Gransnet forums

News & politics

Crucifixion Cartoon in the Times on Good Friday

(112 Posts)
Granny23 Sat 08-Apr-23 13:41:10

I, am absolutely horrified after seeing today's 'cartoon' in the times which has been posted on Face Book. It depicts the Crucifixions of the current 1st Minister of Scotland, his predecessor and her husband. I am not a relative of these 3 nor even a close friend, but I do know them personally - all lovely kind and caring people - they do not deserve this. Also an insult to Christians on this, the holiest day in the calendar. In addition, it seems to be lacking the basic requirement of a cartoon, i,e, It is not funny. Any last vestige of decency or respect oot the windae.

maddyone Tue 11-Apr-23 10:18:14

A lovely post Joseanne. And balanced, as was Glorianny’s.
Thank goodness for balance.

volver3 Tue 11-Apr-23 10:57:13

maddyone

Okay, you’ve made me smile grin
I’m not blinkered though. Others maybe.

wink

nanna8 Tue 11-Apr-23 11:04:04

The idea of a church hierarchy makes me feel sick and I am glad it is not the case where I attend. We are all equal before the Lord and no one wears fancy dress or silly collars in my church. It originated in Scotland with John Knox, great man.

Caleo Tue 11-Apr-23 11:16:37

Depicting the truth about evil is not blasphemy.

Caleo Tue 11-Apr-23 11:19:15

Nanna, John Knox is a statue that perpetually glares across the Royal Mile at the statue of David Hume, a much greater man than John Knox.

Yammy Tue 11-Apr-23 11:20:27

volver3

The fact that its Easter is the point, I think.

Its not mocking Christians or the crucifixion and its not mocking Muslims.

I actually agree with you Volver, they have thought of the time of year and used appropriate symbols. I think it is very clever and as you pointed out up post it is the Saltaire background and they are on the Cross of St Andrew not a Roman or any other way of crucifying.
I look at it two ways they are either crucifying themselves or Crucifying the SNP, take your pick.

volver3 Tue 11-Apr-23 11:38:03

nanna8

The idea of a church hierarchy makes me feel sick and I am glad it is not the case where I attend. We are all equal before the Lord and no one wears fancy dress or silly collars in my church. It originated in Scotland with John Knox, great man.

I think the Catholics had something to do with it long before John Knox appeared on the scene.... confused

volver3 Tue 11-Apr-23 11:39:57

Oh sorry nanna8, I think I misunderstood.

Dinahmo Tue 11-Apr-23 11:44:43

maddyone

You have cited two examples Dinahmo. I’ve acknowledged that Christian people do wrong things just as others do. I’m afraid I find your post judgmental and I presume you’re not a Christian.

If you had read all my posts on this thread you will have noted that I said I was not a Christian but had been brought up in the C of E.

I only cited two examples because I did not want to bore everybody with along list of misdemeanors.

nanna8 Tue 11-Apr-23 14:28:24

volver3

Oh sorry nanna8, I think I misunderstood.

It’s ok - one of the many good things to come from your country imo

Caleo Thu 13-Apr-23 09:46:53

It matters that people know what their principles are and how they justify their principles. The traditional religions will have to get rid of miraculous justifications if they are to satisfy this need for modern civilised people who have a modicum of scientific knowledge.