Anniversary of Israeli massacre

Hamas and the current regime in Israel have both at different times been prepared to negotiate but under terms the other side will not accept.

I can't see it happening if the current Israeli regime continues to force civilians in Northern Gaza - nearly a third of this small region - to move south leaving behind everything they know, their homes, businesses, their ill and elderly (well, whats left of them).

I really do believe in the right of Israel to be a home for Jewish people, I've always said that, but many events of the last year have made me wonder now if taking over the whole of Palestine isn't the real aim of the current regime. Leaving Gaza aside for the moment, their continuing expansion into the West Bank seems to point that way.

Anniebach

Hamas negotiate ?

If they don’t Annie how will they get the hostages back or try to negotiate a peaceful settlement for all. At some point they have to get round a negotiating table, just as the British government had to do with Sinn Fein and the Loyalists. What other options are there?

Wyllow3

Hamas and the current regime in Israel have both at different times been prepared to negotiate but under terms the other side will not accept.

I can't see it happening if the current Israeli regime continues to force civilians in Northern Gaza - nearly a third of this small region - to move south leaving behind everything they know, their homes, businesses, their ill and elderly (well, whats left of them).

I really do believe in the right of Israel to be a home for Jewish people, I've always said that, but many events of the last year have made me wonder now if taking over the whole of Palestine isn't the real aim of the current regime. Leaving Gaza aside for the moment, their continuing expansion into the West Bank seems to point that way.

If Netanyahu’s concern was for the hostages he would have tried to negotiate rather than seeking to displace 40,000 people from Northern Gaza in order to lay siege to Hamas but also those too old or ill to leave etc.,in order to land grab Northern Gaza for Israel. These are not the actions if a man who gives a flying toss about the hostages.
There are supposed to be peace talks in Cairo next week and Hamas had agreed to go, now who knows???

And I agree Wyllow, Israel should be a safe homeland for Jewish people but also a safe homeland for Palestinians. One people should not force the others out.

Quote Babs03 Sun 27-Oct-24 15:05:27
Anniebach
Hamas negotiate ?
If they don’t Annie how will they get the hostages back or try to negotiate a peaceful settlement for all. At some point they have to get round a negotiating table, just as the British government had to do with Sinn Fein and the Loyalists. What other options are there?

Sinn Fein a political party, please name the Hamas political party,

Well, just lets say, whichever regime currently holds power.

Hamas sitting with elected leaders ! Such is the power of terrorists .

Hamas were elected as a political party and don’t forget that Sinn Fein were the political front for the IRA until after the GFA.
People have sat down with those they despise and see as murderers in order to achieve peace for their people. And of course in order for hostages to be released.

Yes Hamas are elected , easy to forget isn’t it

Anniebach

Yes Hamas are elected , easy to forget isn’t it

It was so long ago.

Yes, but they are an elected party

fwiw Gerry Adams was leader of Sinn Fein from 1983 - 2018, the NI peace agreement was 1998. Sorry but I think it's nonsense to say you can't deal with terrorists, I can think of many countries where that has happened, South Africa, Kenya etc etc.
109 hostages were released in August following negotiations and a temporary cease fire. how many have been released by the IDF actions? I think it's 8!

Hamas are an elected party. We have seen video of people in
Gaza celebrating when a dead female hostage driven through the streets. Hamas run the. hospitals Gaza, many doctors from
Gaza have spoken of attacks by Israel.

Neither have Muslims. Islam is a peaceful religion. Never forget the illegal wars in iraq and Afghanistan

@foxie and if the hostages are in northern Gaza which is more than likely God help them in this latest onslaught.
If Netanyahu really cared he would have negotiated in the beginning when Qatar was attempting to meditate, instead he simply forged ahead with a genocide that needn’t have happened and Qatar washed their hands of him.
Anything that happens to the hostages as a result of The General’s Plan is on Netanyahu not Hamas.

Anything which happens to the hostages is the result of their
kidnappers Hamas

Message deleted by Gransnet. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Kalm

Neither have Muslims. Islam is a peaceful religion. Never forget the illegal wars in iraq and Afghanistan

Hamas is a peaceful organization, that had nothing to do with the attack on Israel last year Sinwar didn’t plan it it’s all lies!

Yes NI is a good analogy. The unionists were basically removed of their powers and privileges and they became disunited. Republicans felt that they would be greatly empowered e.g. removal of travel restriction with the south and the two referendums. A meaningful output being is that a democratic mandate that would mean a united ireland. All parties with sen mitchell as a neutral arbiter were told in no uncertain terms to lay down their arms. It was always muted that EU membership would help as far back as 2005. With Brexit there is now unhindered travel and the armed conflict is virtually gone. So let the people of gaza and west bank democratically decide whether they continue to be ruled by Israel. Simultaneously The IDF should be removed and replaced by a neutral international force excluding the UK/USA as the Palestinians won’t trust them. A force comprising eg Ireland, Spain, indonesia Malaysia would govern temporarily. All Palestinian prisoners as well as any Israelis should be released. Masjid e aqsa to be controlled by muslims to enable worship but would allow non muslims except IDF for all religions.
All the those murdered in Gaza would need reparations for the next 3 generations, so the intergenerational animosity is removed.

Fantasy land Kalm but at least gave me a laugh.

Well,funny it is not Oreo.

I think Oreo knows that.

40000 + deaths not funny, the irony being the children (the ones not dead) still singing for freedom. As they say……go figure

Root cause analysis ? Occupation? The trap here is for people to say “what about the jews ?” ….which I won’t because all the jews I have come across are against the Israeli genocide of Palestinians. The JVP in the USA are also to be applauded, as the “antisemitism” charge cannot be used. As an aside my last discussion with jewish person was about kosher and assisted dying….the religious commonality has more similarities than differences.

It’s all about using religion to control the population Hamas is telling the population if you die fighting it will send you to paradise so Hamas is no better than any power hungry dictator.
Iran and Afghanistan is the same and all the other regimes that use religion to impose strict control on the population

They are no different to the Nazis of WW2 they have to be destroyed