Gransnet forums

Relationships

Should I say the 3 little words first

(47 Posts)
Workingnana Thu 16-Jan-20 14:25:52

I have been seeing a guy for 3 years we broke up over a silly argument both at fault, we were apart for 2 years my decision because I am stubborn but has been back together for 2 months we don’t live together because of family it’s not a problem and we are getting on better.
Valentine’s Day is coming up and I would like to get him a card saying I love you, but not sure what he would think as he has never said it, he is very affectionate and treats me really well, flowers etc but I’m scared to do it .... advice please

jaylucy Mon 20-Jan-20 11:05:59

Why not get a card that like cossybabe says "I love being with you" or "You make me feel very special" and then see what you get back !

Theoddbird Mon 20-Jan-20 11:15:40

They are not words to be used in a trivial way... If you can't say it to his face then you should not send a card with it in.

Bbbface Mon 20-Jan-20 11:21:34

I’m confused

Together 3 years but stopped seeing each other for 2 years?!

Babs758 Mon 20-Jan-20 11:44:24

I am following this post for similar reasons! Wait until after Valentine’s Day - which puts too much pressure on men and is vastly overrated anyway. Sometimes men indicate their feelings by being there for you, having your back, being proud to introduce you to their friends and tease the life out of you in a nice way, it is not always about hearts and flowers and cards. Such men are rare and can be easily scared off if you say the word and they are not ready to commit.

That said, life is too short so pluck up the courage to say it but only if you are prepared for the consequences!

Alexa Mon 20-Jan-20 11:49:32

Saying "I'm sorry" can irritate the recipient who might not care if you are sorry or not. It is what you do that matters.

Saying "I'm sorry" can mean "I'm sorry to have hurt your feelings please forgive me" which is worse than useless unless there is a stated intention to put things right.

Millie22 Mon 20-Jan-20 11:51:24

Hmmm I'd wait. If you're not sure there's your answer.

sarahellenwhitney Mon 20-Jan-20 12:16:19

If the card actually says' I love you' let the card do the talking and wait for the response.

Mambypamby Mon 20-Jan-20 13:07:11

I’m afraid I agree with nannypiper and polnan - love is love, I love everyone and everything (unless I don’t!) and life’s too short. I always say they don’t have to say it back - everyone’s at various stages of “love”. Then again what do I know ...

Rosina Mon 20-Jan-20 13:33:01

I have always felt that if you love someone - say it. If he doesn't love you and is 'scared off', then it was never going to be anything other than friendship this time. I know a couple who 'circled around' each other for several years before one of them just had to say the 'L' word - and they both bitterly regretted that they hadn't declared themselves years before. Life is short.

Juicylucy Mon 20-Jan-20 14:05:50

My thoughts are, if you have to ask then the answers NO I wouldn’t tell him.
When in doubt do nowt!!.

NonnaJazz Mon 20-Jan-20 14:23:34

How about a card where you say something like ‘I love the way you make me feel’ or something similar....it is less intense than the words ‘I love you’......which almost demands that your partner reciprocates immediately in a similar vein. Too much pressure, too soon can scare some lesser mortals!

alanginsberg Mon 20-Jan-20 14:36:01

Tell yourself - it doesn`t matter - its blown out of all proportion...don't buy into it.
If you say it and get no response is the sky going to fall in on you ? No...
If he / her is scared of the word, that is their Problem , don't make it yours..
Don't just dip your toe - jump straight in...
If they deserve your Love they will answer in more ways than saying I LOVE YOU back because its the `don thing`
If they say it - it does not mean flowers will spring up all around you and music will fill the heavens....
Each of us should be able to say the words or not say them
Life isn't Linear after all ?

Missiseff Mon 20-Jan-20 16:10:18

Had either of you ever said it in the previous 3 year relationship? If not, that's VERY odd!!!!

Tedber Mon 20-Jan-20 16:26:58

Workingnana IF you do love him ....why not say it? Well it is what I would do anyway. Not any rules about it are there? Nothing says HE has to say it first?

If he runs for the hills then what have you lost exactly?

MiniDriver56 Mon 20-Jan-20 16:39:21

A similar thing happened to me and my husband and said it straight away, I thought it was too soon, however we are now married and happy.

Naty Mon 20-Jan-20 22:53:21

I know a couple....the guy waited 4 years to say it. He cheated on her and then confessed. He then said it right after to keep her. Worked. They're married now.

I would question why he hasn't said it yet.
Be careful.

Callistemon Mon 20-Jan-20 23:32:13

He may be planning to tell you on St Valentine's Day.
If it passes without him sending you a card saying that or saying it to you directly, I don't think I would say it first.

Three years is a long time, did neither of you said it the first time you were together?

Did you approach him recently and say sorry or did he get in touch?

Saying sorry is sometimes harder than saying I love you.

I seem to have asked a lot of questions, you don't have to answer.

Callistemon Mon 20-Jan-20 23:32:45

Say it not said it

Namsnanny Mon 20-Jan-20 23:47:33

Ooooo you've piqued my interest MissAdventure!
^ I always wait to see if it's real^
The word always indicates plural. Been a few times eh? wink
Lucky old you! smile

Back to op, I think *suziewoozie puts it best for me.

GrauntyHelen Tue 21-Jan-20 14:17:00

oh for goodness sake you aren't teenagers if you love him tell him !

Blackcat3 Tue 21-Jan-20 23:17:10

Or say....I love spending time with you.....see how it goes! My daughter signs off every phone call to her boyfriend with..’love you’....just sounds meaningless......