Gransnet forums

Pets

Alain Delon's Dog

(88 Posts)
Caleo Tue 20-Aug-24 18:10:03

The deceased film actor had asked that his healthy 10 year old Malinois be euthanased and buried with alongside him. He said the dog was like a child to him and he knew it would suffer if Alain was not there any more.

His family refused the request ,and animal welfare organisations upheld their decision to not euthanase the animal.

Do you think Alain Delon knew best what was right for the dog?

Casdon Tue 20-Aug-24 20:48:01

No, I don’t. I’m sure the dog loved him, but as long as somebody else loves it too, it will live out the rest of its life happy. I wouldn’t want my dog to die because I did.

Gillycats Tue 20-Aug-24 20:50:25

No. As long as the dog is found a loving and kind home he will be fine.

sodapop Tue 20-Aug-24 21:23:34

I agree with Casdon and Gillycats seems a very selfish request from Alain Delon.

Labradora Tue 20-Aug-24 21:41:07

Casdon

No, I don’t. I’m sure the dog loved him, but as long as somebody else loves it too, it will live out the rest of its life happy. I wouldn’t want my dog to die because I did.

👏👏👏👏👏👏

rafichagran Tue 20-Aug-24 21:53:22

No, it's wrong. I am glad his request was not carried out.

NoodleNut Wed 21-Aug-24 12:07:11

Very old dog - maybe yes
10 yr healthy dog - no

Caleo Wed 21-Aug-24 12:27:58

I sympathise with Alain Delon because I had a German Shepherd a similar breed to Malinois, who was very attached to me.
When I had to be hospitalised for a major operation I had to leave her in carefully chosen kennels. When I got her back she had lost her mind.

JaneJudge Wed 21-Aug-24 12:33:15

I think dogs are quite fickle tbh. I think they do pine but I also think as long as they are fed and walked they don't care too much who is doing it. My dog acts like I am no.1 bitch but I've seen her manipulating the rest of the family into thinking they are too smile I'm definitely her favourite though

MissAdventure Wed 21-Aug-24 12:37:33

I was beginning to think the kindest option would be for my daughter's dog to need euthanised, as she was so devoted, and lost without my girl.

Luckily, she adopted by the kindest couple, who adored her, and must have been very, very kind. smile

dogsmother Wed 21-Aug-24 12:53:18

It’s a very, very sensitive breed. But I still don’t think it’s something I could have done. He plainly had to little respect for his fellow humans.

MissAdventure Wed 21-Aug-24 13:27:15

I'd never heard of that breed, but have been watching their training as military dogs, lately.
They are superb!!

Cossy Wed 21-Aug-24 14:19:44

Nope! Glad the dog was “saved”

AGAA4 Wed 21-Aug-24 14:24:20

No he should not have wanted the dog euthanised. Very strange request imo

Anniebach Wed 21-Aug-24 14:27:32

He was 88 years old, perhaps a little confused

Oreo Wed 21-Aug-24 14:28:28

Caleo

I sympathise with Alain Delon because I had a German Shepherd a similar breed to Malinois, who was very attached to me.
When I had to be hospitalised for a major operation I had to leave her in carefully chosen kennels. When I got her back she had lost her mind.

I was thinking along the same lines, and anyway isn’t 10 a reasonable old age for a good sized dog?

Maya1 Wed 21-Aug-24 15:37:15

I agree with his family not to put Loubo to sleep. I have read that they are keeping him within the family.
My previous boy, a border collie was very attached to me but it was in my will that should something happen my best friend would take him. Finn loved her very much. Since he died, she has now agreed to take Toby.
Neither Finn nor Toby would survive in kennels or going back to rescue as they came from abusive situations.
I can rest easy, knowing Toby will be loved and safe.

sodapop Wed 21-Aug-24 16:03:10

Maybe we should all be euthanized when we reach our three score years and ten Oreo

Maya1 Wed 21-Aug-24 16:08:59

Some dogs have an immense will to live. Toby was rescued after living in an awful shelter in Romania for 10 years. He is approximately 16 years old, an Anatolian Shepherd/Lab mix.
If he can survive all that l want him to go on for as long as he is happy and healthy. Hopefully with me but if not looked after properly.
Age has nothing to do with it.

hollysteers Wed 21-Aug-24 16:12:19

Crikey, who did he think he was, an ancient Egyptian?😳

kircubbin2000 Wed 21-Aug-24 17:55:06

Cats pine too. My friend has been trying to rehome a poor cat whose owner has died. The cat is grieving and won't eat or settle. She has now decided to keep it rather than make it move again.

Oreo Wed 21-Aug-24 18:26:52

sodapop

Maybe we should all be euthanized when we reach our three score years and ten Oreo

We’re talking about a dog here, but you knew that.
A dog is fantastically loyal, especially certain breeds and the loss of the loving owner to it can send it crazy or into massive depression.Ten is old age for a large dog in any case.

sodapop Wed 21-Aug-24 19:34:04

But at least it should be given a chance to see how it copes Oreo

Casdon Wed 21-Aug-24 19:38:27

I’d rely on the fact that his family were the ones who didn’t want the dog euthanised, and they are the ones who will be looking after it. However loyal a dog is, with people it knows love it, as they clearly do, after a period of grieving it will settle down and enjoy the rest of its natural life - they live 12 years on average, some up to 15, so should have more life to enjoy yet.

mae13 Wed 21-Aug-24 20:01:46

No - it was a selfish request. Puts me in mind of the ancient Hindu practice of Suttee which required a widow to demonstrate devotion to her deceased husband by burning herself to death on his funeral pyre.