Gransnet forums

News & politics

Amsterdam attacks

(414 Posts)
ferry23 Fri 08-Nov-24 18:18:07

I'm so sickened by the attacks on Israeli football fans in Amsterdam. Shades of Nazi Germany.

A worrying and disgusting trajectory of anti Semitism in Europe.

Oreo Fri 08-Nov-24 18:24:55

It certainly is.Antisemitism has never gone away of course and is always there simmering under the surface.

Freya5 Fri 08-Nov-24 18:47:40

Absolutely appalling, I haven't been able to watch it, talking to my family over there, people were just hunting and kicking the innocents to the floor.
As one Jewish person said " even after the Shoah, it still goes on".
😢

MaizieD Fri 08-Nov-24 18:52:37

Looking at the BBC coverage it looks to be provocation from both sides.

I suspect that it was more anti Zionist than anti semitic.

And football fans aren't known to be the ,most peaceable folk, on either side.

However, I've nothing further to say.

silverlining48 Fri 08-Nov-24 18:54:43

Just fir balance it was reported that the previous night Israeli football supporters attacked a taxi driver and later a Palestinian flag was taken off a building and burnt. I don’t know if anything else happened.

Oreo Fri 08-Nov-24 18:55:15

They were from Israel, and all the Dutch fans saw were Jews.
The Dutch fans were pro Palestinian. Policing was poor.

madalene Fri 08-Nov-24 18:57:22

ferry23

I'm so sickened by the attacks on Israeli football fans in Amsterdam. Shades of Nazi Germany.

A worrying and disgusting trajectory of anti Semitism in Europe.

I agree ferry.

Anti semitism has never gone away and is worse following the situation in Israel.

escaped Fri 08-Nov-24 18:57:25

This saddens me, in a city where Dutch people did so much to fight antisemitism. I was there earlier this year, and in Dam Square there were a few groups of Palestinian protesters, but it was all peaceful. I'm guessing it all bubbled to the surface with the number of visiting Jewish football fans.
One of the main party leaders has spoken out, We have become the Gaza of Europe. Muslims with Palestinian flags hunting down Jews. He seems very clear who is to blame, and how to deal with it in no uncertain terms.

Oreo Fri 08-Nov-24 19:00:47

Amsterdam, the city where Anne Frank and her family were betrayed.

ferry23 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:01:23

silverlining48

Just fir balance it was reported that the previous night Israeli football supporters attacked a taxi driver and later a Palestinian flag was taken off a building and burnt. I don’t know if anything else happened.

I think your scales of balance need calibrating.

escaped Fri 08-Nov-24 19:07:59

Oreo

Amsterdam, the city where Anne Frank and her family were betrayed.

Yes, a bit off topic, but if anyone is interested, this book is excellent.

silverlining48 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:24:17

So it’s ok to start this by attacking someone ? Their taxi?
Burn a flag ? Chanting anti Arab abuse, Mix that with football fever. Not sure about the taxi driver though. None come out if this well.
Netanyahu talkng about pogroms and nazi Germany is really hyping this up unnecessarily.

Freya5 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:26:29

MaizieD

Looking at the BBC coverage it looks to be provocation from both sides.

I suspect that it was more anti Zionist than anti semitic.

And football fans aren't known to be the ,most peaceable folk, on either side.

However, I've nothing further to say.

The BBC are not the independant news channel they profess to be. I for one never watch it.

Anniebach Fri 08-Nov-24 19:27:27

Anti Zionist is antisemitism

Whitewavemark2 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:29:13

It is not quite as simple or straightforward as the OP suggests. - unfortunately.

Like everything else it seems these days it is two tribes of intolerance and hate.

When will we learn?

Babs03 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:30:10

Apparently both sides were inflamed, but thankfully only light injuries were sustained.
These aren't my words but how it was reported by someone in Amsterdam on the BBC news right now.
My opinion is that blowing this out of proportion will only result in more flash points.

Whitewavemark2 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:32:15

Babs03

Apparently both sides were inflamed, but thankfully only light injuries were sustained.
These aren't my words but how it was reported by someone in Amsterdam on the BBC news right now.
My opinion is that blowing this out of proportion will only result in more flash points.

Yes

Ilovecheese Fri 08-Nov-24 19:32:49

Whitewave and MaisieD are correct. This was not exactly as it is being reported in some quarters.
Anniebach not everyone agrees that your statement is true and they are perfectly entitled to their own opinion.

Cossy Fri 08-Nov-24 19:34:02

In a City such as Amsterdam this is sad and shocking and completely unacceptable.

This has little to do with football and probably even less to do with the average Dutch person, but is a very sad sign of the far right surfacing in Europe.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:34:57

Our neighbours here (in Málaga) are from Amsterdam. They are shocked at the violent scenes depicted. As were we. Truly shocking.

escaped Fri 08-Nov-24 19:43:09

Cossy

In a City such as Amsterdam this is sad and shocking and completely unacceptable.

This has little to do with football and probably even less to do with the average Dutch person, but is a very sad sign of the far right surfacing in Europe.

👏 👏
I think this is much more than simple football hooliganism. It was probably planned, so I am surprised the Dutch police weren't on top of it more.
It's not possible to ignore the historic context here.

silverlining48 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:49:56

Neither side comes out well in this, but no one died or is badly injured and it’s nothing compared to what is going on in Gaza, which is ceaseless in its intensity.
I have just seen people picking up pieces of bodies ….among the ruins of what were once their homes.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:51:12

Seems pogroms have returned to Europe. It’s terrifying, this escalation of violence isn’t it?

BBC reporting this as "clashes between rival fans...". 🤷‍♀️
We need a new phrase to call out antisemitism across our rotten craven illiberal Establishment. Here and in Europe.

FriedGreenTomatoes2 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:53:09

The BBC is reporting this as a "clash between football fans and supporters of Palestine" to emphasise the exact equivalence of the 2 sides. Like Kristallnacht was "a clash between Jewish shopkeepers and the Nazis".

Beggars belief.

Babs03 Fri 08-Nov-24 19:57:53

I don't think that talk of pogroms or Nazis is especially helpful or accurate. If the BBC and other news agencies are all wrong perhaps we should all stop watching the news in any shape or form and just trust those who weren't there/didn't see it to tell us exactly what is going on.