Gransnet forums

News & politics

Labour and the Tories have disenfranchised me

(281 Posts)
ferry23 Thu 13-Jun-24 05:38:14

I always vote. Even at our Parish Council elections. Like so many, I feel I have an obligation to those who fought so hard for me to have that basic right.

This time I feel completely disenfranchised as I have no desire to vote for any of them. I've recently moved from a constituency where the MP works tirelessly for the constituents and, I believe, goes the extra mile in supporting charitable and community projects and initiatives. I was happy to vote for him even if I was a bit disillusioned with his party line.

This time around, after thinking long and hard, I probably won't vote. It goes against everything I believe in and how I was brought up.

Maybe my thinking is naive, or just a way of justifying my decision, but I believe that by NOT voting I am showing my contempt at a broken political system and because of that contempt I CHOOSE not to vote and thanks to those who allowed me to have that choice.

It's like deciding whether I should vote for Jack the Ripper or Harold Shipman. angry

Casdon Fri 14-Jun-24 11:55:14

I think you’ve not been given the full picture on the NHS annual leave issue Dinamho. The maximum possible entitlement for full time nurses with over 19 years service is 33 days. The NHS has 8 bank holidays, which are added to the leave allowance if you work shifts so can’t take the bank holiday off work. So, for a full time nurse the maximum allowance is 41 days.
I’d guess the nurses you refer to work regular additional hours every week, and accrue time in lieu rather than being paid overtime, which would account for the other 14 days per year they claim is annual leave.

AGAA4 Fri 14-Jun-24 11:57:37

Although the polls are showing a lead for Labour. I have been surprised by how many, in my world, have said they are staying with the Conservatives. I don't trust polls because many people are not sure yet what to vote.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 14-Jun-24 11:57:57

11 weeks? Good grief!

ronib Fri 14-Jun-24 12:08:33

I thought gps had very long holiday entitlement?

Casdon Fri 14-Jun-24 12:09:10

GPS are self employed ronib.

AGAA4 Fri 14-Jun-24 12:13:03

My DD is a senior nurse practitioner and she certainly doesn't get that many holidays.

ronib Fri 14-Jun-24 12:25:17

Casdon

GPS are self employed ronib.

Casdon salaried gps?

Wyllow3 Fri 14-Jun-24 12:32:56

Most of the Labour Shadow Cabinet members have had a great deal of experience in parliament. Just as the Conservatives who took over from Labour 14 years ago had had experience in Parliament during the Labour years.

More to the immediate points, how many Conservatives currently in the government are trusted by the electorate. I've read the manifesto and took part in one group about whats needed NHS wise.

The Labour manifesto isn't actually drastically planned, its very moderate steps forward. They've already made clear to the doctors they aren't going to get the 35%!

I trust the costings adequately.

""As an ‘insider’, I would expect you to have the answers" no, I don't pretend to be au fait with details of all policies so not
going to start on the huge issue of controlled immigration and big scale migration tho there is of course L Party policy in the manifesto and broadly agree with the fast processing and investment and involvement in anti people smuggling pan European initiatives.

If we are to discuss it I'd happily join a thread on it, but its interesting that none has been started or iirc raised on this thread.

(Its interesting its also not raised as frequently as it might be on the big TV debates except by one issue Farage - I don't know if its avoidance or greater immediate concerns)

growstuff Fri 14-Jun-24 12:33:55

Germanshepherdsmum

We would indeed be in the hands of amateurs with Labour. Do they seriously think that electricity prices are the biggest factor in most people’s fuel bills? Many millions rely on oil and gas to heat their homes and cook, and of course run petrol and diesel vehicles - but whilst saying that we must be independent of foreign powers for fuel, they will grant no new licences for North Sea exploration. Too many are being taken in by the hype and seemingly cannot think it through. I would love the opportunity to grill Labour on their plans.

Electricity prices are the biggest factor in most people's fuel bills. And, yes, I know some people have oil or other forms of fuel.

