Gransnet forums

Relationships

Don't know what to do

(33 Posts)
JudyJudy12 Thu 20-Sept-18 12:10:48

You and your friends have both only heard one side. I would not say anything as they will support their son and you will lose your friends.

I would be a listening ear but not get involved as you say she has friends and family in the UK that she can contact.

Willow500 Thu 20-Sept-18 12:06:22

I really wouldn't mention anything to your friends unless they talk to you about it and even then it may not be a good idea to let them know you know so much about the situation. It's lovely you're supporting the DiL but it's a bit like treading on eggshells as your friends may feel this is taking sides if they find out. Be sympathetic by all means but don't be critical of the son - after all you've known him all his life and whatever has happened between the two of them you are only hearing one side of it.

Not a good position to be in.

humptydumpty Thu 20-Sept-18 12:01:51

Apologies in advance if I haven't understood your post correctly, but I agree that when you meet your friends you should not comment at all on the situation unless they introduce the subject.

As regards your d.i.l, if she cannot work because it is her husband whose visa permits this, would it not be better to return to the UK?

MawBroon Thu 20-Sept-18 11:57:56

Not questioning anything you say, but isn’t it mostly true that there are two sides to any story?
While you may be able to express your regret at the breakup of the relationship, this can’t be before they mention it and you are certainly not in a position to criticise their son.
Only they may do that as most of us would close ranks and defend our offspring even to close friends.
If their friendship matters to you, keep any criticism to yourselves.
See how the land lies, there may well be a way back from this and to be too outspoken would be likely to be curtains for your friendship.

crazyH Thu 20-Sept-18 11:57:37

Smileless, you must stand up for the righteous ......your friends' son seems to be unreasonable.
You must continue to support the young woman, and I also think his parents should be aware of the situation. It's going to be awkward for you and Mr S when you meet them next week. I, personally would not be able to keep it from them, but then I tend to talk too much. I'm hopeless at keeping secrets.
Isn't it awful when marriages end? It's a good thing there are no children involved.
Good luck Smileless !

aggie Thu 20-Sept-18 11:57:10

Try to say nothing , if you take sides it will not go well if things calm down and you really can't help the poor woman . If you fall out with your friends it won't help either

Izabella Thu 20-Sept-18 11:51:05

I have no idea but didn't want you to think there was no one else out here on the forums. Its hard as really its no one else's problem and there is the issue of confidentiality. I
suppose if they mention it when you meet then you will have to be led by their conversation. Not easy for you .........

Smileless2012 Thu 20-Sept-18 10:52:41

The marriage of the son of 2 of our oldest and dearest friends has ended. They live abroad where he could take a new job to a country, she didn't want to go too for a 2 year period. They've been there for 3.5 years. They've lived in various countries throughout their 14 year marriage as she's always been happy to go where his career has led them.

We've known him since childhood, a kind, generous and loving young man who appears to have turned into a monster.

We are in almost daily contact with our friends d.i.l.; a lovely young woman and have been doing our best to support her. She's all alone, their mutual friends where she's now living no longer contact her and her long standing friends and family are in the UK.

She's totally dependant on him financially as because of their visas, which cannot be changed, he is the only one able to have paid employment.

He doesn't want her contacting his parents, and having seen the abusive and threatening messages he's been sending on almost a daily basis, I'm not surprised.

From what we can gather, he's told his parents he doesn't want them having any contact with her, and that seems to be the case as their only contact with her is on FB and the messages are short, infrequent and kept to enquiries about the children.

My dear friend takes 'putting a brave face on things' to the extreme and has said nothing about what's been going on. Her husband on the other hand when she isn't present, is more forthcoming and what little he's told us, supports the accusations his d.i.l. is making, as do the text messages we've seen that he's sent her.

They are due in court next week as she's had him served with divorce and re settlement of the children papers. We have no idea if our friends know about this.

Her b.i.l. has blocked her from FB and she's frantic that her EH is lying about her to him and his parents, all who she loves, and that they will turn against her.

We're meeting up with our friends next week and I don't know what to do. If they say nothing about it should we do likewise? If from what they say it's obvious they don't know about the court hearing, do we keep quiet? If they tell us and repeat their son's outrageous and false accusations, do we speak up for her?

Today having learned of his latest antics, I am so furious I'm shaking with rage.

We realise if do say anything it could jeopardise our long and valued friendship but it seems wrong to keep quiet when the poor girl is at her wits end.