Gransnet forums

Religion/spirituality

Is Islam a religion of love and peace?

(207 Posts)
absentgrana Sun 16-Sept-12 10:57:34

Although the three so-called great religions have much in common, I think for both Jews and Moslems their religion has a greater immediacy than Christianity does for Christians. Certainly for many Jews when they talk of Abraham and Isaac, it is as if they are discussing close relatives who have recently died. I think most if not all Moslems bitterly resent insults to the Prophet in exactly the same way as they would resent insults to a member of their family. I know there have been instances of extreme offence taken about what Christians view as blasphemy – that Martin Scorsese film, for example, and that talk show opera thing on the television – but generally they just shrug their shoulders and ignore it. While I am far from condoning these acts violence spreading across the Moslem world, I think we actually fail to understand the strength of genuine feeling generated by such things as the Danish cartoons and the American movie trailer.

Greatnan Sun 16-Sept-12 10:46:21

Come on, Lilygran - do give us the benefit of your thoughts - otherwise, why bother posting? We are not mind readers!

Lilygran Sun 16-Sept-12 10:44:44

Lost for words!

baNANA Sun 16-Sept-12 10:35:59

Reactionary Muslims are to love and peace what Tony Blair is to socialism! Digressing her but just reading in the Times about his big fat property portfolio.

Greatnan Sun 16-Sept-12 10:09:37

Could education be the answer?

janeainsworth Sun 16-Sept-12 09:42:04

The reasons are probably similar to the reasons why for many years Protestant and Catholic Christians have butchered each other in Northern Ireland.
I think the real question is why some individuals are more easily indoctrinated and manipulated than others.

Greatnan Sun 16-Sept-12 09:36:46

If so, why is that message not getting across to the rioters, suicide bombers and other murderous thugs? We are told repeatedly that the trouble is caused by a small minority, but it is large enough to frighten me and the majority is silent through their own fear. It is hard to fight back against people who seem to have no fear of death.
Will the next world war be Islam v The Rest?