Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

The word is....

(67 Posts)
bagitha Fri 20-Jan-12 11:26:02

I saw a cute picture of a kitten this morning and thought: it looks as if it's sucking its thumb.

Butternut Fri 20-Jan-12 11:24:16

jeni...and that would affect the effect on my decision making.... wink

Mamie Fri 20-Jan-12 11:23:12

I am re-reading Claire Tomalin's biography of Jane Austen and have been reminded that they pronounced join as jine.

jeni Fri 20-Jan-12 11:16:55

I would advise you to follow my advice?

bagitha Fri 20-Jan-12 11:11:00

People often get advice wrong too.

bagitha Fri 20-Jan-12 11:09:52

Ah. Didn't know that. Thank you. But, accidents or not, they are pronounced the same and it causes problems. What I'm wondering is if the American practice of spelling both noun and verb the same way undermines understanding at all. If it doesn't, then what the hell? wink

Annobel Fri 20-Jan-12 11:03:41

Bags , use the analogy of advice (noun) and advise (verb); prophecy (noun) and prophesy (verb). I seems to be an accident of history that practice and practise are pronounced the same way.

bagitha Fri 20-Jan-12 10:58:34

I have to think about practice and practise every time I use them. I can get it right because I know one is a noun and one is a verb, but I still get it wrong sometimes because of 'keyboarding error' confused. Then I'm embarassed when I see my mistake. Which makes me think there's a case for following the Americans shock and abandoning the practice of spelling the verb practise.

absentgrana Fri 20-Jan-12 10:51:00

em In the US, it's always spelt practice, whether it's a verb or a noun. Practise is just regarded as an English usage.

Annobel Thu 19-Jan-12 22:40:27

You get a tick for that,*jeni*.

jeni Thu 19-Jan-12 22:28:17

I was in general practice and I practise the harp?

em Thu 19-Jan-12 21:33:56

How do you feel about practice/practise? Doesn't help that USA spelling and usage is the opposite of ours.
Notso I 'm trying to imagine what you thought she meant!

Anne58 Wed 18-Jan-12 23:21:40

Glad this has been received well so far, I was a tad nervous!

Notsogrand Wed 18-Jan-12 23:12:28

Oh, spellings. Right.

Annobel Wed 18-Jan-12 23:07:06

Definitely! My advice to my students who almost invariably spelt it wrongly was to think of the word 'finite'. Nobody spells it 'finate' - at least I hope not. grin

Notsogrand Wed 18-Jan-12 22:55:05

I think we can all live with that phoenix smile confused

Anne58 Wed 18-Jan-12 22:49:09

Definitely
Advice

'Nuff said.

PS I know that the word is "enough". wink