Gransnet forums

News & politics

Unfolding Genocide

(1001 Posts)
Whitewavemark2 Wed 13-Aug-25 13:51:55

BBC report

“Israel has faced mounting criticism over the 22-month-long war with Hamas, with UN-backed experts warning of widespread famine unfolding in the besieged territory.

On Tuesday members of an international group of former leaders known as "The Elders" for the first time called the war in Gaza an "unfolding genocide" and blamed Israel for causing famine among its population.

Following a visit to the Gaza border, Helen Clark and Mary Robinson, a former prime minister of New Zealand and a former president of Ireland, said in a joint statement: "What we saw and heard underlines our personal conviction that there is not only an unfolding, human-caused famine in Gaza. There is an unfolding genocide."

ronib Thu 28-Aug-25 08:41:25

Well Anniebach even if the Palestinian Bedouins are looting aid trucks, the fault will still be laid at Israel’s door! Hamas used to control the Palestinian Bedouins it seems.
When is the West going to step up? Israel can’t take on Hamas, Bedouins, Iran, Houthis and the rest all by itself.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 28-Aug-25 08:58:47

Ten Palestinians including two children have died from starvation in the last 24 hours, health authorities in Gaza said on Wednesday, as Pope Leo XIV demanded that Israel stop its “collective punishment” of the population in the besieged territory.

At least 313 people have died from hunger, including 119 children, since the war in Gaza began and Israel intensified its siege on the Palestinian territory. Last week a UN-backed monitoring body confirmed that Gaza was in the throes of famine and warned that without more aid, increasing numbers of people would lose access to food.

As humanitarian conditions continued to worsen, the pope called for a suspension of hostilities.

“I beg for a permanent ceasefire to be reached, the safe entry of humanitarian aid to be facilitated and humanitarian law to be fully respected,” Leo said. He referred to international law and its “prohibition of collective punishment, indiscriminate use of force and the forced displacement of the population”.

The pope was interrupted twice by applause as he called for a ceasefire in front of thousands of people in the Vatican auditorium.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 28-Aug-25 09:00:22

The children become too weak to cry and lie silent - dying slowly and painfully.

Utterly evil bastards

ronib Thu 28-Aug-25 09:05:51

Send in the Papal Guards?

Anniebach Thu 28-Aug-25 09:08:12

The Pope was applauded by thousands in the Vatican Auditorium ? Surely not true !!!!

AGAA4 Thu 28-Aug-25 09:11:37

ronib why do you keep asking for help for Israel? They seem to be managing the massacre of the Palestinians quite well with arms aid from the US and others.
Are any Israelis starving with their homes flattened and being moved from one place to another, shot at and killed?
I find it insensitive to ask for aid for Israel.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 28-Aug-25 09:15:05

Anniebach

The Pope was applauded by thousands in the Vatican Auditorium ? Surely not true !!!!

Of course it is true.

Don’t you understand that the world is utterly appalled at what is happening.

Of course it is - people have not lost their humanity.

ronib Thu 28-Aug-25 09:17:29

I don’t believe for one minute that Israel wants to carry on killing Palestinians. How can you forget that over 1200 Israelis were murdered by Hamas?
I believe that Israel now needs to work out solutions which incorporate safe borders so that Palestinians and Israelis can co-exist. Never again must Israel be so threatened by Hamas. AGAA4.

Wyllow3 Thu 28-Aug-25 09:29:08

The Oxfam posters I printed out are now out to all Quakers in our county, and I keep a supply for people asking for what I have on my window and offer them

I have not met a single person who is not absolutely appalled by what is happening, and that includes people I would on political points disagree with strongly.

A reminder:
www.oxfam.org.uk/get-involved/campaign-with-oxfam/gaza-palestine-downloadable-campaign-posters/

I'm generally using these two as some aren't quite as understandable: the one with a women and child is very very effective with the "explanation" along side

AGAA4 Thu 28-Aug-25 09:29:38

I don't forget that atrocity ronib as most others don't. It doesn't mean that I can condone the endless killing in Gaza.
Do you believe those people deserve this? Only 8000 of the 63000 killed were Hamas. Many were innocent little children.

ronib Thu 28-Aug-25 09:30:28

No one is condoning the endless killing in Gaza.

