Gransnet forums

News & politics

Strewth- a totally different point of view

(195 Posts)
nanna8 Mon 07-Apr-25 01:14:31

We were just sat with a couple of American medical doctors who were avid Trump supporters. They didn’t understand why there is so much opposition to him in the rest of the world. They said he had got rid of a lot of people who did no work but got paid for their services in government circles and that they had witnessed all the waste within government health services and other departments themselves ( didn’t know they had any to be honest, thought it was all private health there). It was interesting to hear that they thought he would save America. They also said the Ukraine is one of the most corrupt regimes in the world (!!) involved with many worldwide illegal trading including that of young girls . Who to believe? They were clearly sensible high achievers. I said Trump may be good for the US but a disaster for everyone else. They didn’t like that at all.

M0nica Wed 09-Apr-25 14:00:07

love0c

We are in trouble in this country and will be in even bigger trouble as the years pass. Why? Because in this country you are 'educated to be told what to think, rather than how to think'.

Since when and what evidence to you have to support your claim?

All people I meet of all ages have immensely different view on everything from believing every conspiracy theory to thinking Jeremy Corbyn is a God. Royalists and rabid antiRoyalists.

There is far more variety of thought now and people are far more willing to say what they think than I can ever remember from my childhood.

I really would like to know on what you base your conclusions or do you just mean people do not agree with you.

IOMGran Wed 09-Apr-25 14:12:29

Norah

Allira

escaped that reminded me of a post-referendum party we went to. 🙂

I have seen comments from several posters that FriedGreenTomatoes2 is always polite despite having differing views from the majority on here and I will agree with that, even though I may disagree with her too.

I agree. FGT2 is always polite and kind.

I disagree with some of her political posts, but I disagree with many things.

Oh well.

Except of you are a foreigner or refugee. Not so nice and kind then.

Parsley3 Wed 09-Apr-25 14:14:34

love0c

We are in trouble in this country and will be in even bigger trouble as the years pass. Why? Because in this country you are 'educated to be told what to think, rather than how to think'.

I would also like to know why you hold this opinion. Who is telling you what to think love0c ? Is it the same source that allows you to post what you want to say?

Cateq Wed 09-Apr-25 14:25:43

With regards to American health care I know for a fact the hospitals regularly overcharge any foreign patients. I’ve seen itemised invoices sent to my previous employer’s travel insurance claims team that billed us for a full box of latex gloves even though they only used 1 glove, likewise tried to charge for full packs of medication even though our customer only received one or two doses. We regularly had to negotiate the price down to what was actually used. Therefore if one of our customers paid the hospital direct they were ripped off. That sounds like corruption to me, the saying people in glass houses should throw stones comes to mind when reading some of comments here.

imaround Wed 09-Apr-25 14:36:56

Not that it makes it any better Cateq, But that practice is not just for foreigners. That is standard practice for all patients. angry this is how they rake in the dough from big insurance amd why most Americans go bankrupt during medical issues.

Obama tried to level the field with the ACA, but Trump managed to gut it during his first term. There is talk that he will do away with it all together in his second, removing all protections for Americans.

imaround Wed 09-Apr-25 14:42:17

SaxonGrace

I couldn’t have put it better myself, I’m not a Trump supporter however my thinking now is that he needs to be given a chance, the last incumbent I found rather scary, my instinct tells me he wants the best for his country, I love his support for Israel too.

So you support the fact that he is participating in illegal and unconstitutional actions, is currently bankrupting many Americans and has engaged in human rights violations of asylum seekers?

I ask, what type of chance would you give a PM that acted like this?

suelld Wed 09-Apr-25 14:43:32

nanna8

We were just sat with a couple of American medical doctors who were avid Trump supporters. They didn’t understand why there is so much opposition to him in the rest of the world. They said he had got rid of a lot of people who did no work but got paid for their services in government circles and that they had witnessed all the waste within government health services and other departments themselves ( didn’t know they had any to be honest, thought it was all private health there). It was interesting to hear that they thought he would save America. They also said the Ukraine is one of the most corrupt regimes in the world (!!) involved with many worldwide illegal trading including that of young girls . Who to believe? They were clearly sensible high achievers. I said Trump may be good for the US but a disaster for everyone else. They didn’t like that at all.

