Gransnet forums

News & politics

Labour and the Tories have disenfranchised me

(281 Posts)
ferry23 Thu 13-Jun-24 05:38:14

I always vote. Even at our Parish Council elections. Like so many, I feel I have an obligation to those who fought so hard for me to have that basic right.

This time I feel completely disenfranchised as I have no desire to vote for any of them. I've recently moved from a constituency where the MP works tirelessly for the constituents and, I believe, goes the extra mile in supporting charitable and community projects and initiatives. I was happy to vote for him even if I was a bit disillusioned with his party line.

This time around, after thinking long and hard, I probably won't vote. It goes against everything I believe in and how I was brought up.

Maybe my thinking is naive, or just a way of justifying my decision, but I believe that by NOT voting I am showing my contempt at a broken political system and because of that contempt I CHOOSE not to vote and thanks to those who allowed me to have that choice.

It's like deciding whether I should vote for Jack the Ripper or Harold Shipman. angry

Jaxjacky Thu 13-Jun-24 10:08:46

I feel I’ll be voting to keep a party out, rather than for one I want in.

Luckygirl3 Thu 13-Jun-24 10:20:02

You cannot choose to vote for the "sitting MP rather than his party" - that makes no sense. However good that MP might be locally, if he/she represents a party with national policies that you do not want, then why saddle the country with that?

I too have an excellent local MP (Tory), but there is no way I could give his party ammunition to further mess up by voting for him on that basis.

This website - stopthetories.vote/ - tells you which candidate is the most likely to oust the Tories in your constituency - you just enter your postcode and it gives the latest polls.

ronib Thu 13-Jun-24 10:40:54

Integrity or lack of in politicians? Was integrity a mirage?

Whitewavemark2 Thu 13-Jun-24 10:49:39

Whoever you vote for, assuming it will be someone who is a member of a political party, you are ALWAYS voting for the party.

The whipping system ensures that.

If they rebel consistently, they will eventually be sacked from the party.

AGAA4 Thu 13-Jun-24 10:54:55

I will be voting but I'm not happy with either of the main parties. I will vote for the party I feel will do the least damage in the coming years.

Grandma70s Thu 13-Jun-24 10:55:58

Where I live Labour always gets in, so I don’t have to vote Labour to keep the Tories out. I shall have a choice between. Lib Dem and Green. Not sure yet which one I’ll go for.

Farzanah Thu 13-Jun-24 11:14:07

Thanks for the link Luckygirl. It shows that the Tory MP in my constituency with 50+% of vote in 2019 will easily be beaten by the Labour candidate.
I wonder where they get their voter intentions data?

Lovetopaint037 Thu 13-Jun-24 11:18:38

Well I know who I won’t vote for. That is the easy part. Certainly won’t be Farage/Reform or Tory. Nor the Greens as they messed up Brighton and have now had investigations into how the cloak of good intentions is hiding those who have less desirable ideologies. Then there is the Lib/Dems but Ed Davy didn’t come out of the Post Master scandal well. Also not interested in daily comic act - had enough of that with Johnson. That leaves Labour. Unlike the popular feeling that he is “boring” I see “serious” and someone who scrutinises detail. Fed up to the teeth with showmen and liers.
Also someone who spent time undertaking unpaid work for the disadvantaged in his past. There you are you take a chance and vote but as said above don’t complain if you don’t.

biglouis Thu 13-Jun-24 11:23:34

I always vote as I have a postal vote. However Labour and Conservative are like two cheeks of the same ass. And Reform are not really right wing enough for me.

Farzanah Thu 13-Jun-24 11:26:38

I hate the idea of ReformUK and all it stands for. I can’t imagine voting for them even as a “protest” vote, and giving them and Farage, any encouragement at all.

ronib Thu 13-Jun-24 11:33:31

131 pages Labour’s manifesto! Why is it so long?

Whitewavemark2 Thu 13-Jun-24 11:53:42

ronib

131 pages Labour’s manifesto! Why is it so long?

I suppose a quick crib sheet could have been handed out. But that will be in the newspapers etc.

I don’t read it all at once, but use it for reference when I want to look up an issue.

We are talking about governing the U.K. which I think deserves a serious manifesto for very serious times.

ronib Thu 13-Jun-24 11:57:45

Yes Wwm2 quite agree - serious manifesto for very serious times . So cut the waffle and get to the chase. 131 pages is ridiculous.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 13-Jun-24 12:01:52

ronib

Yes Wwm2 quite agree - serious manifesto for very serious times . So cut the waffle and get to the chase. 131 pages is ridiculous.

Cut to the chase?

A manifesto for growth

Wish that short enough?

Witzend Thu 13-Jun-24 12:02:58

If anything, IMO the general opinion of non-voters is that they’re apathetic, and/or just can’t be bothered.

