Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Let's start a blitz on bad grammar - nationwide

(270 Posts)
Despairing Thu 05-May-11 16:46:18

commencing with obliterating the dreaded and entirely unnecessary use of the word 'up', eg.listen up, park up, first up, next up and the most hideous - meet up.

What I ask is wrong with the correct versions: listen, park, first, next, meet.

Over to you....
'Despairing'
PS Tomorrow the siXth May, listen to most of the TV presenters saying SITH!

Annobel Wed 01-Jun-11 17:42:41

The use of 'grab' as in 'I'm just going to grab a shower' or 'I grabbed a quick snack' says something about 21st century society. It's all about haste and not wanting to wait for anything. I hope I'm not a grabber and I hope I didn't bring up my family to be grabbers!

PoppaRob Wed 01-Jun-11 14:35:15

susiecb
- 'he's a diabetic/coeliac/ etc etc

I remember some of my Mum's older friends would say "He's got a liver" or "She's got a kidney" when speaking of peoples' ailments. I'm not sure if it was lack of knowledge of the ailments or just a turn of phrase that was common at the time.

Elegran Wed 01-Jun-11 12:16:23

sunnysouthport -

No, to sometimes split an infinitive is a sign of literary creativity, emphasising whatever you split it with. To always split the damned things, though, is a bit excessive, violent even!

What a lot of people hate are things which show that the user does not really understand what they are saying - using I for me shows they do not understand who-dunnit or who-had-it-done -to-them.

em Wed 01-Jun-11 12:03:04

Correct use of Apostrophes? Lynne Truss has a wonderful book (mentioned earlier). 'Eats Shoots and Leaves'. Very informative and very amusing!

My problem is this - I don't understand why/how anyone gets this wrong!

susiecb Wed 01-Jun-11 11:44:09

Here's my list- not exhaustive unfortunately;

- 'bigger' when it should be 'larger'.
- 'the' when it should be 'thee'
-'going forward'
-'fell pregant'
- 'he's a diabetic/coeliac/ etc etc
-'touch base' any management speak really

I'm too depressed to carry on now!

sunnysouthport Wed 01-Jun-11 10:52:05

Well Annobel the problem is that although my husband (He got Latin GCE) has very kindly written me an A4 sheet with the correct use of Apostrophes - I fall asleep after the third line.( I just think that communication is the most important issue especially in these times of less society and more the cult of the individual.

Annobel Wed 01-Jun-11 10:34:07

Oh yes, Elegran. The 'you and I' mistake drives me just about as crazy as misplaced apostrophes.

Annobel Wed 01-Jun-11 10:32:36

Hello Sunny Southport from quite sunny Cheshire. Having taught English all my working life, and although I'm an unrepentant pedant in most other respects, I have no objections to split infinitives. It was a misapprehension on the part of grammarians that the two parts of the infinitive should be kept together, using the analogy of other languages, especially Latin. English is unusual in having a splittable infinitive and in my opinion it just adds to the potential for flexibility which makes ours such a wonderful language for literature, and, in particular, poetry.
Try saying aloud 'to go boldly'. Does it sound anything like as strong as 'to boldly go'?

sunnysouthport Wed 01-Jun-11 09:38:43

So you're all going to hate me if I split an infinitive? Whatever! (I'm new and I thought you all seemed so well you know what I mean nice.

PoppaRob Wed 01-Jun-11 09:27:02

Joan, once again you're spot on. I took French and German at school and it gave me a much better understanding of how and why I was constructing sentences in English.

Our national game is Australian rules football. When I was younger the commentators would speak of kicking or handballing the ball. Now we have "disposal by foot" or "disposal by hand". The ones that annoy me most though are the noun becoming a verb. In football kicking or scoring a goal become "goaling" or "he goals!", and in the Olympics or Commonwealth Games they no longer win a medal, they now "medal".

As much as accents can make the language unintelligible, if we all speak correct English we at least have a common starting point. Back when Freddie Truman was commentating the cricket I really had to concentrate on what he was saying and then translate it into English in my head, but when Henry Blofeld spoke I understood instantly. wink

Elegran Tue 31-May-11 10:02:29

On grammar rather than use of words - I find fewer and fewer people are able to use I and me properly - they know that "me and him did this...." is wrong so they overcompensate in other places and say " this is for you and I...."

