Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

When is a poem a poem?

(45 Posts)
NfkDumpling Wed 28-Jan-15 18:34:33

On Womens Hour this morning a poet was interviewed and read one of her 'poems'. It didn't rythm, scan or flow at all. This was followed by an interview and the interviewee gave a wonderful description which sounded every bit as good as the 'poem'.
Is it now the case that poetry like art is everywhere? Like Tracy Emmens bed? If so - I'm a poet and an artist!

Anne58 Fri 30-Jan-15 15:40:06

Thank you all, I'm blush smile

Falconbird , don't mind at all! Flattered and grateful, actually!

FarNorth Fri 30-Jan-15 16:01:27

I thought you were quoting a poem, Phoenix. Very impressed that it's your own work. smile

Anne58 Fri 30-Jan-15 16:35:01

Thank you, FarNorth !

Eloethan Fri 30-Jan-15 17:34:07

Phoenix Did you write that? It's really poignant.

jinglbellsfrocks Fri 30-Jan-15 18:16:33

That's really nice phoenix.

Anne58 Sat 31-Jan-15 01:03:57

Eloethan & jings yes I did, and thank you both!

NfkDumpling Sat 31-Jan-15 07:45:32

Oh Phoenix you are a brilliant wordsmith - there must be a way of turning your talents into dosh.

Soutra Sat 31-Jan-15 11:28:16

A poem is a poem when the language is fine
The images clear even if it don't rhyme.
When it's made up of sentences, even though it all flows
You know that what you reading is prose.

Eloethan Sat 31-Jan-15 17:03:23

phoenix Why not send it to Mslexia or enter it for a competition? Not that publication makes it any more worthy but it is a nice feeling to see your talents recognised.

NfkDumpling Sun 01-Feb-15 19:11:28

Perfect Soutra!

Falconbird Sun 01-Feb-15 20:08:20

Any more poems by grandparents? I'd love to see them. smile

Falconbird Mon 02-Feb-15 08:16:24

Here's one of mine.

Grandchild.

When he was born,
I thought for a second or two
That he was my own.
I loved him more than words can tell.

I helped care for him,
Prepared bottles and cuddled him
I applauded when he took his first steps,
Caught him when he fell.

Then his mother found a new life far away.
Communication lessened, faltered faded.
I try not to text too much, cry too much.
I miss him more than words can tell.

NfkDumpling Mon 02-Feb-15 08:19:57

Lovely Falcon. It sums up the fragility of the thread of contact grandparents have.

NotTooOld Mon 02-Feb-15 14:59:17

That's very sad, Falconbird, but very lovely. Here's one to cheer us up.

PRISCILLA AND DRUSILLA

Running down the sunny bank, see the children play
Tag and pirates, you-can't-catch-me, all the long bright day
Pick the leaves and smell the roses, find a caterpillar
Two old ladies in the house, Drusilla and Priscilla
Watch the children weave and wheel, play their childhood games
Smile and nod and sometimes wave, never know their names

Rainy days and sunny days, both are just the same
Priscilla and Drusilla nurse their aches and then their pains
Carers come and carers go, some sweet and some so surly
The manager, a Mr Sid, is loud and course and burly
He sees the window on the garden, says its health and safety
Decrees it must be covered up to stop it being draughty

Drusilla and Priscilla with their view of garden gone
Sulk close together muttering, complaining on and on
They ask for knitting wool and needles, scissors and some yarns
Cast on the stitches, rheumy fingers, waiting for their chance
Take up the scissors, quickly snipping, make a hole, now two
Priscilla and Drusilla have at last regained their view.

nannieroz111 Mon 02-Feb-15 16:00:57

Ah Falconbird ....... My heart goes out to you sad

Falconbird Mon 02-Feb-15 17:11:36

It's not written from personal experience nannieroz.

I see my 3 grandchildren reasonably often but I've read all the stories about grandparents who maybe will never see their grandchildren and wrote it for them.

Not Too Old - did you write Priscilla and Drusilla? It's a fun poem. smile

NotTooOld Mon 02-Feb-15 17:27:05

I did write it, Falconbird. It was originally for the poetry module of my OU course.

nannieroz111 Mon 02-Feb-15 18:04:21

Well that's good news falconbird so happy you are able to see your grandchildren when you wish. Your poem nevertheless touched my heart. Keep up the good work.

I have noticed this forum has several talented "artistic" grans. How I wish I was one of them. Maybe now I have plenty time on my hands, I could learn something new.

Falconbird Mon 02-Feb-15 18:58:05

Hi nannieroz - I liked your comment that I could see my grandchildren when I wish - like most grandparents I have to wait for the mums and dads to tell me when I can see them - only fair I guess smile