Currently I’m just watching all the chaos unfold. I’m pretty sure Trump never does ANY actual work on ‘his’ policies. He has, as everyone says: been fixated on Tariffs as a ‘cure-all’ for decades. His minions do all the actual working out, whilst he golfs, etc, then he produces the policies others have worked on that he agrees with! As someone said earlier he’s a reality show con man pretending to be a President! He wants two things Power and money for HIMSELF. As for these two Medics being intelligent… Elon Musk is perhaps a near genius in all things engineering, etc, but his emotional intelligence is near nil! During the pandemic there was a group of 800 doctors led by Dr Simone Gold who were all good as doctors but all swore blind that vaccines were poison and you could use the veterinary invermectin to cure Covid, and other wacky ideas!
Simone Gold was arrested in the Jan 6 th riots! Intelligence is many things. Your doctors may have done all their exams and be bright in many ways, but that doesn’t equate to being intelligent in everything! I am hoping that the wholesale mess Trump has made of Tariffs and the slash and burn of the government rather than a careful surgical erasure of ‘waste, fraud & abuse’ will gradually lift the blinkers from at least some of Trumps followers. But I think that unlikely UNTIL IT AFFECTS THEM NEGATIVELY & PERSONALLY ! Then they might start to see what a fraud HE IS. Not to mention Amanda with no character, empathy or morals. The Tafiff maths are badly flawed… proven… Will he apologise? No… the best he might do is blame someone else. Never himself!

suelld Wed 09-Apr-25 14:45:04

* a Man with NO …

ExaltedWombat Wed 09-Apr-25 14:49:59

We need to discriminate between Trump's actual actions and all the trash-talking that goes with them.

imaround Wed 09-Apr-25 15:13:31

Speaking of health care in the US. He is promising tariffs on our medications now. Which we already can barely afford. This will mean more people going without.

I would think that a President who cares about the people would make access to medical care and prescriptions more accessible, not less.

www.usnews.com/news/world/articles/2025-04-08/trump-says-us-will-soon-announce-tariffs-on-pharmaceutical-imports

undines Wed 09-Apr-25 15:18:38

How, exactly, does one check THE FACTS? For the vast majority of news, we only have our chosen media outlet to go by. I think it behoves us all to question, question and question again. As for that wretched term 'far right' - anyone would think a goodly proportion of our country was akin to Ghengis Khan. Time we stopped labelling, stopped believing (often what we want to believe) and started trying to understand

Casdon Wed 09-Apr-25 15:26:43

undines

How, exactly, does one check THE FACTS? For the vast majority of news, we only have our chosen media outlet to go by. I think it behoves us all to question, question and question again. As for that wretched term 'far right' - anyone would think a goodly proportion of our country was akin to Ghengis Khan. Time we stopped labelling, stopped believing (often what we want to believe) and started trying to understand

I think most of us use worldwide media undines, we don’t rely on UK based only sources, if you check out legitimate news sites across the spectrum you get as near to the facts as you are able to?

cc Wed 09-Apr-25 15:31:04

dragonfly46

We were in the US at the time of Watergate and mixed with some very intelligent high-flying Republicans who were convinced that Nixon was innocent.

That's understandable in some ways, the President was a figurehead and people don't like to think that he is corrupt, especially if they voted for him. However it's worth remembering how long it took Nixon to be voted into the White House and there was clearly a reason for this.
Like many others I can't understand what made people vote for Trump, especially after the dubious things that happened during his last term, and most of all after the violence and rioting in Washington when he lost the election.
People I've spoken to tend to put it down to the fact that the Republicans had no other viable candidate, and once you've voted for someone you don't like to admit it was a mistake.

Gizzy48 Wed 09-Apr-25 16:44:42

Our First Past The Post system makes it difficult to vote according to your conscience or, often to see a vote for the candidate of your choice as having any value. A lot of the time we feel more strongly which party we DON'T want in power than which candidate we'd like to represent us.

The fairest system is Single Transferable Vote, and we had a chance to use it, in a referendum when we had the lib-lab coalition, but the big parties don't like it and campaigned relentlessly to squash it, saying it was too complicated (it really, really isn't!) and lying that it would mean people supporting small parties "got to vote again and again". You only vote once, in order of preference, the count does all the rest.

It helps avoid those situations where the vote is, say, 40/30/30 and both the 30s desperately did NOT want the eventual winner; and it helps parties like the greens to at least "stand up and be counted" by coming second or third in a big race and increasing their chance of winning next time.

But, as I said, the big parties felt threatened by this method and the country appeared more polarised than it actually is.

The American method is strange, because election of a president is by candidate and not by party, so although the senate and the house often both fall in line with the winner's party at the general election, that president can be hobbled by losing both houses two years later at the mid-terms (which almost certainly will happen if Trump carries on the way he is right now)

Gizzy48 Wed 09-Apr-25 16:48:25

"It's worth remembering how long it took Nixon to be voted into the White House" - really? Maybe for his first term, but I was there in 1972 and he won every state except Massachusetts. The Watergate break-in and subsequent cover-up was round that time.

