Gransnet forums

Pets

Alain Delon's Dog

(89 Posts)
Caleo Tue 20-Aug-24 18:10:03

The deceased film actor had asked that his healthy 10 year old Malinois be euthanased and buried with alongside him. He said the dog was like a child to him and he knew it would suffer if Alain was not there any more.

His family refused the request ,and animal welfare organisations upheld their decision to not euthanase the animal.

Do you think Alain Delon knew best what was right for the dog?

flappergirl Wed 21-Aug-24 22:24:52

Of course he didn't know best. Unless the dog had no possible hope of adoption and was likely to starve to death, how can killing the poor thing be in it's best interests. Delon left a vast fortune and he could've easily stipulated in his will continued care of the dog by the beneficiaries.

Delon was exercising his patriarchal privilege, which men are all too fond of. He saw the dog as a possession, not a companion. If he couldn't have it, nobody could. That's not love, that's selfish arrogance.

Anniebach Thu 22-Aug-24 02:11:01

He thought of his grave as a lonely place ,

sodapop Thu 22-Aug-24 09:16:00

That's no reason to selfishly take your companion with you Anniebach

Tuaim Thu 22-Aug-24 09:21:20

A friend of my mother's request that her dog be euthanised before her terminal cancer death. The vet came to the house and the dog died in her arms. The dog was only 5 and my mother had looked after it while the friend was in hospital. We could have looked after the little dog but this was the friend's last request. Still haunts me 60 years later. Funnily enough, I found a picture sketched by a famous local artist in a local antique shop of this little dog as the artist was a friend of the lady who died. It is now framed on my wall for me to remember the happy days spent playing with the dog as a child.

keepingquiet Thu 22-Aug-24 09:27:29

If he knew he was dying why didn't he do it before he died instead of leaving a silly condition in his will? I suspect he was a control freak and thought he could control people from beyond the grave. There are people around like this but they will all go to their eternal judgement I suppose.

escaped Thu 22-Aug-24 09:41:15

Just cos you're dead, you can't be selfish.
My aged aunt asked me to do this. I refused. Lucky cat went to live with someone nice.

Anniebach Thu 22-Aug-24 09:54:12

So he is a control freak, selfish, arrogant, !

Caleo Thu 22-Aug-24 10:50:12

My present dog, a Jack Russell, is a different character from my German Shepherd. My Jack Russell although he is aged, would settle well enough with another person if I died.

MissInterpreted Thu 22-Aug-24 11:13:00

Anniebach

So he is a control freak, selfish, arrogant, !

Yes...

Galaxy Thu 22-Aug-24 11:18:17

I would say there are quite a few red flags if you read the info about his life.

Anniebach Thu 22-Aug-24 11:34:56

I just read some of his life, his sons are very obsessed with money, possibly he feared leaving his dog for his sons to decide
it’s care. Poor man, so very ill.

grandtanteJE65 Thu 22-Aug-24 11:44:49

They were right to disobey - if the dog is obviously grieving like Grey Friars Bobby, then would be the time to have it put to sleep. Not before.

Grannymel12 Thu 22-Aug-24 12:04:13

My gran did the same with her corgi. I was too young to offer to take him (15)

Anniebach Thu 22-Aug-24 12:14:47

Judging a 88 year old man who was dying of cancer I cannot do, he knew his sons he loved his dog, Too easy to judge him ,
we are not emotionally involve.
It’s fair to disagree with the decision he made but calling him
a control freak etc is , for me, cruel .

Spuddy Thu 22-Aug-24 12:21:29

OMG I hate that type of thing! If my hubby and I died before our little cat there's no way in a billion years we'd want to have her murdered and buried with us. We would love her to be buried with us but not under those circumstances.

I'm so happy his family and the animal welfare refused. I hope the doggy was found a good living forever home.

PamQS Thu 22-Aug-24 13:09:44

Our grandchildren adore our cat, and I heard the oldest boy telling him that if granny and grandpa die, he can go and live with them! I come from a family of cat-lovers, so I’m sure someone else will step forward if this doesn’t work out - though the kids will want visiting rights, I imagine!

Labradora Thu 22-Aug-24 13:12:04

hollysteers

Crikey, who did he think he was, an ancient Egyptian?😳

🤣🤣🤣🤣

LucyAnna2 Thu 22-Aug-24 13:12:55

No, not a kind decision on the part of the actor - selfish, imo.
This quite often happens to pets when old(er) people move to residential homes I believe. Sad.

Anniebach Thu 22-Aug-24 13:49:08

Are all older people who make this decision selfish ?

LucyAnna2 Thu 22-Aug-24 14:00:39

Anniebach

Are all older people who make this decision selfish ?

It seems cruel and unnecessary to me, unless the pet is unwell.

MissInterpreted Thu 22-Aug-24 15:10:49

Anniebach

Are all older people who make this decision selfish ?

Yes, they are thinking of themselves, not what is best for their so-called 'beloved' pet.

Whitewavemark2 Thu 22-Aug-24 15:15:06

If you have looked after your dog properly and socialised him as you should have done, he will be more than able to understand that he has an extended family who he can trust and love.

Our beloved dog knew exactly who was part of his family, including my adult children their partners, grandchildren, sister etc. He was entirely happy to spend time with any of them, in fact got exited. Not sure what that meant for our parenting😧.

In fact we are discussing another puppy, nothing decided yet, but it is almost definite that he will outlive us, so socialising with family will be vital, (both adult children are nagging us to get another dog and willing to take him on in the event of our demise)

It is a massive decision, but one thing for sure if we decide to share our home with another dog it won’t be euthanised on our demise.

Oreo Thu 22-Aug-24 15:44:40

Anniebach

Judging a 88 year old man who was dying of cancer I cannot do, he knew his sons he loved his dog, Too easy to judge him ,
we are not emotionally involve.
It’s fair to disagree with the decision he made but calling him
a control freak etc is , for me, cruel .

I totally agree.He was thinking of his dog and it’s distress when he was no longer there, so not selfish at all.Those sort of dogs tend to be one person dogs in any case.

DaisyL Thu 22-Aug-24 16:25:24

It depends on the health of the dog. I am over 80 and have four Labradors aged 12, 10, 4 and six months. I have asked that my two oldest be put down on my death if they are still alive. The 12 year old is stone deaf and has a heart murmur and the 10 year old, her sister has arthritis and is going blind. I am in pretty good health and not expecting to die any time soon but it my view it is the responsible thing to do although many people will disagree with me.

jenpax Thu 22-Aug-24 16:47:32

Hope your dog recovered when you got them back after the op?