Gransnet forums

News & politics

Gender neutral toilets in todays news!

(145 Posts)
Mollygo Fri 30-Jun-23 14:33:24

When will it stop?
A boy has been arrested by police investigating reports of serious sexual assaults in a gender neutral toilet at a school.
We don’t know if he sexually assaulted a boy or a girl (some schools have banned the use of those terms). Probably assault on a girl, because he could have assaulted boys in single sex toilets.

Smileless2012 Tue 04-Jul-23 14:30:30

Yes, in addition to the provision of toilets for women and men.

Doodledog Tue 04-Jul-23 14:45:48

We've done this over and over.

Additional provision is fine, but I don't see how that can be compulsory other than in new buildings. There will be very many premises who don't have the space or plumbing to offer three lots of facilities (plus, potentially, disabled and baby-changing provision).

I have no objection to extra provision where it is logistically possible (but I do object to the opt-out being to colonise the existing Ladies'), but am confused about who would use what.

If (as I believe would be the case), the vast majority of women prefer the pleasanter smell and the safety of a traditional Ladies', and the only people 'presenting as' women who use the GN ones are trans, why can't they use the Gents' in the first place, as they will stand out by going into the GN ones.

If the answer is that it is not safe for those who are not 'male identifying' men to be around men when they are vulnerable, why are women expected to do so now?

There is also the issue of transmen using facilities with male-bodied men who know that the transmen are female-bodied. Will that not put them at risk, too?

In schools, where the sexes are developing differently and both are coming to terms with puberty and sexuality, there is (to me) no good reason why girls should have to deal with periods in front of boys, or boys should have to wee in front of giggling girls. Even single-sex facilities (showers as well as loos) can be embarrassing at that age.

Smileless2012 Tue 04-Jul-23 15:19:01

And will probably have to keep doing this over and over until there's some common sense Doodledog.

Mollygo Tue 04-Jul-23 15:21:34

Doodledog
If the answer is that it is not safe for those who are not 'male identifying' men to be around men when they are vulnerable, why are women expected to do so now?

This is the best reason I’ve seen for a long time to explain to everyone, even to the most ardent IF, why there’s a need for single sex toilets or separate gender neutral toilets or *colonisation of men’s toilets to accommodate TW.*

On a separate point it’s really funny to see deviations from the OP from posters who complain about others doing that.

Callistemon21 Tue 04-Jul-23 15:22:55

I saw a post on FB by a man who was upset to find that, at a recent public event, women were "queuing up to use the men's toilets!" 😯
There were even longer queues for the ladies' loos but he was quite put out by this.

Doodledog Tue 04-Jul-23 15:23:50

On a separate point it’s really funny to see deviations from the OP from posters who complain about others doing that.
Double standards agogo, but what's new?

Smileless2012 Tue 04-Jul-23 15:40:47

Twas ever this Molly and Doodledog.

Glorianny Tue 04-Jul-23 16:00:07

NotSpaghetti it was very naughty of you to introduce the tik-tok recording on this thread and lead the rest of us astray. Consider yourself chastised. grin
I freely admit to being led astray! Mea culpa! Mea culpa

Rowantree Tue 04-Jul-23 17:13:17

I remember the good old days of 1971.
I had joined in a student demonstration and we were 'sitting in' one of the London colleges overnight.
(Don't ask me what it was about - I've long since forgotten!)
Anyway, when I went to the loo, the Ladies /Gents signs had been crossed out and someone had stuck on pieces of paper stating simply: 'People's Bog.'
No one batted an eyelid, as far as I knew.

Rowantree Tue 04-Jul-23 17:17:49

Calistemon I've done just that many times. Long queues at women's toilets and none in men's. So I do sometimes use them.

Rowantree Tue 04-Jul-23 17:49:39

Something further has occurred to me.
If there are pupils at school identifying as cats, aren't schools duty-bound to provide litter trays?

Mollygo Tue 04-Jul-23 18:02:17

Rowantree
Are you saying that your 1971 experience justifies the introduction of gender neutral toilets, which facilitated the sexual assault by the 16 year old male in the OP.
I have never been faced with an obviously male or TW (appearance or behaviour) in washrooms in France, Germany, Italy, The Netherlands, Switzerland or Portugal. I could extrapolate from that, that TW in Europe are better behaved than those in examples we have seen in the UK.

Don’t go into the cat discussion. A poster has criticised other posters for deviating from the OP.

Rowantree Tue 04-Jul-23 23:25:03

Mollygo no, don't think I'm using my 1971 experience to justify anything. Simply amused that it's nothing new.
The alleged cat issue isn't fact anyway. It was dreamed up by a tabloid.

Doodledog Tue 04-Jul-23 23:59:07

grin grin

Have you read the thread, Rowantree?

This is one of the ways that diversions happen.

JaneJudge Thu 06-Jul-23 10:05:09

I think the question to this diversion is, if my cat identifies as female can he use the toilet or does he have to time travel to 1971 and get involved in a cats can be female too student demo

NotSpaghetti Thu 06-Jul-23 18:04:40

Well, JaneJudge, is he/she a student???

JaneJudge Thu 06-Jul-23 19:18:01

whether he is a student or not is just a distraction 😂

ronib Fri 07-Jul-23 07:17:34

Do cats know if they are male or female?

Doodledog Fri 07-Jul-23 07:52:02

Yes. To the naked eye, cats may seem to have a lot of time on their hands/paws, but they don’t waste it fretting over whether or not they should spray their territory, and if they should protect their kittens against all comers. If they feel like doing something they just do it.

They don’t get upset about whether they are called Fifi (she/her) or Fang (he/him) either, despite their massive egos.