Gransnet forums

News & politics

Will the Israeli government be investigated for war crimes?

(167 Posts)
foxie48 Fri 31-Oct-25 07:48:31

"A classified report by a U.S. government watchdog has found that Israeli military units committed “many hundreds” of potential violations of U.S. human rights law in the Gaza Strip that would take the State Department “multiple years” to review, according to two U.S. officials who relayed the details to The Washington Post.

The findings by the State Department’s Office of Inspector General mark the first time a U.S. government report has acknowledged the scale of Israeli actions in Gaza that fall under the purview of Leahy Laws, the landmark legislation that bars U.S. security assistance to foreign military units credibly accused of gross human rights abuses.

U.S. officials, who discussed details of the report on the condition of anonymity because the contents were classified, said the watchdog findings raised doubts about the prospects for accountability for Israel’s actions given the large backlog of incidents and the nature of the review process, which is deferential to the Israel Defense Forces."

Washington Post 31.10.25

The above was taken from today's Washington Post. tbh I don't think Netanyahu or anyone else will be properly investigated, what do you think?

silverlining48 Tue 11-Nov-25 13:26:46

It will be the tip of the iceberg WW, but it’s a start and I agree history will not be kind to Israel.

AGAA4 Tue 11-Nov-25 16:54:41

I have just watched the programme on the IDF. It's good to know that some have a conscience and know what they are told to do is wrong.

Those who have constantly supported the IDF and said they don't kill civilians need to watch this.

Allsorts Tue 11-Nov-25 17:01:52

I think Israel will just get away with genocide, its who you know what matters.

Maremia Tue 11-Nov-25 18:08:04

First reading of a Bill in their Parliament to allow the death penalty for 'terrorism'.

Babs03 Tue 11-Nov-25 18:39:20

Maremia

First reading of a Bill in their Parliament to allow the death penalty for 'terrorism'.

Well, yes, I mean they have given the death penalty to the whole of Gaza, why enshrine this in law when they have so little regard for laws of any kind.

valdavi Tue 11-Nov-25 18:42:07

AGAA4

I have just watched the programme on the IDF. It's good to know that some have a conscience and know what they are told to do is wrong.

Those who have constantly supported the IDF and said they don't kill civilians need to watch this.

Won't change their minds. They won't believe it's genuine. Israel has developed an incredibly convincing propoganda machine over the years.
As happens when you have a "hall pass" from the USA for far too long.

Babs03 Tue 11-Nov-25 18:56:29

And it is this hall pass that allows Israel to put two fingers up to the rest of the international community. Nothing will change whilst the US funds Israeli killing sprees.

CariadAgain Wed 12-Nov-25 07:22:40

Yep....now I've been finding out rather more about the whole situation and it does look like "the buck stops with America". Given the huge financial problems America is currently having = I wonder if we can hope that America will have to "draw its horns in" and stop stirring it like that (though - given that it's Trumps son-in-law that has his own greedy little eyes on profit for himself personally from their plans for Gaza = let's keep fingers crossed that I'm not hoping in vain).

It's incredible to think that a few peoples personal greed (eg that son-in-law) can negatively impact on so many others.

Babs03 Wed 12-Nov-25 08:26:06

I just wonder. At the last election it was revealed many US citizens are unaware that Israel gets more funding than all other countries combined. If more of them became aware of this I am pretty sure they would robustly protest that this money is better spent on domestic issues.

Whitewavemark2 Wed 12-Nov-25 10:32:08

1500 buildings in Gaza have been blown up - just since the ceasefire.

Ethnic cleansing continues apace.

Babs03 Wed 12-Nov-25 10:35:31

Whitewavemark2

1500 buildings in Gaza have been blown up - just since the ceasefire.

Ethnic cleansing continues apace.

Of course it does. And nothing is said about it because Israel got their hostages back so as far as Israel and the US is concerned that’s a job done and to hell with Gaza.

