This government has me puzzled

Oh sorry I didn’t see this before I posted.

But this post encapsulates the destruction of environment also, which will be fought in parliament I think.

This government has me in despair.
Contradictory, inconsistent, duplicitous.
Promising much
delivering little.
Meanwhile.....?

I didn't know we had a government. I know there are a bunch of headless chickens running round Whitehall, but I have yet to see any sign of a government.

Perhaps this explains this new Bill.

Monica well at least the headless chickens running round Whitehall won't have to live in cages .

eazybee

This government has me in despair.
Contradictory, inconsistent, duplicitous.
Promising much
delivering little.
Meanwhile.....?

Delivering little? Many of their manifesto pledges have been achieved, others are in progress. 18 items achieved, 21 items in progress, 17 items on track
fullfact.org/government-tracker/

It’s interesting that so much of the information being shared seems to come from the UK’s right-wing press. That doesn’t mean it’s automatically wrong, but it does mean it’s worth being a bit cautious, especially when the coverage has a clear angle. If we’re trying to get closer to the truth (whatever that may be), it helps to look beyond sources with an obvious bias.

Taking the headline “Government rolls back nature protection to boost housing” and actually checking it, the picture is a bit more mixed. The government is changing planning rules to speed up housebuilding. Some habitat protections, like Biodiversity Net Gain for smaller developments, are being weakened to make things easier for developers. That said, it’s not a case of scrapping all environmental protections. The changes are fairly targeted, and many core protections are still there, even if critics think they may be less effective in practice.

If you take out some of the loaded language, there’s a worthwhile discussion to be had about whether these trade-offs make sense. What’s less helpful is when posts like this feel more about picking a fight or pushing a favourite cause than actually talking through the details.

Well, DaisyAnneReturns, the headlines were taken from the BBC news web page - and, regarding the BBC, nobody seems to be able to determine whether they are right-wing, or left-wing.

And if I am picking a fight, it is only with people who enjoy hunting and who are cruel to animals for profitable purposes.

I still stand by my original comment - that it's hard to understand which direction this government is coming from, or aiming for. It is so full of contradictions, and not just in the animal welfare/nature arena.

Obviously it's not confusing to everyone.

You are seeing the issue from one extreme so cannot really expect to agree with either those with opposite views or those working to achieve a balance.

If you come out with phrases such as "people who enjoy hunting and who are cruel to animals for profitable purposes", which implies all people who hunt are "cruel to animals for profitable purposes" you are going to miss the detail that might allow you to be less "confused".

Even the BBC is looking for clicks these days and similar headlines came from our right-wing press.

I’m wondering if some here either are in the government as spokespersons or have shades over their eyes? I’m inclined to think the former.

M0nica

I didn't know we had a government. I know there are a bunch of headless chickens running round Whitehall, but I have yet to see any sign of a government.

Perhaps this explains this new Bill.

Sadly I see the same. Either that or their communication strategy (what communication strategy?) is so poor that it is all happening but we dont know!! 😏🤔

nanna8

DAR yes, I should have typed "people who enjoy hunting and/or who are cruel to animals for profitable purposes" but, dear me, you really are dredging the bottom of the seabed here in your arguments.

Is Halal meat going to be banned? This form of slaughter is extremely cruel and should be top of the list, but surprise, surprise, it's not even on the list!! Now I wonder why?

The problem, Jaberwok, is that politics is the art of the possible. Governments have to take voters preferences into account.

Hypocrisy is a word that comes to mind! But you're right not causing offence for certain voters pre empts, the moral high ground, truth and of course cruelty. The blind eye is a wonderful tool! It's a sad state of affairs.

Jaberwok

Is Halal meat going to be banned? This form of slaughter is extremely cruel and should be top of the list, but surprise, surprise, it's not even on the list!! Now I wonder why?

Of course they should ban Halal meat. I don't know why the RSPCA don't get involved and lobby for the ban. I'm appalled that it is served in schools as it's easier to give to everyone rather than just the muslim children or other religions that insist on this barbaric slaughter.

There’s been some climb down over inheritance tax and farmers so now first £2.5 million exempt. I wonder if this is enough to pacify them?

Jane43

eazybee

This government has me in despair.
Contradictory, inconsistent, duplicitous.
Promising much
delivering little.
Meanwhile.....?

Delivering little? Many of their manifesto pledges have been achieved, others are in progress. 18 items achieved, 21 items in progress, 17 items on track
fullfact.org/government-tracker/

And how many on back-track?

Another one today and not before time too.
They obviously have now realised who it is provides their bread, butter and in fact lavish meals in the Commons restaurants.

No, not the taxpayers - Farmers!

nanna8

I’m wondering if some here either are in the government as spokespersons or have shades over their eyes? I’m inclined to think the former.

You could be right 😂

Madgran77

M0nica

I didn't know we had a government. I know there are a bunch of headless chickens running round Whitehall, but I have yet to see any sign of a government.

Perhaps this explains this new Bill.

Sadly I see the same. Either that or their communication strategy (what communication strategy?) is so poor that it is all happening but we dont know!! 😏🤔

I think it’s a bit of both, their comms team are useless and so are they.

Oreo

nanna8

I’m wondering if some here either are in the government as spokespersons or have shades over their eyes? I’m inclined to think the former.

You could be right 😂

Oh, I've often thought we've had SpADS on GN of various parties!

Jane43

eazybee

This government has me in despair.
Contradictory, inconsistent, duplicitous.
Promising much
delivering little.
Meanwhile.....?

Delivering little? Many of their manifesto pledges have been achieved, others are in progress. 18 items achieved, 21 items in progress, 17 items on track
fullfact.org/government-tracker/

Its not the number of manifesto pledges that matters but what progress, or not has been made on the major pledges on taxation, growth of the economy and house building.

Growth in the economy has been held back by the increases in taxation that mean that consumers are cutting back on expenditure, and are very cautious about committing themselves to large long term commitments like buying a house, which is why the housing targets will not be met, not because the houses couldn't be built, but because nobody wants to take the risk of increased long term debt.

nanna8

I’m wondering if some here either are in the government as spokespersons or have shades over their eyes? I’m inclined to think the former.

Suggesting critics are paid or biased avoids engaging with the actual points being raised. If disagreement is dismissed as propaganda, there’s not much room left for discussion.

Jaberwok

Is Halal meat going to be banned? This form of slaughter is extremely cruel and should be top of the list, but surprise, surprise, it's not even on the list!! Now I wonder why?

You obviously think you know Jaberwok. Why not share.

nanna8

I’m wondering if some here either are in the government as spokespersons or have shades over their eyes? I’m inclined to think the former.

I don’t have shades over my eyes. I just look at the whole picture not just the one given by the mainly right wing press which is owned by people who neither live or pay taxes here. And whose sole interest is in making rich people ( such as themselves) richer. As for this government it dawned on me today that we actually have a government that will say ok we got that wrong, we’ll look into it. If only the Conservative government(s) would have admitted that Brexit was a financial disaster ( which were still suffering from) but, no, they literally had to keep pretending it was a good thing.