Gransnet forums

News & politics

Manchester Synagogue Attack

(749 Posts)
ferry23 Thu 02-Oct-25 11:22:04

Thoughts with all those affected. Quietly attending their place of worship for prayer and reflection on this, the holiest day in the calendar for the Jewish community.

Despicable and disgusting.

Casdon Tue 07-Oct-25 13:35:39

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_by_death_toll
For ronib.

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 13:40:20

Sorry to pop in but the menu seems to be a bit 'mental' just now, and this is the first real thread. Without clicking on the strange posts, how do I report this?

Anniebach Tue 07-Oct-25 13:42:40

The Holocaust was not result of war

Casdon Tue 07-Oct-25 13:55:49

Peoples have been persecuted and killed in large numbers for their religion and being different for millennia Anniebach. I’m not going to argue about it, it’s factual, and largely forgotten by future generations whose people were not directly involved.

Iam64 Tue 07-Oct-25 14:34:22

Yes Casdon but the holocaust carries such significance because of the organised, recorded, well planned attempt to wipeout the Jewish people.
I’m not dismissing or denying the other groups targeted but the Jews were a special case. Dehumanised, othered thousands of years of anti semitism, pogroms with Jewish people driven from their homes

Lest we forget

Casdon Tue 07-Oct-25 14:37:59

I know Iam64, I’m in no way denying how horrific the treatment of the Jews was, and is. I’m just being realistic about the impact that will have into the long term future.

Iam64 Tue 07-Oct-25 14:40:35

I’m sure we have similar views on this. I confess to being horrified though that the holocaust is still denied

Allira Tue 07-Oct-25 14:43:41

There are campaigns to deny it, Iam64 as well as ignorance about it now.

Casdon Tue 07-Oct-25 14:43:53

I agree.

ronib Tue 07-Oct-25 15:09:45

I am not too sure that The Wiki is accurate with its numbers. How would the millions of dead be counted I wonder all those centuries ago? The Wiki has also not entered the 6 million lost in The Holocaust. I wonder why?

ronib Tue 07-Oct-25 15:14:51

Correction The Wiki has listed The Holocaust under genocide from 1941 to 1945.

StripeyGran Tue 07-Oct-25 17:48:40

Think about the Drama Triangle.

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 17:56:59

What is that?

StripeyGran Tue 07-Oct-25 18:05:05

It is a theory of how humans behave. Victim, persecutor, rescuer. One can become the other.

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 18:11:57

So, with the correct input or motivation, people can change from one to the other.

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 18:13:22

And in different circumstances the same person could present as all three, at different times.

Iam64 Tue 07-Oct-25 18:59:07

StripeyGran

Think about the Drama Triangle.

In what way ? I may be misunderstanding but I’ve worked with the drama triangle and if you’re suggesting the Jewish survivors and descendants of the holocaust are moving into perpetrator, I find that a simplistic and offensive analogy

StripeyGran Tue 07-Oct-25 19:59:55

People seem to be getting offended all the time. I think it's an interesting idea. Trump perhaps likes to cast himself in the role of Rescuer.

Galaxy Tue 07-Oct-25 20:01:14

Oh I thought Iam64 had misinterpreted what you were saying, she obviously hadn't.

Allira Tue 07-Oct-25 20:06:25

Iam64

StripeyGran

Think about the Drama Triangle.

In what way ? I may be misunderstanding but I’ve worked with the drama triangle and if you’re suggesting the Jewish survivors and descendants of the holocaust are moving into perpetrator, I find that a simplistic and offensive analogy

What are the Jewish people who arrived in the UK and other countries as refugees and the descendants of Jewish refugees actually perpetrating please, StripeyGran?

You do realise that not all Palestinians are Hamas terrorists?
Likewise most Jewish people are not members of the Israeli Cabinet.

I agree, Iam64, an offensive and a simplistic analogy.

What a day to post that too. 😥

Allira Tue 07-Oct-25 20:08:54

StripeyGran

People seem to be getting offended all the time. I think it's an interesting idea. Trump perhaps likes to cast himself in the role of Rescuer.

I'm not personally offended, but I can tell when a post is offensive.
There is a difference.

StripeyGran Tue 07-Oct-25 21:04:38

blogs.timesofisrael.com/the-time-has-come-3/

I really don't need to be put in my place.

All human life is of value, it's overwhelmingly sad the whole situation.

Maremia Tue 07-Oct-25 21:25:36

Have been out this evening, and will get a chance to read this in the morning, thanks.