Here we go When - I agree with you again. As I said, I feel Ceasar has been unfairly criticised by some of the 'positive' dog trainers. One of the families he helped during a tour of Britain a couple of years ago are close friends. They had a spaniel puppy who refused to get into the back of their estate car. They said Ceasar spent a whole day with them, their children and 3 dogs and his advice about the spaniel was spot on. They also said he was fun to have around, worked very hard and was totally appropriate with their dogs, and their children. The issue about e-collars continues to cause lots of polarised discussions. I am one of the group who believe there is a place for them. The programme where Ceasar used an e-collar on his pit bull to discourage the dog's continued interest in snakes was very interesting. I agree that Ceasar's work has developed over the years. Just like the work of psychologists etc really. Nanapug, let us know how your lab/collie fits into your family. My grandpa had a spaniel/lab cross when we were children. He was a delight, and the family view was that "first cross" dogs were the best, came without the health problems so many pedigrees have, and usually a relaxed personality. Collie's are such clever dogs, but fortunately seem eager to please and labs are also clever - so hopefully you'll get the best of both breeds......