Gransnet forums

News & politics

Have the Conservatives signed their own death warrant?

(225 Posts)
M0nica Wed 09-Oct-24 16:33:43

The finl choice is between Jenrick and Badenoch, both Reformist Conservatives. Might suit the Conservative party membership, but what matters is nott he membership but the voter.

If you are to the right of the right, why not just vote Reform and get the real deal, but the majority of voters straddle the centre left/right and the Centre right will not vote for a right wing Reformist Conservative party.

Wyllow3 Sat 12-Oct-24 09:08:03

Jenrick is cleaning up his image

"Robert Jenrick has suggests it was a mistake for him to order murals of cartoon characters at a children’s asylum centre to be painted over when he was immigration minister.

Only last week, at Tory conference, Jenrick was defending the decision, which at the time led to him accused of being heartless.

But in an interview with LBC this morning (yesterday) he said he would not do the same thing again."

www.lbc.co.uk/news/i-wouldnt-do-it-again-jenrick-suggests-regret-for-painting-over-murals-asylum/

GrannyGravy13 Sat 12-Oct-24 09:21:30

Wanting secure borders, wanting to know who is entering the UK and why is not racist

Being wary of so called hate preachers in UK mosques who are seen on SM platforms calling women who wear perfume, do not cover up are whores and the lowest of the low, does not make one Islamophobic.

Finding the riots this summer appalling does not make one anti white.

All the above are just traits of concerned citizens.

Whatever party reassures the electorate they take these seriously, along with a plan for growth, NHS (including social care), education along with a fairer tax system will probably win the next election.

Soundbites are yesterday, smash the gangs, stop the boats, grow the economy etc. are meaningless white noise.

growstuff Sat 12-Oct-24 09:23:56

I wish your last sentence were true GrannyGravy.

PS. I agree with the rest of your post.

Fleurpepper Sat 12-Oct-24 09:24:17

JudyBloom

Reform are not hard right, nor are they racist, they are on the side of the 'Silen(ced) Majority' of this country who just want to preserve our values and put British people first, whatever their creed or colour. The media and other parties want you to believe that Reform are hard right because they fear their popularity.

And how do you describe 'British' - who is 'British' in your terminology?

growstuff Sat 12-Oct-24 09:24:45

JudyBloom

Reform are not hard right, nor are they racist, they are on the side of the 'Silen(ced) Majority' of this country who just want to preserve our values and put British people first, whatever their creed or colour. The media and other parties want you to believe that Reform are hard right because they fear their popularity.

I disagree with your post.

Reform is on the side of itself.

growstuff Sat 12-Oct-24 09:27:46

Fleurpepper

JudyBloom

Reform are not hard right, nor are they racist, they are on the side of the 'Silen(ced) Majority' of this country who just want to preserve our values and put British people first, whatever their creed or colour. The media and other parties want you to believe that Reform are hard right because they fear their popularity.

And how do you describe 'British' - who is 'British' in your terminology?

And what are 'our' values? I would put money on my values being different from yours JudyBloom. And I'm about as English as you could get! I've been dabbling in family history for decades and (as far as I know) I don't even have any Welsh, Scottish or Irish ancestors from the last five hundred years, never mind anybody from foreign shores.

Oreo Sat 12-Oct-24 09:28:03

GrannyGravy13

Wanting secure borders, wanting to know who is entering the UK and why is not racist

Being wary of so called hate preachers in UK mosques who are seen on SM platforms calling women who wear perfume, do not cover up are whores and the lowest of the low, does not make one Islamophobic.

Finding the riots this summer appalling does not make one anti white.

All the above are just traits of concerned citizens.

Whatever party reassures the electorate they take these seriously, along with a plan for growth, NHS (including social care), education along with a fairer tax system will probably win the next election.

Soundbites are yesterday, smash the gangs, stop the boats, grow the economy etc. are meaningless white noise.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Add 22 billion black hole to the soundbites as well😄

Mollygo Sat 12-Oct-24 09:29:35

Thanks for that post GrannyGravy13.

foxie48 Sat 12-Oct-24 09:49:30

JudyBloom

Reform are not hard right, nor are they racist, they are on the side of the 'Silen(ced) Majority' of this country who just want to preserve our values and put British people first, whatever their creed or colour. The media and other parties want you to believe that Reform are hard right because they fear their popularity.

I also totally disagree with your post. Reform does not appeal to the silent or "silenced" majority, they appeal to the worst in people not the best. What are these British values that you want to uphold? I strongly suspect they are very different to mine and those of my family and friends. fwiw I want an immigration service that is effective and fair, the difference is I do not see every problem that we have as a society being solved by demonising immigrants and asylum seekers and from Reform I see nothing else.

eggplant Sat 12-Oct-24 09:57:10

You will be totally suppressed. Its happening here already!

Can you give me some examples of this repression please?

Reform's unique selling point is immigration

Some immigration, not all

Allira Sat 12-Oct-24 09:58:58

If Reform appealed to the Silence(d) Majority wouldn't they have nearer 609 MPs now?
An overwhelming majority?

growstuff Sat 12-Oct-24 10:00:44

Allira

If Reform appealed to the Silence(d) Majority wouldn't they have nearer 609 MPs now?
An overwhelming majority?