It is not that difficult After all,you would not say "me did it ...." after you passed the age of 3 so why say "me and you did it...".

Where you would say "we did..." then it is "you and I...." or "he and I...."
Where you would say "for us...." then it must be "for you and me...." etc.

Once upon a time (up to the early 60s) this was taught in English lessons. At that point the emphasis changed to self-expression "If they write anything at all, praise it to the skies" I predicted then that future English teachers were not actually learning any English, so grammar would become a thing of the past.

Yes, all language gradually changes, but the scaffolding on which language is built cannot be suddenly dismantled without a collapse of accurate transmission of meaning.

Hunt Tue 31-May-11 09:28:10

When my husband hears 'seeyah' He usually replies 'Probably not'

supernana Mon 30-May-11 18:48:09

GrAnnie ...I'm known by that name by my grandchildren but, apart from that amazing connection, I LOATHE "there you go" along with "Hiya" and "Seeya" it should be banned forever and a day...and why haven't we a symbol for GRUMPY?

GrAnnie Mon 30-May-11 17:06:45

there you go

Melanie Sat 28-May-11 20:29:42

It's our generation. smile We were properly educated and generations after us were not. I went back to work as a humble typist and nearly fainted at what incomprehensible and wrongly spelled rubbish the Directors wrote for me to type. shock
Also their speech was so poor. How can you have respect for a boss who says, "anythink" and "nothink" and "haitch"? I couldn't. It was all I could do not to laugh, or cry. confused

Hunt Sat 28-May-11 10:31:57

supernana - in a word, yes.

supernana Fri 27-May-11 17:48:01

Hunt...to whom it may concern. Have I made your day? smile

Hunt Fri 27-May-11 17:23:27

What has happened to the word 'whom' ? I can't remember the last time I heard it used.

crimson Thu 26-May-11 12:46:15

I used to get angry when my childrens' spelling and grammar wasn't corrected in their schoolwork, but my daughter is now a teacher and I look after the children one day a week so she can do her marking. It's endless work and she said to me a while ago that she just didn't have the time to correct spelling and grammar as much as she'd like to.Like most jobs [I work for the NHS] everyone is so bogged down with paperwork they struggle to do the really important things. As for my grammar and spelling, it is now terrible [I was going to write apalling but couldn't spell it!], and I'm quite ashamed of it. I do agree, though; I hate to see bad grammar and spelling.

supernana Thu 26-May-11 12:22:26

gma...I concur!

gma Wed 25-May-11 22:29:19

Just thought of something else. When TV hosts say "and we will see you next week" !!!!! NO you will not see me, but I will see you, I could be sitting in my pjs, drinking a beer and eating crisps, so I would not want you to see me!!!!!!

gma Wed 25-May-11 22:25:08

I cringe when I hear sports reporters say "He showed good skill" GOOD SKILL!!!!!! Have you seen bad skill? No neither have I confused

nainnainnain Sun 22-May-11 19:07:52

Marigold - at last! I thought I was the only person in the world who had noticed people nowadays - even mature BBC presenters - saying "thuh end of thuh afternoon" and "tuh ask you tuh apply" etc, instead of "thee end" and "too ask.." Using "tuh" before a vowel necessitates using the glottal stop, which seems to me much more awkward than sliding from vowel to vowel with a slight "y" or "w" sound. What can this portend? ( It can't be good for the singing voice, for a start!)
Gosh, one does have to mind one's Ps and Qs (I mean punctuation and grammar) when posting on this thread! Have I done alright? And before someone says it should be "all right", G.B.Shaw used "alright", (I suppose by analogy with "almost, already, etc.) so I reckon it's alright!
Phew!

em Sun 22-May-11 09:13:11

Becoming more prevalent - 'There is lots of reasons for.......'
Noone seems to use 'There are.....' even when the subject is plural!

supernana Sat 21-May-11 16:48:34

Wheniwasyourage...welcome to the club!