I have electricity and gas. My central heating and water are heated by gas, as is my hob. My electricity bill is currently twice my gas bill, so it is the biggest factor in my fuel bill. My electricity standing charge is about a third of my total electricity bill.

Obviously, my gas use increases during the colder months when the central heating is switched on, but my total electricity bill is still higher.

I live in a standard, well insulated modern-ish house. I suspect most (ie more than half of people) are like me.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 14-Jun-24 12:50:26

My son’s heating is fuelled by oil - no other option in the village - and the house has an oil-fired Aga (installed by previous owners). This is not an unusual situation in the countryside - we have no gas in our village. Gas is cheaper than oil but it is unavailable to a great many people, who have no option but to use oil.

I doubt that most people live in a well-insulated modern house. A huge amount of the housing stock is old and incapable of being well-insulated.

eazybee Fri 14-Jun-24 12:52:11

You have not been disenfranchised by any party; the majority of MPs are like the one you describe; just put more thought and consideration into your choice than you normally would do. But to refuse to vote is cowardly; a broken political system will not be repaired by the electorate withholding their votes. Get out there and campaign for what you believe in; do not succumb to apathy.

growstuff Fri 14-Jun-24 13:01:04

Germanshepherdsmum

My son’s heating is fuelled by oil - no other option in the village - and the house has an oil-fired Aga (installed by previous owners). This is not an unusual situation in the countryside - we have no gas in our village. Gas is cheaper than oil but it is unavailable to a great many people, who have no option but to use oil.

I doubt that most people live in a well-insulated modern house. A huge amount of the housing stock is old and incapable of being well-insulated.

I know. I once lived in a house in a village where there was no mains gas, but most people don't have oil.

Look around you, at the amount of new building (people are always complaining about it) and the number of houses which have been built in the last 20/30 years.

I'm well aware that some areas have crumbling housing stock, but most homes can be well-insulated and have mains gas.

Franbern Fri 14-Jun-24 13:11:54

The First past the vote system is dreadful, and whilst we have that there is no way is the UK a democratic country.

If there are smaller parties standing in a constituency who may nearer reflect a voters wishes, then vote for them, do not be mislead with this silly idea of 'strategic voting', which only perpetuates the FPTP system.

If the is really no-one on thE ballot paper who you feel you can vote for then still go, collect that voting slip, cross them all out putting clearly NONE OF TH ABOVE.

Do NOT JUST NOT VOTE.

My first votes were cast in 1964 - for the very first time since then I will not be voting Labour as the Labour Party has one out of existence (despite one still falsely using that name).

Over the past five years, as the Tories have continually moved to the right, so Starmars' party has then moved into the space they left. Starmars' party is now virtually identical to the Conservative party as it was before Johnson.

My vote is going to the Greens.

Casdon Fri 14-Jun-24 13:42:30

ronib

Casdon

GPS are self employed ronib.

Casdon salaried gps?

This is the annual leave entitlement for doctors employed by the NHS at all grades for you ronib.

www.bma.org.uk/pay-and-contracts/leave/annual-leave-entitlement/doctors-annual-leave-entitlements

Salaried GPs entitlements almost exactly mirror the entitlements for nurses I outlined above.

ronib Fri 14-Jun-24 14:04:02

Casdon plus of course Bank Holiday entitlement 8 days this year? Not too bad?

pascal30 Fri 14-Jun-24 14:09:09

Franbern

The First past the vote system is dreadful, and whilst we have that there is no way is the UK a democratic country.

If there are smaller parties standing in a constituency who may nearer reflect a voters wishes, then vote for them, do not be mislead with this silly idea of 'strategic voting', which only perpetuates the FPTP system.

If the is really no-one on thE ballot paper who you feel you can vote for then still go, collect that voting slip, cross them all out putting clearly NONE OF TH ABOVE.

Do NOT JUST NOT VOTE.

