each other while everyone else ignores them

Yes, that sounds very like the current Parliament. Time for a change.

DaisyAnne Tue 26-Apr-22 10:07:14

I think we have a Russian propoganda bot. Should it be reported? I thought they had updated them so they could converse and sound human.

DaisyAnne Tue 26-Apr-22 10:10:31

It's horrifying WWM. I suppose we could all subscribe and form a non-govermental Electoral Commission?

If this government is out at the next election, I hope everthing the incoming government finds is made public.

AGAA4 Tue 26-Apr-22 10:12:23

I do worry about the what this government is up to while people's attention is focused on other serious matters.

MaizieD Tue 26-Apr-22 10:14:08

Beckett

Where the same people vent their spleen to each other while everyone else ignores them

You can contribute to this, you know.

How about answering my questions? Don't you care about democracy?

Whitewavemark2 Tue 26-Apr-22 10:15:03

volver

I prefer to think of it as the daily pro-democracy thread.

Anyway, what is their excuse WWM2? Why do they think we need it?

Might have something to do with it.

Vote Leave has today (Friday 29 March 2019) withdrawn its appeal and related proceedings against the Electoral Commission’s finding of multiple offences under electoral law, committed during the 2016 EU referendum campaign.

Vote Leave was the designated lead campaigner for the leave outcome at the referendum. We found that it broke the electoral rules set out by Parliament to ensure fairness, confidence and legitimacy at an electoral event. Serious offences such as these undermine public confidence in our system and it is vital, therefore, that they are properly investigated and sanctioned.

Vote Leave has now paid its £61,000 fine in full.

OakDryad Tue 26-Apr-22 10:17:26

Could we talk about specifics please?

This from Doug Cowan from the Electoral Reform Society:

The bill proposes Britons who have been overseas for more than 15 years would also be able to donate to political parties. Expanding the ability to make political donations to those who permanently live abroad could pave the way for foreign interests to influence our politics (even more than they already do).

While everyone on the electoral roll has a single vote, some can use their wealth to gain further influence. There is a basic British principle that those funding our parties should be domiciled here – indeed it is in law but not enacted. Businesses donating to parties must generate revenue here, so it seems fair that individuals wishing to funnel in funds from abroad should be able to prove a consistent connection to the UK.

We need clear, consistent principles for the funding of our parties in the modern age. Our Parliament and parties should not be available to the highest bidders around the world.

Voters should not accept a situation where tax exiles and shell companies are able to exert a disproportionate sway over our politics.

The Government should listen to these concerns and launch a comprehensive review of Britain’s loophole-ridden campaign rules.

Perhaps someone who is FOR the bill could explain why they they support it and why they oppose the ERS’s concerns.

Whitewavemark2 Tue 26-Apr-22 10:20:53

One intention by the government.

“Finally, to avoid imposing an undue burden on taxpayers’ funds and duplicating the work of the Crown Prosecution Service and Public Prosecution Service Northern Ireland, we will legislate to expressly prevent the Commission from bringing criminal prosecutions in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. This will not apply in Scotland where there is already a single prosecutorial authority”

hmm

Elegran Tue 26-Apr-22 11:34:23

The price of freedom is eternal vigilance. How can this "free" country exert vigilance over how our democratic representatives are chosen if an independent Electoral Commission can't oversee fair elections?

Or if "Britons who have been overseas for more than 15 years . . permanently live abroad . . able to donate to political parties . . could pave the way for foreign interests to influence our politics (even more than they already do)"

It is the thin end of the wedge. Time to make a stand to stop the erosion of standards in government.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 28-Apr-22 09:37:49

The elections watchdog is no longer independent.

Gove is in charge. He was also a member of vote leave that was found fraudulent by the electoral Commission.

DaisyAnne Thu 28-Apr-22 09:49:30

Another nail in democracies coffin, WWM. So sad. We have had most of our lives, but just what are we leaving future generations.

TopsyIrene06 Thu 28-Apr-22 10:23:08

This is all getting really scary now.

Keep educating me DA, WWM2, EG, OD, MD, et al on this page. It helps when I feel that all is lost which I do on a daily basis.

Grandmabatty Thu 28-Apr-22 10:29:40

They've also effectively disenfranchised people who don't have a visual form of identification. My mum is 87. She doesn't have a driving licence, passport or bus pass. She has voted conscientiously for decades but now will be unable to? Another Tory idea which is ill thought out.

MawtheMerrier Thu 28-Apr-22 10:34:46

Grandmabatty

They've also effectively disenfranchised people who don't have a visual form of identification. My mum is 87. She doesn't have a driving licence, passport or bus pass. She has voted conscientiously for decades but now will be unable to? Another Tory idea which is ill thought out.

I don’t quite follow Grandmabatty - why won’t she be able to vote?

Grandmabatty Thu 28-Apr-22 11:29:20

She has no form of identification which has her face on it, which is a recent ploy of the government to stop illegal voters. Apparently there are almost no such beings but don't let that stand in the way of shrinking our rights.

MawtheMerrier Thu 28-Apr-22 11:34:20

Are you in the U.K.?
I have never, ever had to show proof of identity or even produce my polling card -although I usually have it on me.
Surely she gets one?
All I have ever done is confirm my address, they look it up on a list, issue me with a voting slip and off I go to vote.
Of course if she is not in the U.K. things may be different.

Grandmabatty Thu 28-Apr-22 11:51:31

It is a very recent innovation of the government and yes, I live in UK, as does my mum. The local elections next week will be the last time we can use polling cards without a visual form of identification as well.