Gransnet forums

News & politics

The loss of freedom of speech, of sidelining women and biology

(874 Posts)
DiamondLily Thu 12-May-22 12:47:27

I've been asked to repost this:

'Julie Bindel had a pretty horrendous time whilst delivering a (previously postponed) lecture to York University's Free Speech Society.

The activists, who say we must be "all be kind" didn't display much courtesy or kindness to her.?

She was abused, accused, screamed at, and had placards thrust in her face. The TW mob were out in force, and she was "invited" to kiss their "man-boobs" and told things she could do with their "trans d*cks".

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10806353/JULIE-BINDEL-explains-female-students-bullied-hearing-feminists.html

Meanwhile, in the Court case involving Alison Bailey, Stonewall tell us that there are no such things as male and female bodies. They don't exist...?

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10807211/We-not-inherently-male-female-Stonewall-campaigner-says-bodies-just-bodies.html

It sure is a funny old world out there in Trans La-La land.

Elegran Tue 31-May-22 08:16:06

Pride goeth before a fall. The more of these incidents they engineer, the more obvious it will become that for many participants the object is to inspire fear in anyone who doesn't instantly kowtow to them and give up their own rights without a fight.

"Real women are half the world. Their rights to privacy and to protection from predatory men must not be over-ridden to appease male aggression.'

Elegran Tue 31-May-22 08:28:40

If once you pay the Danegeld, you will never be rid of the Danes.

Each successful challenge by aggressive trans activists over non-aggressive women forms a platform from which they launch another. These extremists are NOT seeking justice for trans people (who are just pawns in their power play) Their aim is supremacy over what they see are meek and conforming non-trans, easy to cow into submission by accusations of hate and transphobia if they show any signs of rebellion.

Be kind my eye to bullies like these false "representatives" of usually reasonable trans people. They see kindness as weakness.

FarNorth Tue 31-May-22 11:58:34

Some light relief - a cute video of two people whose pronouns are she/they and they/them

www.tiktok.com/@dylanmulvaney/video/7103679534020742446?_t=8SlgS2hT5l8&_r=1

Doodledog Tue 31-May-22 13:00:56

Mollygo

What it needs is for those female students to find their places, awards, and jobs have been taken by males pretending to be female. Or as they get older define that their daughters achievements have been over ridden by males pretending to be female. Being a student is evidently an excuse for shortsightedness.

I agree with this.

I see it as similar to the way many young women can't see the ned for feminism, and think it is passé. Because they are young, they won't have experienced discrimination (yet). At the start of their careers, they are probably on the same salary as men of their age, as it's not until more senior levels that the glass ceiling kicks in, and it's when they have had a career break or maternity leave that they understand how that has affected their prospects.

When they come back from maternity leave to find that a bloke called Gladys who has a wife at home looking after 'her' children has been promoted above them, and has done so by taking advantage of an all-female shortlist policy, she might feel differently, particularly when Gladys and 'her' mates pee all over the floor in the Ladies loos and leave the seat up after them.

Doodledog Tue 31-May-22 13:02:03

Excuse the millions of typos in that post grin. Oh, for an edit button.

DiamondLily Tue 31-May-22 14:14:28

The one thing that is a shame is that one of the "chief hecklers" is the son of Yvette Cooper and Ed Balls.?

This has given the right wing media some ammunition against Labour.?

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10870697/Trans-activist-heckled-Nadhim-Zahawi-Warwick-University-campus-son-Yvette-Cooper.html

FarNorth Tue 31-May-22 14:41:52

Mr Zahawi said that the young man behaved politely.

As Labour are happy to say they have no idea what a woman is, there's no problem.

I wish politicians were asked what a man is - they might think a little harder about that.

DiamondLily Thu 02-Jun-22 08:11:20

FarNorth

Mr Zahawi said that the young man behaved politely.

As Labour are happy to say they have no idea what a woman is, there's no problem.

I wish politicians were asked what a man is - they might think a little harder about that.

We can but hope that Labour stop trying to pacify all sides, and just state the common sense/majority view.. ?

Meanwhile, a smile: ?

FarNorth Thu 02-Jun-22 13:14:30

The Crown Prosecution Service has a new "speak-out champion" for diversity and inclusion.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/83d463a6-e1cd-11ec-baab-53d14c642149?shareToken=3d7e695b2b0cfb5599bab7a88730b4c1&fbclid=IwAR0RmTlYV5aHxImpKGxHj1i9-6wf00ogXGLTpM08qXVkPzK-NonhUXS9Ar0

FarNorth Thu 02-Jun-22 13:43:58

The Allison Bailey court case continues.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/bar-chiefs-in-free-speech-dispute-lpw0s2psw?shareToken=62dbe6ef4d278ae0bf0106b23d0ac508&fbclid=IwAR1zByvmxzefLACpQeIg-1wSUHvr2oKz6-g1QAsaJZfY_XS4Na4NgvRN_WQ

( No paywall on these last two links )

FarNorth Thu 02-Jun-22 23:21:24

AussieNana I hope this twitter link works for you so that you can hear transman Scott Newgent talking about the transition process that girls and young women are being led into.
(it's less than 2 mins)

mobile.twitter.com/MattWalshBlog/status/1532392581568638978

AussieNanna Fri 03-Jun-22 02:02:14

Far North what point are you making?