My first votes were cast in 1964 - for the very first time since then I will not be voting Labour as the Labour Party has one out of existence (despite one still falsely using that name).

Over the past five years, as the Tories have continually moved to the right, so Starmars' party has then moved into the space they left. Starmars' party is now virtually identical to the Conservative party as it was before Johnson.

My vote is going to the Greens.

Mine too Franbern,, though how our candidate will replace Caroline Lucas is to be seen..

Casdon Fri 14-Jun-24 14:19:39

ronib

Casdon plus of course Bank Holiday entitlement 8 days this year? Not too bad?

Not sure what you mean ronib, do you think professional staff should get less than that?

Luckygirl3 Fri 14-Jun-24 14:50:43

Franbern

The First past the vote system is dreadful, and whilst we have that there is no way is the UK a democratic country.

If there are smaller parties standing in a constituency who may nearer reflect a voters wishes, then vote for them, do not be mislead with this silly idea of 'strategic voting', which only perpetuates the FPTP system.

If the is really no-one on thE ballot paper who you feel you can vote for then still go, collect that voting slip, cross them all out putting clearly NONE OF TH ABOVE.

Do NOT JUST NOT VOTE.

My first votes were cast in 1964 - for the very first time since then I will not be voting Labour as the Labour Party has one out of existence (despite one still falsely using that name).

Over the past five years, as the Tories have continually moved to the right, so Starmars' party has then moved into the space they left. Starmars' party is now virtually identical to the Conservative party as it was before Johnson.

My vote is going to the Greens.

Strategic/tactical voting does not perpetuate the awful FPTP system (which I agree is undemocratic) - it plays that system in order to get as near as possible to the wishes of the populace. No-one wants to have to do this, but what other option is there when so many constituencies finish up with an MP for whom the majority of the electorate did not vote?

A vote for the Greens (however much you agree with their policies) is a vote down the pan, especially in areas (like most) where they stand no chance of winning. Similarly with other small parties.

It is a travesty of democracy when we are forced to play the system in this way.

ronib Fri 14-Jun-24 14:55:37

Casdon far be it from me to judge the medical profession… but the holiday entitlement does include Bank Holidays as an extra and I don’t think that was mentioned?

ronib Fri 14-Jun-24 15:02:08

Meanwhile Farage is demanding a debate with Starmer, as Farage is the self appointed next leader of the opposition. So from a party with not one elected mp, to the main opposition in one fell swoop. Remarkable.
I hope voters remember this dire period in our democracy once it’s all over.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 14-Jun-24 15:05:12

I don’t like Farage but I would like to see him questioning Starmer.

Casdon Fri 14-Jun-24 15:09:55

ronib

Casdon far be it from me to judge the medical profession… but the holiday entitlement does include Bank Holidays as an extra and I don’t think that was mentioned?

It’s the national minimum for bank holidays ronib, all employees in the UK get it? I also mentioned that doctors get the same total leave entitlement as nurses, and had split between annual leave and bank holidays? I don’t know what you’re driving at, can you explain?

Casdon Fri 14-Jun-24 15:14:52

Germanshepherdsmum

I don’t like Farage but I would like to see him questioning Starmer.

I’d be fine with that, as long as it’s four way, as Reform are in third place, with the Lib Dem’s very close behind them and set to win a lot more seats - but I’d much rather Farage faced the same level of scrutiny that Sunak and Starmer did in the leaders interviews. He’s not undergone any tough scrutiny regarding his policies yet, and that is what is needed.

Germanshepherdsmum Fri 14-Jun-24 15:20:07

I simply want to see Starmer properly grilled and put on the spot. That hasn’t happened yet. His manifesto is full of lies and half-truths and he knows it. Farage doesn’t pull his punches. I think he would do a good job of exposing Starmer and his party for what they are.

ronib Fri 14-Jun-24 15:25:42

Gsm why on earth can’t the Conservative Party ask the right questions of Starmer? Why expect Farage of all people to step in where Sunak should be leading?