Gransnet forums

News & politics

J D Vance Munich address today.

(239 Posts)
Sago Fri 14-Feb-25 16:12:44

I have just listened to J D Vance’s speech in Munich today.

It was absolutely spot on, what a man!

Wyllow3 Mon 17-Feb-25 15:24:27

There are plenty of spaces in a democracy to challenge any of our laws, start campaigns, but not at the cost of a relatively small number of spaces that vulnerable women need to use, be they a clinic that includes abortion services, or outside womens refuges.

The US funded ADF, by the way, who are spearing the campaign against abortion, also oppose gay marriage.

They are deliberately trying to turn the debate into one of free speech as opposed to abortion rights, deliberately putting people into buffer zones who are "just praying" but to the vulnerable feel intimidatory and spreading misinformation on being able to pray at home.

But their endgame is to end rights to abortion and gay marriage.

AGAA4 Mon 17-Feb-25 15:55:13

"But their end game is to end rights to abortion and gay marriage"

Spot on Wyllow3 That's what they want.

Galaxy Mon 17-Feb-25 18:37:12

Nope I am able to make my own mind up about free speech, been doing it for years as have many others.

Wyllow3 Mon 17-Feb-25 18:52:01

A hard won right in 1967, and as an activist in the Womens Liberation Movement I was involved in marches in the 1975 The National Abortion Campaign to defend the 1967 Abortion Act and fight against proposed amendments. (so I guess I feel strongly)

I really do take the reservations and feelings people have around it, never an easy discussion, but as discussed in a previous GN thread some states are only allowing it if the mothers life is at risk - Vance is part of that movement and will take any opportunity to further his ideas.

JD Vance’s anti-choice record includes wanting abortion to be “illegal nationally,” attacking exceptions for rape and incest, comparing abortion to slavery, and more.

democrats.org/news/reality-check-jd-vance-says-he-wants-to-make-abortion-illegal-nationally-and-has-attacked-exceptions-for-rape-and-incest/

LizzieDrip Mon 17-Feb-25 19:39:10

Thank you Wyllowflowers

Oreo Mon 17-Feb-25 19:43:50

Lizziedrip why keep sending members flowers for comments? On SM flowers are used as sympathy emojis.Use a smiley emoji instead.

Babs03 Mon 17-Feb-25 19:44:22

Wyllow3

A hard won right in 1967, and as an activist in the Womens Liberation Movement I was involved in marches in the 1975 The National Abortion Campaign to defend the 1967 Abortion Act and fight against proposed amendments. (so I guess I feel strongly)

I really do take the reservations and feelings people have around it, never an easy discussion, but as discussed in a previous GN thread some states are only allowing it if the mothers life is at risk - Vance is part of that movement and will take any opportunity to further his ideas.

JD Vance’s anti-choice record includes wanting abortion to be “illegal nationally,” attacking exceptions for rape and incest, comparing abortion to slavery, and more.

democrats.org/news/reality-check-jd-vance-says-he-wants-to-make-abortion-illegal-nationally-and-has-attacked-exceptions-for-rape-and-incest/

Well done Wyllow.
xx

Oreo Mon 17-Feb-25 19:45:46

Wyllow3

There are plenty of spaces in a democracy to challenge any of our laws, start campaigns, but not at the cost of a relatively small number of spaces that vulnerable women need to use, be they a clinic that includes abortion services, or outside womens refuges.

The US funded ADF, by the way, who are spearing the campaign against abortion, also oppose gay marriage.

They are deliberately trying to turn the debate into one of free speech as opposed to abortion rights, deliberately putting people into buffer zones who are "just praying" but to the vulnerable feel intimidatory and spreading misinformation on being able to pray at home.

But their endgame is to end rights to abortion and gay marriage.

I would hope not, but wouldn’t each State have the say so on anything like these matters?

Wyllow3 Mon 17-Feb-25 19:57:40

Oreo

Lizziedrip why keep sending members flowers for comments? On SM flowers are used as sympathy emojis.Use a smiley emoji instead.

It was probably because this is what I wrote upthread Oreo

*My sister, aged 19, our father recently suddenly dead, just starting uni, our mother in hospital, fell in love with. dreadful man, and became pregnant. (all true, honestly).

She had to have an abortion in her circs. she didn't tell me - she went alone*.

Thinking she should have had to run any gauntlet at all appalls me

Thank you for my flowers Lizzie they were appreciated.

LizzieDrip Mon 17-Feb-25 20:08:24

Oreo
”Lizziedrip why keep sending members flowers for comments? On SM flowers are used as sympathy emojis.Use a smiley emoji instead”

On the GN emojis, there are two flowers; one denoting flowers; one denoting thanks.

Please don’t tell me what emojis to use / not use.

When I want your advice, I’ll ask for it.

flowersflowersflowersflowersflowersflowers

LizzieDrip Mon 17-Feb-25 20:12:24

”Thank you for my flowers Lizzie they were appreciated”

You’re welcome Wyllow.

Namsnanny Tue 18-Feb-25 10:48:17

Galaxy

There is a difference between speech and burning clinics down.

Quite a big difference
In fact two different subjects altogether.

Namsnanny Tue 18-Feb-25 10:56:22

Galaxy

That men cant be women. But surely you know this. Numerous court cases, one going on at the moment, etc, etc.

I'm beginning to wonder if people are ill informed by choice or because the media of their choice literally does not report facts.
The last time I checked the BBC hadn't reported on the WPATH files. If they have by now it's old news.
Is that responsible for a network with such a prestigious history?