Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Discreet/ discrete. Which one ?

(83 Posts)
MrsKen33 Fri 06-Jan-23 14:28:45

I am doing some writing and I can’t decide which of these to use. Is there a rule, and if so what might it be.

BlueBelle Fri 06-Jan-23 14:30:14

Only ever used discreet

Allsorts Fri 06-Jan-23 14:30:38

Discreet

Riverwalk Fri 06-Jan-23 14:32:59

Discrete is used for separate pieces, detached, individual.

lixy Fri 06-Jan-23 14:37:20

Discreet describes someone you can trust with a confidence.

Discrete is as Riverwalk says, separate items.

MaizieD Fri 06-Jan-23 15:00:36

I'd suggest that if you aren't sure about a word you consult a dictionary.

lixy is correct.

LadyHonoriaDedlock Fri 06-Jan-23 15:06:44

If you keep quiet about something you know in order to avoid a scandal, you are being discreet.

If you are blown into small pieces by an explosion you are discrete (it's the opposite of concrete as adjective).

MrsKen33 Fri 06-Jan-23 15:53:47

So is it ‘They sat at a discrete distance’ and ‘ He told her his problem as he knew she would be discreet.’ ?

Have I got it right ?

Riverwalk Fri 06-Jan-23 16:06:00

They sat at a discreet distance - meaning showing restraint or respect.

He told her his problem as he knew she would be discreet - meaning she would keep the problem to herself.

For the second sentence you need to use another phrase, such as he knew she wouldn't betray his secret, or he knew he could trust her not to gossip.

The two words sound the same but have completely different meanings, so best not used in the same paragraph.

Deedaa Fri 06-Jan-23 16:11:15

I know that DD uses discrete a lot as a scientific term, whereas discreet just means low profile.

Yammy Fri 06-Jan-23 16:15:08

MaizieD

I'd suggest that if you aren't sure about a word you consult a dictionary.

lixy is correct.

Rather than getting the rather sharp reply on gransnet, just type the meaning of one into your computer and then the other. Computers are far more compassionate than some grans netters are getting these days. Unfortunately, it comes to us all.

MaizieD Fri 06-Jan-23 16:23:17

Yammy

MaizieD

I'd suggest that if you aren't sure about a word you consult a dictionary.

lixy is correct.

Rather than getting the rather sharp reply on gransnet, just type the meaning of one into your computer and then the other. Computers are far more compassionate than some grans netters are getting these days. Unfortunately, it comes to us all.

There are even dictionaries on line, Yammy.

Or do people have to be really, really spoonfed these days?

MrsKen33 Fri 06-Jan-23 17:10:52

Reason I asked is that my proofreader seems to have no idea of grammar, and I need to be sure I am right. She seems also to be unable to grasp capitals for proper nouns etc. hey ho!

B9exchange Fri 06-Jan-23 17:17:32

Never trust a proof reader! grin In the medical sense, we talk about a discrete lump, meaning it is sufficiently defined that you can feel its edges.

If you don't want someone to pass on your secrets, choose someone who is discreet!

MawtheMerrier Fri 06-Jan-23 17:27:32

As Lixy and Riverwalk say - NB these words do not mean the same thing.

Callistemon21 Fri 06-Jan-23 17:43:06

Never trust a proof reader^! grin

Someone who doesn't know the difference between discreet and discrete shouldn't be working as a proof reader!

Yammy Fri 06-Jan-23 18:00:02

MaizieD

Yammy

MaizieD

I'd suggest that if you aren't sure about a word you consult a dictionary.

lixy is correct.

Rather than getting the rather sharp reply on gransnet, just type the meaning of one into your computer and then the other. Computers are far more compassionate than some grans netters are getting these days. Unfortunately, it comes to us all.

There are even dictionaries on line, Yammy.

Or do people have to be really, really spoonfed these days?

Well, you don't say what a revelation. Though it is easier if you are not that aufait with a computer to type the meaning in of one and them and then the other.
I think as we get older a lot of us need a bit of help call it spoon-fed if you like.

MrsKen33 Fri 06-Jan-23 18:00:41

Exactly Callistemon

MaizieD Fri 06-Jan-23 18:08:10

Yammy

MaizieD

Yammy

MaizieD

I'd suggest that if you aren't sure about a word you consult a dictionary.

lixy is correct.

Rather than getting the rather sharp reply on gransnet, just type the meaning of one into your computer and then the other. Computers are far more compassionate than some grans netters are getting these days. Unfortunately, it comes to us all.

There are even dictionaries on line, Yammy.

Or do people have to be really, really spoonfed these days?

Well, you don't say what a revelation. Though it is easier if you are not that aufait with a computer to type the meaning in of one and them and then the other.
I think as we get older a lot of us need a bit of help call it spoon-fed if you like.

You don't have to type in the meanings, just the words

e.g discrete definition

discreet definition

The computer will give you lots and lots of correct definitions.

If you tried via the 'meaning' you'd probably get a whole thesaurus...

MaizieD Fri 06-Jan-23 18:09:33

MrsKen33

Exactly *Callistemon *

Is this the same proof reader you were having problems with earlier?

I'm sure any one of us pedants would do a better job grin

MrsKen33 Fri 06-Jan-23 18:50:12

Yes it is. She also crossed out ‘laundry’ and substituted it with ‘ laundromat’. In 1950s Wales? I don’t think so.

welbeck Fri 06-Jan-23 19:02:02

that sounds american anyway.
or are you in america, perhaps ?
i would say laundrette, or if being whimsical, washateria.
but she/he does not seem to recognise the existence of a commercial laundry, to which items were sent.
maybe laundry to her/him is just the items to be washed.
or it is an inanimate online proof-reader ?
all these people who boast on here about their grammar school education. and those who do not, could do a better job OP.

MrsKen33 Fri 06-Jan-23 19:40:03

No I’m not in America ……SW Wales

Elegran Fri 06-Jan-23 19:42:34

Discreet/discrete - as a clue, the two Es are separate in the word discrEtE- just as separate things are discrEtE.

If you are discrEEt with two Es together you kEEp things to yourself with both lips together, and don't shout about them to everyone.

welbeck Fri 06-Jan-23 19:46:00

discreet in more likely to be correct, as it is a much more used word, more everyday.
so maybe when in doubt, use that.
discrete is more used in specialist writing, technical or scientific.