Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

grammar question

(293 Posts)
TriciaF Fri 17-Jul-15 11:55:38

about the verb to swim.
Is it correct to say "we've swum in that lake".
Or is it "we've swam " " " ."
I wrote "swum" first, it looked strange, so I changed it to "we've been swimming etc."

Greenfinch Thu 23-Jul-15 09:06:22

I also hate "see you later "especially when spoken by someone like a cashier or bus driver that you have no plans to see ever again. It was once said to me by the receptionist at a hotel several hundred miles from home !

Falconbird Thu 23-Jul-15 09:38:28

Don't like the way people are beginning sentences with "so."
Also heard someone pronounce surreal as so real.

SloeGinny Thu 23-Jul-15 10:28:27

I'm in agreement with Falcon, beginning a sentence with 'So.....' is becoming very common and very irritating.

My real horrors though are the teeth-grindingly annoying 'off of' and the seemingly universal, but shudderingly awful 'should of'.

It's HAVE, SHOULD HAVE!

(Breathe and relax, you can cope grin)

Elegran Thu 23-Jul-15 10:33:29

I start sentences with "So . . ." when they do really have an observation that follows on logically from the previous one. Rather like starting a line of a mathematical proof with "Therefore . . ."

durhamjen Thu 23-Jul-15 11:00:57

I do that as well Elegran for the same reason. Should we from now on start sentences with Therefore?

TriciaF Thu 23-Jul-15 11:24:27

There seems to be a fashion now for leaving off the pronoun before the verb in when writing or typing - eg "Went shopping today", leaving out I or we, or "Saw Mary in the market" etc.
I can't make my mind up whether it's useful or not - it seems to speed things up.

KatyK Thu 23-Jul-15 11:45:38

There is a florist near me who has a chalk board outside which says
'we provide flowers for funeral's, wedding's, birthday's etc.' Every time I walk past I am tempted to rub out the apostrophes.

Falconbird Thu 23-Jul-15 12:36:29

I like the greengrocers signs with apostrophes. I saw one where a potato owned some tomatoes, cucumbers and some eggs.

Potato's, tomatoes, cucumbers and eggs.

Elegran and duramjen - please don't stop using "so" at the beginning of a sentence, language is changing all the time it's just a personal thing with me. My sons use "so" all the time.

I used to teach the apostrophe and we had fun with Santa and his Grotto. i.e. Santas' Grotto. How many Santas how many Grottos. smile

There is talk about stopping the use of the apostrophe. It is complicated and before I taught it I had to look it up and study it quite closely.

Ana Thu 23-Jul-15 12:43:51

No!!! shock

They can't abolish the apostrophe - all sorts of misunderstandings could ensue...

Ana Thu 23-Jul-15 12:44:46

It's not that hard...

mummsymags Thu 23-Jul-15 13:48:44

thatbags just love your alligators.....adopting it if I may?
Anya your ICE is a cool rule, thanks for that
KatyK great comments

I am losing my hearing, to a degree (I hope) so have the subtitles on a lot of the time and find some of the interpretations hilarious. I cried with laughter a few weeks ago when Boris Johnson was called Irish Dancing - now we can differ on pronunciation but that was a beauty!!

mummsymags Thu 23-Jul-15 13:51:46

Ooops.....sorry thatbags and the 'which' explanation - think I've got it now smile

annodomini Fri 24-Jul-15 13:05:11

I have just received a promotional email with this priceless example of a misplaced apostrophe:

Leed's Newest Open Air Theatre

thatbags Fri 24-Jul-15 14:50:44

Alligators will love being adopted, mummsymags smile

Re the which/that discussion, both the examples I gave could miss out which/that entirely as well. That may be the simplest option in many cases!

e.g. I own this broomstick which [insert semi-colon here in stead]; I'm about to fly on it to the next gransnet party.

The broomstick that I enjoy flying on the most is over there.

thatbags Fri 24-Jul-15 14:51:20

instead

soop Fri 24-Jul-15 15:33:50

bags darling, shouldn't that be...the broomstick what/wot I enjoy...wink

mummsymags Fri 24-Jul-15 15:36:00

thatbags I'm not known for using one word when a dozen will do!! Thanks for the explanation and examples, they helped a lot - so simple once you 'get' it. I can't believe I struggled with it now. Mental block. Many thanks.

Purpledaffodil Fri 24-Jul-15 18:16:55

Sign painted van I saw, "Farmer's Market's Organiser's". When I taught year 3 apostrophe use, every piece of writing for weeks was then adorned liberally with apostrophes. We used to call them 'Tadpole picnics'grin

Falconbird Sat 25-Jul-15 07:00:27

When I was teaching the apostrophe on a Business Admin Course for adults some of the questions in the test paper were tricky. I can't remember them exactly but this is an example from memory.

Pluralize and place apostrophes in the following sentence:

The secretarys desk was close to the directors office.

NfkDumpling Sat 25-Jul-15 07:40:19

Mr iPad doesn't help. He adds apostrophes all over the place unasked. We have quite a tussle sometimes when I try to remove them. I just typed Saturday's (as in "Enjoy your Saturdays Everyone") on Mick's Good Morning thread and see? Apostrophes. Should they both be there? Have I got it wrong? I do struggle with them - probably they're used wrongly so often.

feetlebaum Sat 25-Jul-15 07:53:04

I had an ordinary Grammar School education, and I have to say that the apostrophe seemed perfectly logical to me - BUT nobody said a dickie-bird about the 'its' v. 'it's' question. I was in my twenties before that was brought home to me.

"Look at my dog. It's got its paws in its bowl and it's walking in its dinner."
(i.e., it's = 'it is' and 'its' is possessive.) Duh...

Redrach Sat 25-Jul-15 09:35:12

You have all made my day. I have always thought I was the only grammar pedant after losing my dear father! I don't think anyone has mentioned "half a per cent". Grrrr!

trisher Sat 25-Jul-15 11:27:54

It's "there", "their" and "they're" that I find annoying. So often it's the wrong one that is used.
I was taught an easy way to remember-
It's not here- it's over there

Ana Sat 25-Jul-15 11:31:00

And how many times do we see 'loose' used instead of 'lose'?

Drives me mad...hmm

thatbags Sat 25-Jul-15 11:39:42

The one I dislike most intensely is the widespread use of the plural fungi when the singular, fungus, is what is actually what is required.

And as for people pronouncing it funji (j as in jog).... Shudder.