M0nica Wed 09-Apr-25 17:17:33

I think as with the move to the right in the UK and other European countries, people are looking around them and seeing the rich get richer and richer while the poor keep getting poorer. They see towns with no manufacturing and no jobs, children with no futures and they look for someone to blame, so they blame the, generally, liberal/left leaning political parties under which much of this has happened.

In fact globalisation came out of the rightwing politics of Mrs Thatcher and President Regan, but the more leftward leaning governments that followed, and that includes the USA followed through in the misguided belief in openess and internationalism, which they confused with the globalising market economics of the right. Remember Peter Mandelson sayng he was: intensely relaxed about people getting filthy rich as long as they pay their taxes. Well, of course they never do. Since the damage done to people's lives happened when centre/left parties were in power, those suffering, have two choices, go right or go extreme left. A choice between a rock and a hard place. Most have chosen to move to the right - and that includes in the US.

The Democrats lost the election because Jo Biden was the best man for the job and that tells you all. They simply have no one with charisma, presence or intelligence enough to counter Trump. Trump did not win the election, the Democrats lost it.

He promised to sort everything out, get America back to work, given how weak the alternative was, it is not surprising people voted for him, even intelligent educated people. In a 2 party state he was the only alternative to more of the same under Biden/Harris.

Perhaps Trump is the antidote to Mrs Thatcher, he is the one coming in from the cold and throwing all the toys out of the pram and starting again

fancythat Wed 09-Apr-25 17:51:28

^^The Democrats lost the election because Jo Biden was the best man for the job and that tells you all. They simply have no one with charisma, presence or intelligence enough to counter Trump. Trump did not win the election, the Democrats lost it.
^

I do think immigration is a big issue too.
And getting bigger.
Even bigger than most even realise.
In many Countries.

In very affluent Countries it may not be as big an issue.
I am not sure I any longer count Uk as affluent[yes I know it prob is in top 10 of the world]. Or the US. from what seems to be emerging from "ordinary" Americans.

fancythat Wed 09-Apr-25 17:53:43

Many, including posters on this site, have tried their best to hide/bury/move on/deceive on this issue.
But it hasnt worked.

imaround Wed 09-Apr-25 18:09:35

It is my opinion only, for what that is worth, that AOC is likely to take on Trump in 2028, if we still have elections by then.

She is the antidote to Trump's brand of division. Her outspokenness and pushing back has to happen in order to bring issue to light. She is exactly what the dems need to court blue collar workers and get those voters back to the Dems.

Jasmine Crockett, Cory Booker, AOC. These will be the people who can best fight Trump. If the old Democrats get out of the way and let them.

There are plenty of future Democratic leaders emerging in Congress, but they are being shut down by old school Dems.

What will be interesting to watch is how many conservatives jump ship. Remember after the 1930 tariffs, the entire country went left and conservatives lost over 130 seats in Congress.

Bankrupt people tend to care less about political parties when they can't feed their children.

Galaxy Wed 09-Apr-25 18:10:06

I absolutely agree that the Democrats lost the election. It is I think to do with the left leaning parties moving further and further away from 'working people'.

imaround Wed 09-Apr-25 18:22:40

Yes Galaxy. A fine example of that is the number of Unions and Union voters who who supported Trump. Which is the opposite of their best interests.

I, and other voters like me, are loudly holding the Dems feet to the fire and condemning their lack of action.

I realize that the Dems do not have much power in Congress, which will limit them for now. But the worst part is the Schumers and Pelosis catapulting to Republicans and Trump on nominations and budgets. They hold responsibility and will answer to that in the next election cycle, if we make it that far.

Iam64 Wed 09-Apr-25 18:25:20

Trump’s policies are likely to increase attempts by people affected, like the Vietnamese, to immigrate to Europe where they hope for better economic opportunites

Bluecat Wed 09-Apr-25 18:39:03

My daughter lives in the USA and, in her opinion, i

Bluecat Wed 09-Apr-25 18:43:17

Sorry, pressed post by accident. Wanted to say that, in my daughter's opinion it's a mistake to think Trump's supporters are all MAGA maniacs. Some areas of the USA are bleak due to the failure of their industries and consequent unemployment. Those people want the jobs to come back and will believe any liar who promises to bring them back.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 09-Apr-25 18:45:46

Iam64

Trump’s policies are likely to increase attempts by people affected, like the Vietnamese, to immigrate to Europe where they hope for better economic opportunites

I suspect that China will offer help to countries like Vietnam and others.