I dont doubt the process of transition is arduous and complicated but I dont agree we are leading generations into it or any of the other hyperbole he claimed.

Mollygo Fri 03-Jun-22 02:29:28

That’s fine if you don’t believe it, AussieNana. The sad thing is that if even one person, girl or woman, boy or man is being led into damaging their body in the belief that it will change their ‘sex’ then the perpetrators of such harm need to be held to account.
Treatment and support for gender dysphoria is one thing. Irrevocable harm for a false belief is another.

FarNorth Fri 03-Jun-22 02:49:17

AussieNana why do you not believe that that transman is telling the truth?

DiamondLily Fri 03-Jun-22 09:47:52

If adults wish to take body changing drugs, or have surgery, that might do them harm, then they have a right to do so.

It's totally different with children and teenagers, because they are not emotionally mature enough to make that sort of decision.

Clinics, as with any branch of medicine, should be held accountable if they harm anyone, especially those under adult age.?

DiamondLily Fri 03-Jun-22 13:48:40

There's a national shortage of HRT, leading to a lot of problems for women, who are suffering from the effects of the menopause.

But, luckily, there has been some available for biological men, identifying as women.

The number of adults in the UK being treated for gender dysphoria on the NHS has risen 75 per cent in five years, MailOnline can reveal.

Latest figures for 2021 show more than 11,000 patients received care for the condition that causes sufferers to feel they were born the wrong gender.

This is 74 per cent more compared to the 6,371 patients being treated in 2016.

A gender dysphoria diagnosis is the first step to getting prescribed cross-sex hormone therapies that help trans people develop the characteristics of their preferred gender.

It comes amid a nationwide shortage of hormone replacement therapy which is also used to help alleviate the symptoms of the menopause.

Around 1,600 trans patients were prescribed the female hormone oestrogen in 2021, the most popular HRT drug that is most short in stock.

However, the total figure is believed to be higher because data is only available for four out of the 12 of the gender clinics that provided information to MailOnline.

A current HRT shortage has left menopausal women rationing doses, trading supplies in car parks or turning to the black market.

Brilliant....?

www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-10881403/Number-trans-people-receiving-NHS-treatment-rises-75-five-years-amid-national-HRT-shortage.html

AussieNanna Fri 03-Jun-22 15:01:09

Mollygo

That’s fine if you don’t believe it, AussieNana. The sad thing is that if even one person, girl or woman, boy or man is being led into damaging their body in the belief that it will change their ‘sex’ then the perpetrators of such harm need to be held to account.
Treatment and support for gender dysphoria is one thing. Irrevocable harm for a false belief is another.

What false belief?

Yes I support treatment and support for gender dysmorphia.

And any permanent treatment or surgery here involves in depth counselling first - it would be sad if people were denied that because their issue wasn't seen as real.

AussieNanna Fri 03-Jun-22 15:04:30

DiamondLily

If adults wish to take body changing drugs, or have surgery, that might do them harm, then they have a right to do so.

It's totally different with children and teenagers, because they are not emotionally mature enough to make that sort of decision.

Clinics, as with any branch of medicine, should be held accountable if they harm anyone, especially those under adult age.?

That's right - any permanent treatment should only be available to adults.

And of course they should be aware of any risks involved - just like any other medical treatment.

And they do have a right to do that.

AussieNanna Fri 03-Jun-22 15:05:36

FarNorth

AussieNana why do you not believe that that transman is telling the truth?

The link was mostly hyperbole and personal opinion,not any truth.

FarNorth Fri 03-Jun-22 15:18:06

Personal opinion of a transman, based on personal experience of "gender-affirming" treatment that has caused huge health problems.

Children and young people who are encouraged to believe they are in the wrong body are being led towards this type of treatment.

FarNorth Fri 03-Jun-22 15:21:51

It is not sensible to say that as soon as a person is legally an adult they are competent to decide to have treatment that is likely to harm them, if that person has been coached by those around them, maybe from a very young age, to believe that they need that treatment.

FarNorth Fri 03-Jun-22 15:28:15

Further on what happened with the 6th-former who was bullied for stating that biological sex is real, and on the climate in that school.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10838801/The-sixth-form-girl-bullied-school-saying-biological-sex-real.html

I hope you're right AussieNana that people are sensitively counseled if they appear to have gender dysphoria.
That hasn't always been happening in the UK or in the USA.

Stormystar Fri 03-Jun-22 15:52:05

Why are we accepting what is child abuse on so many levels. Not just with the grooming of young minds but the powerful hormones being given to children. And through Chest milk being fed to new born babies, by transgender woman who take powerful drugs in order to induce lactation (which we have no way of knowing the dangerous damaging effects they could have on the babies health) and which are banned in many countries. I weep at the insanity Of humanity, and feel so ashamed of my own passive inaction.

FarNorth Fri 03-Jun-22 16:07:42

Stormystar you could email your MP about why you want the UK government to prevent Scotland bringing in self-id of sex.
fairplayforwomen.com/dont-let-sex-self-id-through-scottish-backdoor/

You can find out who your MP is, and how to contact them, on www.theyworkforyou.com

Elegran Fri 03-Jun-22 17:10:52

You can email not only your own MSP but in one move send it also to several others representing your area, direct from the website forwomen.scot.

Advice on how to compose an effective message. forwomen.scot/contact-your-msps/

Link to the page to compose and send your email.
forwomenscotland.eaction.org.uk/MSP