Obviously somebody silenced them when they came to put a secret cross on a ballot paper. hmm

eggplant Sat 12-Oct-24 10:01:40

Who are this majority and in what way are they silenced?

37 percent of doctors are immigrants. So next time you are ill and vulnerable perhaps you coudl say you are one of the silent majority an ask for an alternative?

Wyllow3 Sat 12-Oct-24 10:04:26

Reforms other policies put them at the far right end of the spectrum.

But I don't see why anyone objects to the descriptive term of "far right" anymore than "centrist conservative" or "left centrist" politics" or "far left" politics, we need terms to be able to discuss matters.

To return to the Conservative Leadership elections, I feel that the candidates should be assessed not on immigration policies but the whole raft of social and economic issues, if the end game is to build an opposition that will deal with the nitty gritty of law making and governance and clearly defined intentions to improve our lives in work, health, education, retirement and so on.

BevSec Sat 12-Oct-24 10:22:46

But not my grandchildren Growstuff

BevSec Sat 12-Oct-24 10:24:41

JudyBloom, your post is excellent, Reform are not hard right and do speak for the silenced majority.

growstuff Sat 12-Oct-24 10:26:28

BevSec

JudyBloom, your post is excellent, Reform are not hard right and do speak for the silenced majority.

Just because something is repeated doesn't make it true.

growstuff Sat 12-Oct-24 10:27:19

BevSec

But not my grandchildren Growstuff

What about your grandchildren?

Do you have 66 million of them?

growstuff Sat 12-Oct-24 10:30:06

Wyllow3

Reforms other policies put them at the far right end of the spectrum.

But I don't see why anyone objects to the descriptive term of "far right" anymore than "centrist conservative" or "left centrist" politics" or "far left" politics, we need terms to be able to discuss matters.

To return to the Conservative Leadership elections, I feel that the candidates should be assessed not on immigration policies but the whole raft of social and economic issues, if the end game is to build an opposition that will deal with the nitty gritty of law making and governance and clearly defined intentions to improve our lives in work, health, education, retirement and so on.

So do I Wyllow.

To be honest, though, either Jenrick or Badenoch will end up as a leader. I don't think either will be a good party leader. I won't be voting for them anyway, so I don't really care.

BevSec Sat 12-Oct-24 10:30:46

Eggplant, we are not talking about a GP who is here quite legally and very well trained. This is about illegal uncontrolled immigration, which does not make anyone racist who is worried about this. I thought your comment quite unpleasant.

Allira Sat 12-Oct-24 10:32:46

BevSec

JudyBloom, your post is excellent, Reform are not hard right and do speak for the silenced majority.

I'm not following the logic, because if Reform speak for the majority, this majority has the right to choose at the the ballot box even if they keep silent about the way they have voted.

I realise that the FPTP system does not reflect their share of the vote, nor does it with any party, but even so, 14.3% is still not a majority of voters.
The Lib Dem and Plaid seats probably most closely correlate with their share of the vote.

growstuff Sat 12-Oct-24 10:36:20

BevSec

Eggplant, we are not talking about a GP who is here quite legally and very well trained. This is about illegal uncontrolled immigration, which does not make anyone racist who is worried about this. I thought your comment quite unpleasant.

The vast majority of immigrants are in the UK legally, so what's the big issue with immigration?

growstuff Sat 12-Oct-24 10:37:52

Allira

BevSec

JudyBloom, your post is excellent, Reform are not hard right and do speak for the silenced majority.

I'm not following the logic, because if Reform speak for the majority, this majority has the right to choose at the the ballot box even if they keep silent about the way they have voted.

I realise that the FPTP system does not reflect their share of the vote, nor does it with any party, but even so, 14.3% is still not a majority of voters.
The Lib Dem and Plaid seats probably most closely correlate with their share of the vote.

I agree with you Allira. Nobody (as far as I am aware) has been silenced at the ballot box and Reform just did not receive a majority of votes, so what was stopping them?

Wyllow3 Sat 12-Oct-24 10:39:51

My grandchildren are being brought up in a situation where they regularly interact with people of different cultural backgrounds - school, doctors, people in the supermarket...both mum and dad work in multicultural situations -
As they grow up I hope they will stand firmly against extreme views wherever they come from, but seek in humanity what we have in common and stand up to hate-mongering, tarring all people in certain ethnic groups with the worst demonising brush.

eggplant Sat 12-Oct-24 10:40:23

BevSec

Eggplant, we are not talking about a GP who is here quite legally and very well trained. This is about illegal uncontrolled immigration, which does not make anyone racist who is worried about this. I thought your comment quite unpleasant.

In what way is it unpleasant? Im still curious as to this repression which has already started?

Any minute now, I will be donning a swim suit and partaking of some wild swimming, followed by a hearty lunch and a few glasses of wine. I may rant a little in a loud voice about politics.

Where is the repression please?