Gransnet forums

News & politics

Assisted dying bill passed.

(109 Posts)
Sago Fri 29-Nov-24 14:31:14

I’m not surprised this bill was passed but in all honesty I really don’t know how I feel about the new legislation.

If I had been given the vote it would have been a tough call.

Are we playing God?

Grantanow Sun 01-Dec-24 09:58:08

To the best of my knowledge there is no requirement on doctors to take the Hippocratic Oath.

GrannyGravy13 Sun 01-Dec-24 10:02:06

Grantanow

To the best of my knowledge there is no requirement on doctors to take the Hippocratic Oath.

I have just been reading up on this and it appears it is part of their graduation ceremony.

Fleurpepper Tue 03-Dec-24 11:36:41

What does 'do no harm' mean, in modern medicine?

Does artificially prolonging a miserable, painful life, against a patient's wishes, add to 'doing harm' or not?

Medical ehtics is a fascinating and very complex subject.

Iam64 Tue 03-Dec-24 13:04:51

medical ethics is a fascinating and very complex subject

It is and currently, the bill recognises this

foxie48 Tue 03-Dec-24 19:44:13

Medical ethics is indeed an interesting subject! DD is just finishing a stint in intensive care as part of her training. She has an issue with other doctors wanting her to accept their patients into ICU when they are going to die anyway. Basically transferring responsibility to the ICU staff rather than dealing with it themselves and taking up an ICU bed, which are in short supply, potentially denying it to someone who with the right care might survive. As she said, working in ICU is very stressful, dealing with death on a daily basis, often of young people and frequently doing your best to keep someone alive but failing can sap your energy and resilience. But fighting for the right of someone to die with dignity, not sedated with a tube down their throat and a machine keeping them alive is just the worst experience. We really need to think more about giving someone a good death rather than extending their life unnecessarily and if this bill helps some terminally ill people, then I'm all for it.

Iam64 Tue 03-Dec-24 19:50:06

Please thank your wise daughter foxie

Fleurpepper Tue 03-Dec-24 20:05:03

Good for your daughter foxie48.

Aveline Tue 03-Dec-24 20:13:08

She's got the right attitude foxie48 good luck to her coping with the other medics.