Gransnet forums

Pedants' corner

Me and................

(106 Posts)
CountessFosco Fri 22-Aug-25 16:42:21

Virtually every day, we read or hear "me and my husband/sister/friend etc", even on the BBC [well, that's not really surprising is it], but shouldn't the grammatically correct way be "My husband/sister/friend and I"? Or does the phrase "my husband and I" have other connotations? smile

Oldnproud Sat 30-Aug-25 14:06:41

It doesn't bother me. In fact, I think it sounds rather outdated in everyday conversation.

An in-law, a retired primary school teacher, is forever correcting her grandchildren (and their parents) if they mis-use this, but she regularly says things such as 'Joan went with Bill and I".
The parents love to point out to her that I is wrong in that sentence, but she doesnt like it at all when she is the one bring corrected. 😂

knspol Sat 30-Aug-25 14:01:48

I haven't notice the 'me and my ...' very much but when I do hear it I find it annoying but what really aggravates me is the incorrect use of 'myself' which is becoming more and more prevalent.
The dropping of the 'g' in 'ing' at the end of a word or not pronouncing the letter 't' also rile me especially in newsreaders who I expect to speak properly.

Dowsabella Sat 30-Aug-25 13:58:34

welbeck

This is so prevalent now that I think it has become an alternative form.

Or "alternate" if the American is to be used!!

As for myself (!) I worked with a librarian who used expressions like "Myself went to a different library". It drove the rest of us to screaming point!!

Lizardyoga Sat 30-Aug-25 13:58:03

I agree, and conversely people hypercorrect by saying They were talking to Jane and I. You wouldn't say They were talking to I. Not unless you were a Rastafarian

polnan Sat 30-Aug-25 13:57:07

Argh! at last I keep on and on about putting the other person first,,, how I was taught!

Jacky1947 Sat 30-Aug-25 13:42:55

Hubby and me, me and my friend/mum/sister....sound more normal imo smile

AuntieE Fri 29-Aug-25 15:21:11

It drives me mad too, and has done so, ever since it first cropped up in nineteen-seventy-something.

Allira Fri 29-Aug-25 15:10:51

Doodledog

When I see this thread title I get an earworm of Me And Bobby McGee grin

Meant to quote Doodledog's post

Allira Fri 29-Aug-25 15:10:16

Yes, that's the one, I was trying to remember it 🎵🎶🎵🎵

Mollygo Fri 29-Aug-25 02:31:51

Doodledog

When I see this thread title I get an earworm of Me And Bobby McGee grin

Me and my shadow, strolling down the Avenue, has been on my mind since reading.

Doodledog Thu 28-Aug-25 20:56:32

When I see this thread title I get an earworm of Me And Bobby McGee grin

Mollygo Thu 28-Aug-25 19:01:24

The trademark "Andrews Liver Salt" was registered in 1909

Mollygo Thu 28-Aug-25 18:02:10

Feelingmyage55

Andrew’s?
Andrew’s’?

His too.
His too.

Feelingmyage55 Thu 28-Aug-25 16:19:59

Andrew’s?
Andrew’s’?

Mollygo Thu 28-Aug-25 16:16:39

Allira
🤗🤗
Re the Andrews

Mollygo Thu 28-Aug-25 16:15:44

Allira

Allira Thu 28-Aug-25 16:10:44

keepingquiet

I think if we understand the meaning- who cares about correctness?

I don't understand what connotations you refer to?

Or does the phrase "my husband and I" have other connotations?

As the old saying goes:
My husband and I are deeply moved
By Andrews Liver Salts

(Sorry to lower the tone.)

Skydancer Thu 28-Aug-25 15:19:01

Yes. I hate this constant use of “myself”.

dalrymple23 Thu 28-Aug-25 14:39:37

Misuse of "myself" drives me to insanity. I wrote a stroppy to M & S yesterday following an email which started: "here's reasons". I queried why they were massacring the English language!

These multinationals really must maintain standards.

Witzend Thu 28-Aug-25 12:11:25

keepingquiet

I think if we understand the meaning- who cares about correctness?

I don't understand what connotations you refer to?

Quite a few of us do! And it really riles me when people say or imply that these things don’t matter any more.

keepingquiet Sun 24-Aug-25 10:10:59

Why didn't she just call him Phillip? That was his name after all- we know he's her husband!

Oreo Sat 23-Aug-25 08:37:42

keepingquiet

I think if we understand the meaning- who cares about correctness?

I don't understand what connotations you refer to?

The late Queen?
The grammatically correct way sounds perfectly ridiculous to me.

Georgesgran Sat 23-Aug-25 08:21:36

This is pedants’ corner kq.

Another that grates on me is ‘her and me’. It sounds like a 4 year old at Nursery!

Myself now seems the norm on tv - ‘welcome to the programme, with myself Jane’

While I’m in a roll - stood/sat. We were stood waiting for ages., then we were sat near the kitchen door.

keepingquiet Sat 23-Aug-25 07:58:58

I think if we understand the meaning- who cares about correctness?

I don't understand what connotations you refer to?

Aldom Sat 23-Aug-25 07:54:36

A member of my family uses this form of speech. She's a well educated person in her early sixties. If her father was alive I think he would say something to her about it. I just keep quiet, but it grates on me.