Maremia Thu 13-Nov-25 10:12:17

Two more dreadful headlines about Israel ,Gaza and the West Bank

Maremia Thu 13-Nov-25 10:12:37

Brutality and arson by settlers

Maremia Thu 13-Nov-25 10:13:20

A truly horrible story about the IDF using civilians to explore dangerous tunnels

Whitewavemark2 Thu 13-Nov-25 10:48:43

This

“Domicide” is the word for the purposeful destruction of homes, and there is another for the deliberate destruction of cities: urbicide. The term, which, unlike genocide, has not been codified as a crime in international law, gained traction after the Bosnian conflict of 1992–95, in particular following the sieges of Mostar and Sarajevo.
Targeting cities ensures people have nowhere to return to. “It’s about clearing spaces of those you think are different. And it’s about consolidating your control of those spaces,” says Martin Coward, a professor at Queen Mary, University of London, and author of the 2009 book Urbicide: the Politics of Urban Destruction.”

Gaza is a special case because it is such a concentrated area, meaning the damage has been great. And its people have not been able to leave.
In academia, “There is a debate about the relationship between deliberate destruction of cities and genocide,” says Coward. “I think they are distinct, but they go hand in hand.” (A government minister’s celebration of Gaza being “flattened” was cited by South Africa as evidence in its International Court of Justice case.)

Maremia Thu 13-Nov-25 13:57:57

That's an unpleasant new word for my vocabulary.

AGAA4 Thu 13-Nov-25 14:35:31

Maremia

A truly horrible story about the IDF using civilians to explore dangerous tunnels

I saw that on the documentary by ITV. Some of the Palestinians they sent into the tunnels were very young girls. They did this so that it would be a Palestinian who would be killed and not an IDF soldier.
I think they have had to stop that now. It was despicable.

David49 Thu 13-Nov-25 18:05:36

Israel will simply refuse to cooperate with any trial and protect any alledged offenders. Other countries could apply sanctions, but I’m pretty sure the US will always support Israel. The US caused the death of countless civilians in the Vietnam war, I don’t recall any war crime trials.

Previous war crime trial have been of leaders of the loosing side Nazis, Serbians, Rwanda war crimes

Maremia Thu 13-Nov-25 18:38:20

As long as people in the 'know how' keep gathering the evidence. Amnesty International has been raising funds for a while now.

Oreo Thu 13-Nov-25 22:33:32

AGAA4

Maremia

A truly horrible story about the IDF using civilians to explore dangerous tunnels

I saw that on the documentary by ITV. Some of the Palestinians they sent into the tunnels were very young girls. They did this so that it would be a Palestinian who would be killed and not an IDF soldier.
I think they have had to stop that now. It was despicable.

You saw this on a documentary so it must be true?🙄

Allira Thu 13-Nov-25 23:23:57

Babs03

I just wonder. At the last election it was revealed many US citizens are unaware that Israel gets more funding than all other countries combined. If more of them became aware of this I am pretty sure they would robustly protest that this money is better spent on domestic issues.

That is not true in fact.
In the last year that fiscal reports were issued, Ukraine received the most aid, Israel next with far less and certainly not more than all the other countries combined.

The top aid recipient in FY 2023 — Ukraine — received more money from the US than the bottom 159 aid-receiving countries combined. Some places that receive aid are not recognized by the US Department of State as countries and are not dependencies or territories of any other sovereign country. In FY 2023, these were West Bank and Gaza ($112.0 million) and Taiwan ($136.1 million).

USAFacts.

nanna8 Fri 14-Nov-25 00:39:07

Look at both sides. Hamas and the Palestinians are not lily white. They vow to wipe out Israel, from the river to the sea. Should the Israelis just sit back and accept this ? War crimes on both sides, it is very easy to fall back into the old way of anti Semitism which has been going on for centuries.

David49 Fri 14-Nov-25 07:21:53

nanna8

Look at both sides. Hamas and the Palestinians are not lily white. They vow to wipe out Israel, from the river to the sea. Should the Israelis just sit back and accept this ? War crimes on both sides, it is very easy to fall back into the old way of anti Semitism which has been going on for centuries.

I didn’t include Hamas because many leaders have already been killed by Israel, Hamas is a terrorist organization not a government, accountable but not in the same way as state.

Maremia Fri 14-Nov-25 07:24:23

David, just about to make a similar comment.
Hamas has committed atrocities, but Hamas is not Palestine.

Babs03 Fri 14-Nov-25 07:53:46

I stand corrected Allira and am going back to before the Ukraine conflict. My sources are therefore not as good as those used now.
This was, however, brought up during the last election as something that could be a bone of contention with the electorate due to excessive funding over many decades let’s say.
And whilst that continues no Israeli government is going to take much notice of what other countries think. The US enables their bully boy tactics.