But I can understand why anyone wouldn’t feel like voting for any of them. IMO there should be a box on the ballot paper that says, ‘None of the above inspires me with any confidence.’

All such votes then to be counted, and the total stated with the other results.

Dinahmo Thu 13-Jun-24 12:06:47

We have gone to great lengths to vote in the upcoming election as although we live in France we do not like what has happened to the UK with the austerity of the last 14 years.

When we moved to Suffolk our MP was John Selwyn Gummer. He was elected to Eye in 1979 and remained in the larger Suffolk Coastal until he retired from the commons in 2020. He was a good constituency MP, although not of my political persuasion. Sadly his replacement, Therese Coffey was not so good. She was in favour of the govt's plans to sell off forestry and woodland in public ownership (later shelved) and for pensioners to pay NIC on earnings.

With a bit of luck she won't win this time.

maddyone Thu 13-Jun-24 12:07:10

I cannot vote for either of the main parties. I cannot vote Green or LibDem. I cannot vote Reform. Where does that leave me? There is an independent candidate putting up in my constituency but he won’t get in. Shall I simply spoil my ballot paper to register my utter dismay and disgust with the two main parties?
I will definitely go to the polling station and vote or spoil my paper.

ronib Thu 13-Jun-24 12:14:34

Wwm2 have we not heard growing the economy before ? Before the economy collapsed again? Saying something just doesn’t make it happen or so I remind my grandchildren.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 13-Jun-24 12:23:00

ronib

Wwm2 have we not heard growing the economy before ? Before the economy collapsed again? Saying something just doesn’t make it happen or so I remind my grandchildren.

Then from your misunderstanding I would refer you to the manifesto.

Two clear tenants outlined by the speakers at the beginning.

Health and Housing

growstuff Thu 13-Jun-24 12:32:08

The FPTP system has always disenfranchised me because I've always lived in a constituency with a huge Conservative majority (and I've never voted Conservative).

Nevertheless, I've always voted because it gives some indication of the opinions of those on the "losing" side and it adds a few pence to the coffers of the party I vote for.

I wouldn't consider it appropriate to have an opinion about anything, if I hadn't at least tried to vote in somebody who would represent me and my opinions better.

growstuff Thu 13-Jun-24 12:32:53

maddyone

I cannot vote for either of the main parties. I cannot vote Green or LibDem. I cannot vote Reform. Where does that leave me? There is an independent candidate putting up in my constituency but he won’t get in. Shall I simply spoil my ballot paper to register my utter dismay and disgust with the two main parties?
I will definitely go to the polling station and vote or spoil my paper.

Vote for the independent, if he/she represents your views.

growstuff Thu 13-Jun-24 12:34:51

Dinahmo

We have gone to great lengths to vote in the upcoming election as although we live in France we do not like what has happened to the UK with the austerity of the last 14 years.

When we moved to Suffolk our MP was John Selwyn Gummer. He was elected to Eye in 1979 and remained in the larger Suffolk Coastal until he retired from the commons in 2020. He was a good constituency MP, although not of my political persuasion. Sadly his replacement, Therese Coffey was not so good. She was in favour of the govt's plans to sell off forestry and woodland in public ownership (later shelved) and for pensioners to pay NIC on earnings.

With a bit of luck she won't win this time.

She has a massive majority. I suspect she will retain her seat.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 13-Jun-24 12:38:51

What I will say is that both parties are saying that they are going for growth, and both have the same uphill struggle in achieving this growth.

However Labours focus on using the wealth for the NHS and investment in the infrastructure and housing rather than tax cuts as the Tories promise.

For my money tax cuts don’t buy cancer treatment or heart operations nor does it produce a house for my grandchildren.

It is a matter of focus.

Mollygo Thu 13-Jun-24 12:40:36

Whitewavemark2

We need to reform the FPTP system and introduce some form of PR and then your vote will always be meaningful.

It wouldn’t solve all problems, but it would certainly help.
Sad thing is that the opposition is more likely to push for that . . . until they win an election.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 13-Jun-24 12:41:24

growstuff

Dinahmo

We have gone to great lengths to vote in the upcoming election as although we live in France we do not like what has happened to the UK with the austerity of the last 14 years.

When we moved to Suffolk our MP was John Selwyn Gummer. He was elected to Eye in 1979 and remained in the larger Suffolk Coastal until he retired from the commons in 2020. He was a good constituency MP, although not of my political persuasion. Sadly his replacement, Therese Coffey was not so good. She was in favour of the govt's plans to sell off forestry and woodland in public ownership (later shelved) and for pensioners to pay NIC on earnings.

With a bit of luck she won't win this time.

She has a massive majority. I suspect she will retain her seat.

She, along with Truss (her bestie) are considered to be the worse ministers ever by DEFRA.