AGAA4 Thu 28-Aug-25 09:31:33

ronib

No one is condoning the endless killing in Gaza.

You are asking for aid for Israel.

ronib Thu 28-Aug-25 09:32:45

Yes aid in the sense of a coming together of countries to stop the war and find peace.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 28-Aug-25 09:33:05

ronib

No one is condoning the endless killing in Gaza.

🙄

Wyllow3 Thu 28-Aug-25 09:34:33

Bit bemused why my posters haven't come up, will re-try.

Babs03 Thu 28-Aug-25 09:51:00

Am afraid those supporting Netanyahu and his cronies are complicit in the genocide taking place. And scrabbling around for tidbits of info that blames Hamas or anyone else is not going to cut it anymore.
We all know Hamas did a despicable thing in massacring innocents and are a terrorist organisation still holding Israeli hostages, those who shout loudest in support of the insupportable keep repeating this. We know. But we also know that two wrongs don’t make a right and what Netanyahu is doing right now is not only wrong but breaking so many international laws that quite frankly I have lost count.
It is genocide committed by a first world country with a huge army and weaponry supplied by the US against a third world strip of land populated by powerless starving Palestinian civilians who can’t escape.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 28-Aug-25 10:39:10

Babs03

Am afraid those supporting Netanyahu and his cronies are complicit in the genocide taking place. And scrabbling around for tidbits of info that blames Hamas or anyone else is not going to cut it anymore.
We all know Hamas did a despicable thing in massacring innocents and are a terrorist organisation still holding Israeli hostages, those who shout loudest in support of the insupportable keep repeating this. We know. But we also know that two wrongs don’t make a right and what Netanyahu is doing right now is not only wrong but breaking so many international laws that quite frankly I have lost count.
It is genocide committed by a first world country with a huge army and weaponry supplied by the US against a third world strip of land populated by powerless starving Palestinian civilians who can’t escape.

Absolutely.

I never thought I would ever see such evil committed by a country who is supposedly an ally of the west.

They are no ally of the rule of law, decency or humanity.

Anniebach Thu 28-Aug-25 10:50:18

I never thought I would still see persecution of the descendants of the Holocaust after the world declared “Never Again “

Smileless2012 Thu 28-Aug-25 10:59:13

And I never thought I'd see such blatant and inhumane persecution carried out by Israel after the world declared "Never Again".

Oreo Thu 28-Aug-25 11:13:54

‘Two wrongs don’t make a right’ is a saying for children.
Israel will have no more Israeli deaths at the hands of extremists from Gaza.
It’s over for them and so is a two state solution.Israel would never be safe from missiles and violent incursions if the State of Palestine was next to it.
They brought it on themselves.

ronib Thu 28-Aug-25 11:14:19

It’s about learning to live with your worst enemy.

Anniebach Thu 28-Aug-25 11:14:22

Quote Smileless2012 Thu 28-Aug-25 10:59:13
And I never thought I'd see such blatant and inhumane persecution carried out by Israel after the world declared "Never Again".

Those hollow words were spoken for the Holocaust not a war,
unkind surely to use them to suit oneself

Babs03 Thu 28-Aug-25 11:27:03

Anniebach

Quote Smileless2012 Thu 28-Aug-25 10:59:13
And I never thought I'd see such blatant and inhumane persecution carried out by Israel after the world declared "Never Again".

Those hollow words were spoken for the Holocaust not a war,
unkind surely to use them to suit oneself

I agree with Smileless, fact is human suffering is human suffering, one cannot be weighed against the other. And phrases coined to remind us never to inflict that kind of suffering on another group of people is particularly apt right now.
No group of people anywhere in the world has the monopoly on human suffering.

Babs03 Thu 28-Aug-25 11:34:32

This isn’t a war, a war occurs between two sovereign states, not one sovereign state against a stateless people imprisoned on a strip of land with no human rights.
This is not a definition of war.

ronib Thu 28-Aug-25 11:46:19

Completely wrong Babs03 definition of a war can be between different groups within a country.

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion